"being treated like a kindergartener".
I can't speak for Doug's employer of course, having never worked there. But at EVERY flying job I've ever had pilots were treated like kindergarteners. (and not Montessori either where kids do things for themselves!)
I remember meeting one of the Chief Pilots at Comair just prior to beginning IOE. About half the class were furloughed from other airlines... USAir, DHL, United...
The chief pilot told us. "I expect that you will land on the centerline and in the touchdown zone every time. A smooth landing is not a good landing."
Seriously? Did the chief pilot just tell us we were supposed to land on the centerline? Who does he think we are?? Student pilots at their first post-Seminole flying job??
I was deeply offended. Then we left his office and I saw someone walk by in a big, fuzzy mascot suit... it was "R. Jay"... our mascot, on his way to entertain some kids. Suddenly it felt like we were working at McDonalds.
- At another job they required the Captain to fill out a form on my performance every time I flew a trip for the first year.
- At another they required a doctor's note every time I called in sick. (At my current job they actually SEND you to the doctor if you call in sick. Every time.)
- You are randomly tested for alcohol and drugs (usually AFTER a trip... wouldn't want to impact the schedule). Someone has to meet you at your airplane, take you to a little room, and wait for you to pee.
- You are not permitted to eat the same thing as your coworkers.
I'm sure we could come up with a list of ways that we are treated like children. We become desensitized to it over time.
I submit that the only thing that matters in this profession is compensation, and adequate time at home to enjoy it with your family. At the end of the day we're quite lucky aren't we? How many people get to do exactly what they wanted to do when they were little kids?? Nobody grows up saying "I want to be an accountant!" That doesn't mean that it is right when an employer exploits our expertise. Or when they devalue our professional contribution. (I'd love for someone to take the quote from that Great Lakes executive to the newsmedia... wonder how the public might react to having an "intern" flying their airplane?)
I have said time and again both here and in the "real world" that First Officer is not an apprenticeship. It is a valued and essential member of a flight crew. Sure the FO will learn things from the Captain. But if you don't think that Captains are learning things from their FOs... you probably need to take a hard look in the mirror. Don't devalue yourself. It takes a crew to fly your airplane... not a flight instructor and his student.
When you make career choices. Try to make them based on compensation, work rules, and quality of life (including domicile). After the first few hundred hours the view out the window is the same from every airplane (even those you need a shoehorn to get into the cockpit of). So why subject yourself to mistreatment just to fly some desirable metal?
Ask yourself this: Do I live to work? or do I work to live?