VLJ= the end of domestic 121 first class?

scramjet

Well-Known Member
I was reading Aviation Week and Space Technology's review on the Cessna Mustang VLJ (Very Light Jet) and I was particularly struck by the base hourly operating costs of it, which were around $600/hour. Add in some labor costs, profit markup, other associated costs, and this thing is still significantly cheaper to charter than a conventional jet charter. A rough guestimate would be around $5000 for a four hour round trip, that versus $15,000-$20,000 (including overnight) for a "traditional" flying chariot. I wonder if VLJs will eat away at that segment of the flying public that can't really pay for a charter, but are willing to pay for first class on traditional airlines. Perhaps this will open up charter to this segment even others. Maybe I'm doing the math wrong or looking at it wrong.
Thoughts?
 
Aint gonna happen.

The dynamics of the business are only a forecast at this point. There are planes out there that are capable of similar DOCs yet no major intrusion into the 121 world.

Hmmm..
 
I was reading Aviation Week and Space Technology's review on the Cessna Mustang VLJ (Very Light Jet) and I was particularly struck by the base hourly operating costs of it, which were around $600/hour. Add in some labor costs, profit markup, other associated costs, and this thing is still significantly cheaper to charter than a conventional jet charter. A rough guestimate would be around $5000 for a four hour round trip, that versus $15,000-$20,000 (including overnight) for a "traditional" flying chariot. I wonder if VLJs will eat away at that segment of the flying public that can't really pay for a charter, but are willing to pay for first class on traditional airlines. Perhaps this will open up charter to this segment even others. Maybe I'm doing the math wrong or looking at it wrong.
Thoughts?

whered you get the 15-20,000 dollar figure????

A VLJ like the mustang can hold 4 people i believe. For 15,000-20,000 you could get a large falcon or pretty damn close to a gulfstream.

The costs for a VLJ are very similiar to what you get with a normal citation or the like. My firend was flying a westwind and I believe a charter from dallas out to LA for 2 days was around 5,000 for the customer.

The airtaxi market that your describing was eclipses whole reason for being but now that they have the airplane more or less up and running theyre seeing per mile costs running nearly the same as the rest of the small jet charter industry. Its a nice dream and maybe they could have done it when the jets were only 800,000 bucks but now that they're at least double that plus a bunch of other problems then theres no real cost savings...just a slower less comfortable airplane.
 
whered you get the 15-20,000 dollar figure????

I VLJ like the mustang can hold 4 people i believe. For 15,000-20,000 you could get a large falcon or pretty damn close to a gulfstream.

The costs for a VLJ are very similiar to what you get with a normal citation or the like. My firend was flying a westwind and I believe a charter from dallas out to LA for 2 days was around 5,000 for the customer.
I meant overall cost. I got that quote from an industry association, I'll have to see if I can find it again.
 
whered you get the 15-20,000 dollar figure????

I VLJ like the mustang can hold 4 people i believe. For 15,000-20,000 you could get a large falcon or pretty damn close to a gulfstream.

Nooo way, Tex.

A charter on a King 200 from Phoenix to Orange County, round trip, was $9,200 for my company. This at a rate of $1200 per hour.

A recent charter my company did was a GII out of SLC to JFK for a mere $61,000 round trip.
 
Nooo way, Tex.

A charter on a King 200 from Phoenix to Orange County, round trip, was $9,200 for my company. This at a rate of $1200 per hour.

A recent charter my company did was a GII out of SLC to JFK for a mere $61,000 round trip.

This was just a quick list i saw of average prices.

