You really haven't read all of the posts.
There are really two options.
It's currently set that all posts that haven't been read for 72 hours are thus marked read, so the software is only looking at a 72 hour "moving window" to determine which threads it'll indicate as 'new'. I could reduce that window to 48 or 24 hours if that would be more convenient.
The other option is having the entire forum marked read when you leave the forum topic, and/or log off.