Washington Post Cartoon - Offensive? Bad Taste?

Personally, I think it AWESOME!!

Is it in bad taste? Was Jonathan Swift being distasteful in 1729? I think not.

The fact of the matter is that airlines are late, and they're late a lot. Too much, in fact.

Good job, Post.

Lloyd, just because I can't kick your bad-ass Marine butt doesn't mean I can't try! :p

Make fun of the airlines all you want, but as I said, click it on again and imagine if you were the widows of the pilots of United 93.
 
Lloyd, just because I can't kick your bad-ass Marine butt doesn't mean I can't try! :p

LOL . . . bring it, Sister!!:D


Make fun of the airlines all you want, but as I said, click it on again and imagine you were the widows of the pilots of United 93.

I know, it sucks. But, I'm not going to stop laughing at satire simply because it references an unfortunate event. I can't. If it's funny, it's funny.
 
Okay, so one thing a lot of people here do is pick on the Iraq war.

Should we stop doing so because it might offend the widows and orphans of those who died there?

And let's keep in mind the death toll in Iraq has now exceeded that of September 11 by a pretty decent margin.
 
Okay, so one thing a lot of people here do is pick on the Iraq war.

Should we stop doing so because it might offend the widows and orphans of those who died there?

And let's keep in mind the death toll in Iraq has now exceeded that of September 11 by a pretty decent margin.

Well personally, I don't think the war in Iraq is funny. "Picking" on the war in Iraq, and why we are there, is a completely different thing than making fun of the tragedy of this war.

Hey, I have a great sense of humor, and enjoy satire, but jokes about 9/11 or Iraq don't sit well with me...but man, you can make all of the jokes you want about the doofus and his administration you want - they're nothing but walking jokes.
 
Stupid, but scarily reminiscent of the 'entitlement era' we were in just prior to 9/11.

Yay! I can't wait until a repeat of the "And I demand that pizza. They didn't feed us on the last leg and you probably get a crew meal anyway" (true story!)

Here's a snippet from the Daily Bulletin from the SLC CPO:

Fight for passengers rights? On July 29, passengers on Continental Flight 1669, angry about a long tarmac delay, began clapping and pounding on overhead bins. The strategy got them off the plane--with a police escort. Unfortunately they had to spend another two hours in a holding area before they could enter customs.

The entitlement era is in full swing! :)
 
I think it CAN be found to offensive.

Just the whole let's roll thing i see the possibility of it becoming offensive since it's SOMEWHAT making a mockery of the overheard phone convo that day...

Leave me out of the rest of this conversation though...
 
Stupid, but scarily reminiscent of the 'entitlement era' we were in just prior to 9/11.

Yay! I can't wait until a repeat of the "And I demand that pizza. They didn't feed us on the last leg and you probably get a crew meal anyway" (true story!)

Here's a snippet from the Daily Bulletin from the SLC CPO:



The entitlement era is in full swing! :)


Hey, I'm all for satire, especially about the current state of the airlines and the messiness of flying lately. Don't you think it affects what I do all day? I hear about it a lot, and often "nervously" make jokes with my clients about it because they have to get from point A to point B on an airplane and it could happen to them as well - it's out of my control.

This was on my sign on screen tonight when I got home.


http://news.aol.com/story/ar/_a/irate-airline-passengers-threaten-to-sue/20070814133609990001

The cartoon didn't sit well with me though. Maybe it's because I have a friend who is a captain for United and the captain of United 93 was his best friend, so I kind of feel like I knew Jason Dahl.
 
The cartoon didn't sit well with me though. Maybe it's because I have a friend who is a captain for United and the captain of United 93 was his best friend, so I kind of feel like I knew Jason Dahl.

Yeah and I know a Jew, so the Holocaust is like a personal tragedy to me.

I agree with the "it's time to move on" sentiment.

A quarterback goes out and throws an interception... The next time he comes out, he:
1) Throws another interception, dwelling too much on the previous pass attempt causes him anxiety and he makes another poor throw
2) Drives down the field and scores a touchdown.