AIRCRAFT SPECIFICATIONS AND INDUSTRY RATES

The following is a chart listing of the most commonly used executive charter aircraft, their specifications and typical industry rates. Take a look at approximate rates as you scroll down and move on to the Quote Page.
AIRCRAFT MODEL
TYPE AIRCRAFT PISTON, PROPJET, JET
CRUISE SPEED, KTS
MAX RANGE, NAUT. MILES
AVG. NO. PASS. SEATS
FOOD/BEV SERVICE
PRICE RANGE $ PER FLIGHT HOUR*





Beechcraft King Air B-200
BE-200 Prop Jet
280
1600
8
Limited
900-1350


Cessna Citation I, CE500/501
Fan Jet
345
1100
5
Limited
1300-1800

Cessna Citation II, CE550
Fan Jet
360
1500
7
Limited
1400-1900


Gulfstream IV, G1159-C
Fan Jet
459
4168
12-16
Full
4500-8000

Canadair CL-600 Fan Jet 459 2900 10-14 Full 3500-4800


I'd have to look to find direct operating costs of a king air to compare what theyre charging per hour but I'd bet its pretty dang close to what the VLJ's are doing.
 
NO WAY...but here are some thoughts.

VLJ = not too much range. Hypothetical for you. Dayton, Ohio to Albany, NY would be a good example for the typical legs going to be flown in a VLJ. Right now people do not fly first class on those flights, cause they don't have first class on those VLCAJT (very light commercial aircraft jet thingys aka: CRJ/ERJ). So its not going to kill that 121 first class. There might be some people who have enough money to charter a VLJ for that trip, but it will probably cost about the same as a King Air, and probably close to the same speeds (no fact there just guessing about the speed). It would make business sense to be more productive. 2 hour trip via VLJ or show in DAY 1 hour prior 18 min flight to CVG, change planes, wait get coffee at the starbucks in terminal C, hop on another plane, 1.6-7 hours to ALB on another CRJ totaling about 3-4 hours burned. Airlines have not looked at the business traveler since before 911, now all they care about is undercutting their competitor by $1 a ticket so Bob and Suzie can go see Uncle Buck in Albany for 58 dollars a ticket.
(wow that got off track)

I don't think the airlines really care about first class or coach on flights within the range of a VLJ, those are all run by RJs feeding the hub.

ON ANOTHER VLJ topic...

I just hope, pray, burn candles, play Ouija, and other non secular rituals, that the VLJs don't do to Corporate Pilot Pay what the RJs did to Airline Pilot pay.

PS GO AMR PILOTS GET THAT 30%
 
So everyone so far seems in disagreement with that premise.

As far as the performance, the Mustang has a cruise around .60 Mach, so not really any competition to the "big boys." I'm not sure what the others have in that regard (such as the Eclipse, etc).
 
If userfees become a reality, video might have killed the radio star, and userfees will have killed the VLJ before they even got off the ground!
 
Take a look at approximate rates as you scroll down and move on to the Quote Page.

My point was you can not get a Gulfstream for those amounts mentioned. You cant even get a King Air 200.

The King Air trip from Phoenix to Orange County, California was a round trip at a rate of $1200 per hour. Dont think the trip would cost only the flight hours there and back. The total off the invoice was $9175.60 round trip. This included $579 in excise tax, $200 in ramp fees, and $655 in a fuel charge.

$5000 for a 4 hour trip to be quite blunt, is cheap in the charter world. Two years ago we chartered a PC12 out of Million Air in Salt Lake City and flew it to Jackson Hole, WY for $8000 round trip. The flight wasnt more than an hour or so.

Most VLJ operators are talking about the pay-per-mile mode as opposed to chartering the entire aircraft.

Will it work? Stay tuned..
 
I just left the cessna factory, and they do not refer to the mustang as a VLJ, b/c it is not. If you look at the Eclipse, it has the same range as a King Air, but faster. But if you look at the weights it does not even come close. The VLJ jet market, will be a dissapointment, to the people that want one to save money. Those planes are going after the people that want to say I own a jet. Not I flew in a Eclipse to this meeting. As for the mustang, it has the better range and more weight then a King Air, and the cost is alot higher then the Eclispes. As for the first class, it is hard enough to get a company to pick up and $2000 dollar First Class ticket across county, so how are they going to approve a $5000 jet that needs three fuel stops.
 
