What will the "Carrot" be?

it has already passed. this isnt section 6. If pcl pilots vote no, the company goes to the judge with a new 1113c, toss out the current contract and this become the "last best offer." This becomes the new contract and pcl gets shut down. The pcl pilots won the first round in court when the judge said thst the august ask was too much. He was quoted as saying "he didnt want to start a race to the bottom, but if the company came off the ask a bit, he would approve another 1113c from the company ." If this thing is voted no by 100 percent of the pilots, the assn and the company dont go back to the table. it just goes straight to the judge. game, set, match for pcl. The game is rigged in bk and pcl is the latest loser.

The real test is what will asa and the others in section 6 be able to come away with. Delta has created an artificial suplus and new whipsaw model by reducing DCI fleet size, and then shutting down comair and maybe pinnacle. That leaves the management at the remaining carriers fighting to keep costs as low as possible. If regionals start having trouble filling classes in the next few years, maybe more leverage will come back to the pilots. vote in a short duration contract with modest gains may be the best bet. Im not sure. To the L/Pcl pilots credit, they stuck it out for years waiting for a contract that was better than industry average. That wont happen this time. Even if we vote no, it will go through the court and be implemented within a month or two, just so that delta can put pressure on the remaining carriers. Unless you are in the top 300-400 at pcl, this sucks, sucks, and sucks. We lose our pay, we lose our jobs, and we lower the bar without a real way to fight back.
 
FWIW, 6 of 7 FOs I know at 9E are voting no.

The 7th will be leaving within a week for better employment. Which, guess means he won't really be voting...so 6 of 6...

Chief reason among the six? They all, openly, acknowledged the impact this will have on the places they will be seeking employment within the first six months if 2013.

I'm not solidly in the yes this'll pass or no it won't camp, but the past five days of talking to just my small sampling is pretty telling.
 
I'm probably hovering around the no vote myself. It doesn't matter though. If delta doesn't get the vote, they get the judge. Either way it happens. That's what chaps me the most. The game is rigged and will effect all dci carriers, not just pinnacle
 
I don't know. I'm just not a big believer in flow thrus.

Preferential interviews, you bet!

I like the idea of the airline being able to choose across the spectrum of qualified applicants, not just take the next guy in line from a predetermined pool.

No kidding. I'd like to have a shot at interviewing over at Delta, even though my jet is silver and red, not red/white/blue. I swear, I do a good job, even if I've never been a DCI guy. :)
 
Guys...just accept the fact that this will most likely pass. Even the guys that lose their jobs will be getting a few months of pay/benefits and a small signing bonus when it does. The senior guys are taking a huge hit (close to 20/hr I'm guessing) but they are getting a signing bonus of around 26k. The union is making it perfectly clear that if this TA fails, Delta is shutting the company down within 6-12 months, and Delta already has the agreements with the various airlines that would take over the flying. I'm currently a NO voter so don't shoot the messenger. I highly doubt there is a regional group out there that would all be willing (aka 50%+1) to fall on their swords for the sake of saving other regional carriers.
 
Guys...just accept the fact that this will most likely pass. Even the guys that lose their jobs will be getting a few months of pay/benefits and a small signing bonus when it does. The senior guys are taking a huge hit (close to 20/hr I'm guessing) but they are getting a signing bonus of around 26k. The union is making it perfectly clear that if this TA fails, Delta is shutting the company down within 6-12 months, and Delta already has the agreements with the various airlines that would take over the flying. I'm currently a NO voter so don't shoot the messenger. I highly doubt there is a regional group out there that would all be willing (aka 50%+1) to fall on their swords for the sake of saving other regional carriers.

And that's why everyone in the bottom 60% needs to vote this thing down. You're out of a job anyways, and the lifers are going to screw you out of an interview with DL because they are going to log jam almost all the captain slots needed to qualify for an interview while they bring home their 26,000 dollars.

They've screwed you in the previous signing bonus, screwed you many times over with how poorly they run the training department, and don't deserve that 26k while you get put on the street with some pocket change and nothing to show for it.
 
That's an interesting angle.

Think of the "5%" that every airline had that comprises the wack-jobs, weirdos and whatnot having a "contractual" ability to potentially move up when you're probably a better candidate.

Screw that. I want the guy in my right seat to be well networked, a hard worker, the guy who was the best rather than a dope that voted himself a payout and sat around in his epaulets sweater in the warm cockpit as his crewmembers did the heavy lifting.