The same course of action needs to be taken whenever something *bad* happens to you. You can either be the quarterback that gets over it and does what they can to fix the fixable (present and future) rather than the uneditable (past)... or you can be the QB that dwells on it and throws more INTs. Keanu Reeves called it "Quicksand" in The Replacements.
 
Count me in the "not offensive, but just not funny" column.

Remember, there is no right to "not be offended".
 
Trust me... I lost my share of friends there too. Sure, none of them were "family" but some of them came damn close.

My point is this. We (as a country) have been sitting nice and innocent for a long time protected by our two big oceans. Sure... got to watch out for those crazy Mexicans to the south and you NEVER know what the Canadians are going to do, but over all we were pretty secure. Sure... we had our share of domestic terrorism (with OK City probably being the worst) but over all we lived fat dumb and happy. And then 9-11 came along and all of the sudden WE were the victims. Don't get me wrong. It sucked. It hurt. And it was a tragic loss beyond belief. However, the rest of the world has been dealing with this sort of crap for hundreds of years now. And yet, some how, it is ok to joke (or make comics or books or movies) about that stuff, but when it happens in our own back yard, we've got to think of the widows and families. Maybe some people subscribe to the "eventually it will be ok to roll it into the rest of our history and it will just be like the JFK assassination and the Civil War." That event was SO far out of the norm for what we as Americans have been programed to deal with domestically that I really don't think people know HOW to react to it so the do the typical thing and ignore the 300 pound elephant in the corner and make anything but quiet respectful comments about it taboo.

Anybody remember The Onion headline the of September 18th? They got it right.

That's just my opinion though. But before you go judging where somebody's views come from don't assume they are just talking from the outside looking in.
"Nice and innocent for a long time protected by our two big oceans." YGTBSM Decades of standing on watch with nuclear missiles targeting our whole population, and standing watch for free Europe while we were at it. WWII, freeing western Europe and much of the Pacific Rim. Korea, keeping everyone south of the 38th parallel free of communist enslavement. Attempting and failing the same in Vietnam. Allied with and standing with Israel while other countries that helped establish it waffle and play games with terrorist countries.

Whenever the world has "dealt with some crap" we've been there. As just one example: Tsunami in the Indian Ocean? The UN (rest of the world) holds meetings and pledge drives. We dispatch the military to rescue people and provide clean water and food.

The cartoon was in very poor taste. But you never know if the cartoonist intentionally tried to denigrate the victims of 9/11 or was just oblivious. But the editors that published should know what such a cartoon would mean to many people. So I'd have to put it down as an intentional slight. One that would not have been on the page if it had in any way slighted Islam. We're just too sensitive to other people's feelings for that.

The excuse of "time" is no excuse at all. There are some sacrifices/events that don't get funny with time.
 
Nice, looks like a growing crowd here are on the side of "It's not in bad taste, just not funny."

Job well done JC. . .I'm impressed.
 
Stupid, but scarily reminiscent of the 'entitlement era' we were in just prior to 9/11.

Yay! I can't wait until a repeat of the "And I demand that pizza. They didn't feed us on the last leg and you probably get a crew meal anyway" (true story!)

The entitlement era is in full swing!

Over the years one of the most idiotic things to me has been the incarceration on airplanes of inbound international passengers who were involved in divert situations. While I agree with you, in general, that people are often too "soft" when things get a little tough I don't think that getting trapped for several hours on a ramp in a narrow body airplane without food or water is a case of "entitlement".

While they weren't international flights I've twice used captain's authority to put an airplane on a gate and deplane my passengers against the direction of ops people. There are old people, children, diabetics, people on other meds, etc. who cannot tolerate these ordeals.

We are not at war with our customers. While we've trained them to not expect much, anymore, there have to be limits to what they are subjected to. The "it's not the pilot's fault" excuse only goes so far. The captain becomes the advocate for his passengers once they step onto his airplane. He/she is responsible for the safety and comfort of those people. If the attitude of the crew is that it's war with the customers nothing good can happen.

I agree with John Nance that if the situation deteriorated to the point of passenger revolt there is a good chance the crew was doing a poor job of handling the situation.
 
Besides, aren't we constitutionally guaranteed the right to free speech and a free press, EVEN IF IT OFFENDS SOMEONE?