HERE'S MY PREDICTION:

VLJ's will do the same thing to aviation as fractional ownership has done in the last ten years ---> EXPLODE!

Many years ago, flying on a private jet meant that you or your company OWNED a $30 million dollar jet, paid for all the fuel, hired pilots to fly, paid for maintenance, and PAID for all the ownership costs associated with owning a plane. VERY EXPENSIVE!
Then came NetJets and other fractionals. Well, a 1/16 share of a $30 million dollar jet is a lot more affordable for A LOT more people. And you just paid an hourly fee when you went flying.

Well... what happens you start selling 1/16th shares of a $1.6 million dollar jet (That's $100,000 for an ownership share in a jet). Now A WHOLE LOT MORE people can start owning private jets. And with operating expenses similar to a few first class tickets per trip, you can start seeing private jet passengers from the upper middle class. I predict the growth in the VLJ market will be at an even faster pace than the growth we saw in the fractional ownership market over the past several years!
 
I predict the growth in the VLJ market will be at an even faster pace than the growth we saw in the fractional ownership market over the past several years!

In order for that to happen the 'air taxi' market (i.e. Dayjet) would have to flourish, and with per mile costs as high as they are now ($3-4?) I really, really doubt it.

Go here and click on 'Eclipse vs. Mustang', I found it interesting
http://www.eclipsecritic.net/

Also, go here if you want some good opinons on why the eclipse and their whole 'Air Taxi' high volume/low price propaganda is BS
http://www.eclipseaviationcritic.blogspot.com/
 
Many people see the lower initial purchase price of these new VLJs as a way in to the jet owner club. I believe that once they start realizing the real costs of owning these fun little guys they will be less excited about things. Insurance for an inexperienced pilot flying a single pilot jet will be incredibly expensive. It will also hurt big time when the first major repair is needed. Landing fees, hangar rental, recurrent training and a host of other costs will continue the need for big cash outlays.

I suspect that there will be an initial enthusiasm to buy these new jets, but for the person that is only interested in convenience, saving money or to justify their ownership of a VLJ over typical first class fares, they will be disappointed. I don't think the airlines have much to worry about there.

Now the question of safety and these low time owner pilots? That will be interesting to observe. Hopefully I won't run into one of these guys / gals at FL350.
 
If userfees become a reality, video might have killed the radio star, and userfees will have killed the VLJ before they even got off the ground!

In consideration of that comment, if someone has enough money to purchase a VLJ outright, the user fee issue is insignificant to the total financial picture of the VLJ owner.

I would rather fly my own plane than sit in first class on an airline any day domestically. It is all about convienence: go when I want, no TSA (don't have to be strip searched any more), and enjoying the ride.
 
HERE'S MY PREDICTION:

VLJ's will do the same thing to aviation as fractional ownership has done in the last ten years ---> EXPLODE!

Many years ago, flying on a private jet meant that you or your company OWNED a $30 million dollar jet, paid for all the fuel, hired pilots to fly, paid for maintenance, and PAID for all the ownership costs associated with owning a plane. VERY EXPENSIVE!

I don't believe they are going to add up to all the hype. I also do not see the market for as many of them as they are predicting. However, they will appeal to many in the high end piston twin market and "some" charter operators. I don't see them making the impact that the fractionals have made in the first class cabin. Airlines have made press releases stating that the fracs have made an impact. 20 years ago $30M would get you a GIII, but there have always been Citations and Lears under the $4Mil range. I also don’t think they will be well received in the flight levels.

Well... what happens you start selling 1/16th shares of a $1.6 million dollar jet (That's $100,000 for an ownership share in a jet). Now A WHOLE LOT MORE people can start owning private jets. And with operating expenses similar to a few first class tickets per trip, you can start seeing private jet passengers from the upper middle class. I predict the growth in the VLJ market will be at an even faster pace than the growth we saw in the fractional ownership market over the past several years!

