flynryan692
Well-Known Member
@MikeD I have one question for you about this response and then I'm done. You are the dispatch hiring manager at CrappedOn Regional Airlines dba NotFlyingOnUs Express. You'll have had 3 dispatchers leave and now need to find and hire the best 3 candidates you can find. Your boss says that you are only allowed to fly in your top 15 candidates for interviews.
Applications close and you are presented with a stack of 50 resumes. You pour through these resumes quick hoping to the dispatch gods that you see a guy with mainline experience that wants a massive pay cut and to be treated like garbage again.
After you wake up from your fantasy, you scour it again looking for a regional guy that is looking for a change of scenery and a lateral move. Damn those major airlines for hiring so much the last 3 years, I don't have anyone that fits that bill.
You're hopeful that maybe you will find some aviation experience on this next try. Perhaps an aviation degree in addition to the dispatch license. Maybe a private pilot certificate as well, experience working for an airline in any capacity, FBO? Sweet I found three! Only 12 more to go!
Ok let's look at the general resume. I see a couple with military service, that's a plus. Now only 10 to invite in. Sweet this is easy! We're almost done!
Oh wait.... Damn it, I still have 45 resumes that are practically the same. Joe Schmo has a 10 year work record and was promotable as evidenced by his supervisory experience. Jane Doe has the same. Santa Claus did this as well! Oh no, the Easter Bunny has the same exact qualifications as the first three. Crap...
So MikeD, you're calling the shots here. You have 45 resumes that are very similar. None of them have dispatch or aviation experience outside of their brand new dispatch certificate. We need to find the best individuals to bring in to interview, but you can't bring them all in to evaluate the individual, in an interview. They are all the same on paper outside of the dispatch school (which we have decided can't be a factor because it's pathetic, even though out of the last 5 dispatchers that I hired right from dispatch school, 3 are excellent dispatchers who went to ABC dispatch school and 2 are completely worthless who went to XYZ Dispatch School.) You can't give any preference to age, race, gender, etc. because that would get us sued and you fired really quick. How do you choose the last 10 to bring in for the interview? Coin flip? Lay out the resumes and blindly pick? Throw darts at them and call the guys that you hit?
I really am interested to see how you solve this conundrum that a hiring manager is presented with every time they hire without giving weight to where the candidates went to school.
I know this is intended for MikeD, but the obvious answer is phone interviews. They cost nothing but your time, which you're already spending on reading over the resume. Nearly every interview I've had for a regional began with either an in depth phone interview, or a quick chat with three or four questions before being invited out for an in person interview.