I mean, seriously, if people are allowed to go to military funerals with signs that say "God hates fags" then why can't we make a joke about something that happened six years ago?
 
Yeah and I know a Jew, so the Holocaust is like a personal tragedy to me.

I agree with the "it's time to move on" sentiment.

A quarterback goes out and throws an interception... The next time he comes out, he:
1) Throws another interception, dwelling too much on the previous pass attempt causes him anxiety and he makes another poor throw
2) Drives down the field and scores a touchdown.

The same course of action needs to be taken whenever something *bad* happens to you. You can either be the quarterback that gets over it and does what they can to fix the fixable (present and future) rather than the uneditable (past)... or you can be the QB that dwells on it and throws more INTs. Keanu Reeves called it "Quicksand" in The Replacements.

Whatever dude. Wildcougar was very upset with the cartoon and I was acknowledging that I found it tasteless as well. I'm done with the subject, and would rather be making my new man some breakfast anyway. Y'all can argue about it all you want. I spoke my piece.
 
Personally, I don't find it offensive. I could see how some could, especially if they had personal connections to 9/11.

In bad taste? Meh, I dunno, taste is subjective.

I don't think it's very funny, as far as humor level goes. The flight crews on the planes want very much to get the pax where they're going.
 
When Toles drew that cartoon he could have chosen Cubans (a bit dated) or Muslims (a bit more appropriate) but instead chose Beamer, Burnett, and Bingham on Flight 93. Now think about this for a minute. Who was in the cockpit when they rushed it. Terrorists. These guys:
20011029jarrah_100.jpg
20011029Haznawi_100.jpg
20011029Ghamdi_100.jpg
20011029Nami_100.jpg


If you are an airline pilot who doesn't get your flight to its destination on time he is comparing you to the terrorists on Flight 93.

It's offensive.

I don't spend a lot time getting offended or outraged, and this isn't Toles' most offensive cartoon by far, but I can see how people are offended.
 
Besides, aren't we constitutionally guaranteed the right to free speech and a free press, EVEN IF IT OFFENDS SOMEONE?

I mean, seriously, if people are allowed to go to military funerals with signs that say "God hates fags" then why can't we make a joke about something that happened six years ago?

As usual, the fact that some are offended, even deeply hurt, comes out to "but aren't we guaranteed the right to offend? Why are you trying to stop us?" And of course nobody is. The reaction to the offensive material is just as protected as the material itself.

You can joke about 9/11 or just about anything you want. However, there are some subjects that may just get you dead, which would be an infingement on your rights.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2007/08/03/BAGVJRCCPR7.DTL
 
The only thing offensive about it is how patently ignorant it is. Tom Toles (the cartoonist) either:

A. Has no idea that the pilot wants to get to the proper destination, on time, just as much as everyone else in the plane.

or,

B. Knows 'A' full well, and is just playing to the lowest common denominator.

Either way, it's just plain dumb. And unfunny. And unbecoming a pulitzer-prize winning cartoonist.
 
Over the years one of the most idiotic things to me has been the incarceration on airplanes of inbound international passengers who were involved in divert situations.

While they weren't international flights I've twice used captain's authority to put an airplane on a gate and deplane my passengers against the direction of ops people. There are old people, children, diabetics, people on other meds, etc. who cannot tolerate these ordeals.

We are not at war with our customers. While we've trained them to not expect much, anymore, there have to be limits to what they are subjected to. The "it's not the pilot's fault" excuse only goes so far. The captain becomes the advocate for his passengers once they step onto his airplane. He/she is responsible for the safety and comfort of those people. If the attitude of the crew is that it's war with the customers nothing good can happen.

This is the point of the cartoon, guys. All I see here is a bunch of Nancy's whining about their 'sensitivity', when the point is how horrible the air transportation system has become.

I am not out there. I cannot say with experience what I would do, but I can see from many TV reports that too many pax are subjected to inexcusable many hours long delays cramped up in an airplane.

The Captain is the Captain of his ship and if you can't do something about this, all hope is lost.

That's my 2 cent rant.
 
Back
Top