You can already get access to much more capable jets for 100K with the fractional provided jet card programs. For approximately the same price you can fly a Citation Ultra with 7 pax faster and farther than any of the VLJs.
 
saving money or to justify their ownership of a VLJ over typical first class fares


Any owner of a truly high performance vehicle is not really interested in the "cost savings" of that vehicle. If you can truly afford to buy it, the upkeep is a moot point. The operation of that vehicle needs to be safe and smart though, I agree.

They may fill a small niche, but I don't think they will be all over the sky.
 
......no TSA (don't have to be strip searched any more).....




I thought you girls liked getting the treatment from those TSA boys that look like Brad Pitt and Johnny Depp?

I wouldn't mind a good patdown from a Angelina Jolie TSA type. Problem is, most of the ones that give me the once over look like Rosie O'Donnell - or worse.
 
Not to start a fight, but you might want to look at the source that is providing you with that information.
http://www.eclipse[b]CRITIC[/b].net/
Not saying it is bad or incorrect, but it is very easy to skew facts to make your airplane look good.

My whole point is there are going to be THOUSANDS UPON THOUSANDS of VLJ's flying, and they will do to the private jet market what fractional ownership did over the past 10 years. Not saying Eclipse is better than the Mustang (I know it's not), but at $1.6 million dollars, a 1/16 share is very affordable. And although none of us know the true operating costs, I can guarentee you the Eclipse has lower operating costs than a CJ1, and that is ultimately the "entry level jet." Lower operating costs means more people will fly them. And while I don't see air taxi necessary exploding, I am sure it will have its niche.

Some other good information:
Eclipse had over 2,350 orders as of November 2005 (That was atleast 18 months ago!). That's not including numbers of VLJ's ordered from Adam Aircraft, Honda, Piper, Cessna, etc...

To put that into perspective, approximately 7600 Cessna-152's have been produced during all the years it was on the market. And that was one of the top 5-10 general aviation aircraft when it comes to number produced. While I cannot find exact numbers, I am pretty sure in just a few years it will be one of the top 5 passenger jets ever produced (only behind the 737 and A320).
 
If you can truly afford to buy it, the upkeep is a moot point.



Even rich folks can over spend. Look at how many fortunes have died at the hands of stupid people. The rich that stay rich do so by making smart decisions with their money. That's precisely why I am not rich. :laff:
 
Any owner of a truly high performance vehicle is not really interested in the "cost savings" of that vehicle. If you can truly afford to buy it, the upkeep is a moot point. The operation of that vehicle needs to be safe and smart though, I agree.

They may fill a small niche, but I don't think they will be all over the sky.

I tend to agree with this sentiment because it speaks to existing practicalities among people who also own very expensive homes, cars, etc - if you have a 4.8 million dollar mansion, chances are you don't worry a hell of a lot about the mortgage or the taxes on the place. Sort of a 'if you have to ask, you can't afford it'-type-thing.

Mustang isn't a VLJ according to Cessna and everything I've read. Cessna's not a dumb company, either - they do book orders and deposits before they build the things, y'know, and they've received a bunch of orders already - so there's definitely a market for them.

I think part of what may be driving this market is the cost of time and efficiency to the traveler.
 
Not to start a fight, but you might want to look at the source that is providing you with that information.
http://www.eclipseCRITIC.net/
Not saying it is bad or incorrect, but it is very easy to skew facts to make your airplane look good.

My whole point is there are going to be THOUSANDS UPON THOUSANDS of VLJ's flying, and they will do to the private jet market what fractional ownership did over the past 10 years.

Some other good information:
Eclipse had over 2,350 orders as of November 2005 (That was atleast 18 months ago!).

I can't argue with any of that...I just won't :)

You are right that the CRITIC website is what it is, but it is nessisary when people are being told that Eclipse has 2,000+ orders. Almost everything you said was spoken by eclipse. If we are going to debate anything we both have to find 3rd party sources (like the market predictions that state 1000s+ of VLJ won't be flying soon) but thats too much work right now.
 
Back
Top