Theoretically of course.
 
I have no vendetta against anyone at the company be it junior/senior. I just have a hard time voting yes to anything that lowers the bar so much. I am also single with no kids so its a little easier for me than others. Many of the junior yes voters I know are voting to keep their insurance and paycheck for two years instead of a few months. The majority of 200s won't leave property until 2014 which gives most guys here a lot more time to play with than voting no and having Delta shut the place down within the year. That alone makes it hard for me to judge anyone hoping to keep their family afloat for as long as possible. Lots of guys will vote yes, collect the $$$, then try to leave ASAP. If they can't find anything right away, at least they get to stay employed longer.
 
That's an interesting angle.

Think of the "5%" that every airline had that comprises the wack-jobs, weirdos and whatnot having a "contractual" ability to potentially move up when you're probably a better candidate.

Screw that. I want the guy in my right seat to be well networked, a hard worker, the guy who was the best rather than a dope that voted himself a payout and sat around in his epaulets sweater in the warm cockpit as his crewmembers did the heavy lifting.

Theoretically of course.

The problem is that the top 500 at Pinnacle have about 60% of the "10%" (yeah, its known as the 10% there, not the 1% or 5% like you hear about elsewhere). Add to that most of those guys are without a degree and they are just going to sit there and collect their signing bonus and hang on to their captain seats... creating an ever worsening log jam until finally there are no more captain slots available for others to progress from out of the only 405 that there will be end state.
 
So it seems that if any pilot votes based upon some "career progression at Delta", they're got a pocket full of fools gold.
 
So it seems that if any pilot votes based upon some "career progression at Delta", they're got a pocket full of fools gold.

Yep... I'd be willing to bet the program is toast by the time it progresses below seniority #1000 to 1200.
 
I have no vendetta against anyone at the company be it junior/senior. I just have a hard time voting yes to anything that lowers the bar so much. I am also single with no kids so its a little easier for me than others. Many of the junior yes voters I know are voting to keep their insurance and paycheck for two years instead of a few months. The majority of 200s won't leave property until 2014 which gives most guys here a lot more time to play with than voting no and having Delta shut the place down within the year. That alone makes it hard for me to judge anyone hoping to keep their family afloat for as long as possible. Lots of guys will vote yes, collect the $$$, then try to leave ASAP. If they can't find anything right away, at least they get to stay employed longer.

I don't buy a no vote means the end of 9E. 3-4 years if everything lines up.
 
VOTE YES, or:

2012-Movie-Stills-006.jpg


Love the schtick. :D
 
I don't buy a no vote means the end of 9E. 3-4 years if everything lines up.

Bingo. I of course can't promise this, but the wind down will take a while.

In fact, I think they are toast regardless. The selection program will leave the airline with only the deadwood remaining flying and everyone behind them on the street (with a few lucky and deserving individuals making it to DL). Then... just shut it down eliminating the deadwood to wander off somewhere else.
 
I think it is worth noting that we are in a bankruptcy negotiation. ALPA National, if this passes, will sign on the line as well. So, that being the case, it is worth pointing out to the folks who want us to vote one way or another to "protect" upcoming negotiations that you should consider that your National office is the one endorsing this strategy of "cooperate at all cost" ... To the industry's detriment this time.

Cue a unionist telling me that it's different because it's 1113c vs other "normal" negotiations...

There is no way ALPA National is a real union, it's a holding company for a smaller unions. That's why it seems to be failing me. There should be a National standard of compensation and rules that National has so that the pendulum doesn't swing so far from company to company.

We are being told by our union that this is the best deal they could get under the circumstances.

Can someone please enlighten me on this point to: what is the difference in difficulty for other negotiating teams based on a yes no given:

A yes vote gives the company 3 or 4 more years at agreed upon rates and "new airplanes".
A no vote gives the company 3 or 4 years to wind down and pays what a judge will say we should make.

How do either of these scenarios not negatively affect negotiations everywhere else... "damned if you do, damned if you don't."
 
The carrot is just enough for this guy. I'm being forced to get a new job one way or another whether I want to stay at 9E or not. You can go on and on about how it screws the industry and blah blah blah. The cards are stacked against us and telling them to shove it does nothing. They still win. Every. Single. Time. They can buy my vote for $2,000 + 3 months furlough pay and I'll pay down some debt and go on to the next • sandwich. I'm not sure how you logic your way out of taking the money and running when you know you're not gonna have a job either way you vote.
 
Back
Top