What would you do? (Windshear)

RRPower

Well-Known Member
Some of you guys will know why I am posting this, feel free to add your opinions too.


Your an FO. Coming in to land on 33 in DCA, Captains leg. As you roll out on final (less than a mile from the end of the runway and about 300ft you get a windshear warning. It is real not a false alarm. You call a go around and the Capt does nothing....you think he froze so you jam the power in there to do it yourself, BUT he then preceeds to chop the power again and refuse to go around. What do you do? (there is nothing else wrong with the airplane like its on fire or anything)

Alot of you may say this couldn't possibly happen because who would be that dumb to do that....well it did happen a couple of weeks ago. Luckily somehow they did not crash and ONLY struck a wingtip. Any thoughts?
 
Key up the mic, call the tower and tell them you're missed approach due to a wind sheer warning. If you call the go around a time or two and he doesn't respond at all inform him you're taking the aircraft as at this point you have no idea if he's dead or alive since he's not responding to what you're saying at all.

If he doesn't let go of the controls, don't freaking wrestle for the controls. When you get on the ground get off the trip and call the CPO and pro stands, they'll take care of him.
 
Key up the mic, call the tower and tell them you're missed approach due to a wind sheer warning.

Aboulutely. They will cancel your landing clearance. Force him to go missed.

When you get on the ground get off the trip and call the CPO and pro stands, they'll take care of him.

For someone who doesn't like guns, you sure have a lot of common sense!:laff:
 
Key up the mic, call the tower and tell them you're missed approach due to a wind sheer warning. If you call the go around a time or two and he doesn't respond at all inform him you're taking the aircraft as at this point you have no idea if he's dead or alive since he's not responding to what you're saying at all.

If he doesn't let go of the controls, don't freaking wrestle for the controls. When you get on the ground get off the trip and call the CPO and pro stands, they'll take care of him.

:yeahthat: Sounds like great advice to me :rawk:
 
This is a winshear warning at 300ft!! By the time you call the tower the first time you might be in the ground...much less the second time. See I would have answered it the same way on an interview but this is a different type deal. Plus he struck a wingtip, so the company has to find out. I am merely asking about a pilot that is in a windshear downdraft that is either frozen or defient or whatever but he wasn't going around. If you won't go around in a windshear warning with downdrafts then having the tower cancel the landing clearance wouldn't do anything anyway. Thanks for your comments. Keep em coming.
 
Let me put it this way, then.

You are safer letting the captain scrape a wingtip and/or pancaking the thing into the runway and collapsing the gear while you're wings are level than you are trying to wrestle the controls away from the guy, REALLY clipping a wingtip on the ground and cartwheeling down the runway in a fiery ball of death.

Make sense?
 
Wow. I'm guessing this is a CRJ. Usually, when you get the actual warning it's pretty serious...I can't believe someone would try to land out of that. I agree with John, though--call a go-around out to tower first, if he still doesn't do anything he might be incapacitated.

You're sure this was a warning and not a simple caution followed by a crappy landing?
 
Wow. I'm guessing this is a CRJ. Usually, when you get the actual warning it's pretty serious...I can't believe someone would try to land out of that. I agree with John, though--call a go-around out to tower first, if he still doesn't do anything he might be incapacitated.

You're sure this was a warning and not a simple caution followed by a crappy landing?

That's what I was wondering. Was it a WARNING or a CAUTION? If you get the warning, it's pretty darn serious and get out of there. If it's the caution (you just get the AMI and the single tone, no WINDSHEAR WINDSHEAR! yelling at you), you CAN continue if there's no convective activity in the area. In fact at 300ft, that might not be a bad option.
 
What's the difference between a warning and a caution in the CRJ? We don't have a caution, just increasing vs. decreasing performance wind sheer alerts, both of which we're supposed to go around with.
 
The caution throws up a yellow WINDSHEAR message on the PFD as well as an AMI but no aural. The warning puts up a red WINDSHEAR message, gives you a HI-LO tone followed by a "windshear" aural. It also puts up an alpha margin show your stall pitch and it disconnects the autopilot (3 seconds later I think).

In general you will get a "caution" windshear during an increasing performance situation where as the "warning" windshear comes up during a decreasing performance encounter.

So, this crew got a RED windshear warning at 300 feet and the captain elected to continue so the FO just took the plane with out saying anything? But the captain took the plane back and they landed and dragged a wingtip? There's got to be more to the story then that.

I've only landed with a red windshear message displayed once, and that was pnly because despite adding full power we still touched down. At that point I felt it was safer to "land" then go back up the air.

And 33 isn't a runway you want to mess around on either.
 
What's the difference between a warning and a caution in the CRJ? We don't have a caution, just increasing vs. decreasing performance wind sheer alerts, both of which we're supposed to go around with.

increasing is a caution and decreasing is a warning in the 145 too, FYI :)

AIM chat?
 
Back
Top