[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
"but if you are in IMC you will get into BIG trouble if you deviate from your clearance."
I disagree. Why is it I'm always disagreeing with flyguy?
[/ QUOTE ]
First of all, its not me you're disagreeing with, its several controllers from NORCAL you are disagreeing with because that's who told me that. But since you're the almighty 757/767 pilot who's been flying longer than I've been alive I'm sure you know better than they do.
[/ QUOTE ]
He probably does. Most controllers are not pilots. I am a big supporter of the "Fly a Controller" program for that very reason. I also dislike the title "Controller" very much as they are
not in control. A better title would be "Coordinater."
I've deviated from clearances in IMC so many times ... and I haven't got in trouble. I tell them what I'm doing and why, but I will deviate from a clearance if it's going to keep me alive! I suppose you could call that an emergency situation but I never said the words "declaring an emergency."
The best thing to do is not accept the clearance. "Unable" is a great word. I had a controller try to move me in to a thunderstorm just to let some DCA puke join a practice approach. Not only was I "Unable" I informed the controller of my opinion of his judgement, or lack there of.
I believe my incredibly "diplomatic" response was "You're going to turn me in to a level 5 echo just so some Communist Air Puke wasting his daddy's money can fly a practice approach? What are you thinking?"
The controller was trying not to laugh as he apologized
You may say that everyone has the same priority once they're in the air but that's just naive BS. Someone who is building time should not only expect delay vectors, but enjoy them! After all, you're out there "building time" ....
I have my asbestos suit on for the flaming I'm going to get from this one!