very bad news from near tulsa..

exleardriver

Well-Known Member
a new student called me early this am about going with him to tulsa in his c-177rg to pick up his new c-t210, but i didn't feel well, so didn't answer the call. i owned a c-t210 a dozen years ago he had been advised and he needed a number of hours from his insurance company with an instructor. at any rate, he went on ahead without me in his plane, carrying along his wife and father. arriving in tulsa, he apparently got a 'quick' high-performance sign-off and set off on a return flight to little rock. i called him at 1 pm just before he left to acknowledge his call and that we would work together this week and next to finish the hours requirement, etc.

they apparently departed shortly thereafter..he experienced some problem with the aircraft and tried to return to tulsa. losing altitude the plane apparently hit power lines and caught fire. his wife and father were killed in the crash/fire, but i understand he was pulled alive from the wreckage. i suppose i would have flown the aircraft back and he would have followed in his c-177rg and we could have done his endorsement back in little rock.

you can imagine how badly right now that i wish i'd been able to take that call, folks.. :(
 
Very sorry to hear that. My thoughts and prayers go out to you all. Let me know if I can help in any way.
 
Very sorry to hear that. My thoughts and prayers go out to you all. Let me know if I can help in any way.

thank you for the reply, mhcasey..hoping to hear more information from those in the community that work near tulsa. i've seen too many die in this profession..probably why i'm a particularly regimented, procedural instrument instructor. although i would stress that i'm almost 100% certain that weather was no factor here..pretty sure it was cavu as in little rock today.
 
Wow. What a tradgedy.

I've been fortunate enough to not lose anyone I personally know to an aviation accident, but I've only been doing this for four years. I'm sure it will happen sooner or later. I hope it never hits as close to me as it did to you today.

Very sorry to hear all this.
 
Sad news indeed EXLE..., but it could've easily been you also. It sucks to have to hear/read incidents like this and I've been fortunate enough to not know anyone personally involved in an accident, but the aviation community is small and the impact can be wide spread.

Pac Man
 
I was landing at RVS when it happened, they closed the airport and sent me off elsewhere, btw I dint think the plane caught on fire, It looked like to me the power lines started some brush fires though. After looking at the crash site, Im amazed anyone lived through it.
 
Very sorry to hear that news. As previously stated, don't blame yourself. You had no way of knowing this would happen.
 
Sorry to hear about this, but like it was stated above you can't put any blame on yourself. You're realized that you were'nt 100% and shouldn't fly.
 
Sad situation indeed, I landed about 10 minutes before this happened and the weather was fine, reports are that there was electrical problems and he was returning back to RVS. As fly_unity said, I think they hit powerlines which caused a brush fire, I don't think those who perished would have suffered. And exleardriver, as others have said, there is no way to know what was going to happen, it's not your fault. RIP to those who didn't make it. :(
 
I'm about 50 miles away from TUL, in SWO, and I haven't heard anything about it yet.

Very sorry to hear that, but as Steve said, this is NOT your fault.

Fly Safe
 
thanks, folks..i appreciate it. it's pretty hard not to second-guess my choice not to answer the phone..going through a hard divorce right now, i didn't have anything scheduled for yesterday just so i could lay around and lick my wounds. still, i appreciate it. certainly my prayers go out to the family as well. it just makes you sick. this isn't the first i've seen it flying professionally 15 years and won't be the last, unfortunately. thanks to you guys near tulsa for the extra information - i had been told the plane burned. nice to know that perhaps it was impact forces instead that claimed lives. .some consolation.
 
thanks, folks..i appreciate it. it's pretty hard not to second-guess my choice not to answer the phone..
Don't.

You made a decision to not answer a telephone call from an unknown person while you were not feeling well.

You know that a T-210 is a lot of airplane compared to a Cardinal and a big step up. The phone call you received was from a cetificated pilot who should have known that as well, but nevertheless made a series of bad choices with unfortunately tragic results.

Feeling bad about the tragedy is understandable. We all feel that. But you can't hold yourself responsible for someone else's bad decisions.
 
Don't.

You made a decision to not answer a telephone call from an unknown person while you were not feeling well.

You know that a T-210 is a lot of airplane compared to a Cardinal and a big step up. The phone call you received was from a cetificated pilot who should have known that as well, but nevertheless made a series of bad choices with unfortunately tragic results.

Feeling bad about the tragedy is understandable. We all feel that. But you can't hold yourself responsible for someone else's bad decisions.


Exactly what I was going to respond with. I’ve very sorry to hear of this.
 
thing is that i know him..and i knew what the call was going to be concerning. i just didn't feel like working yesterday am. best i can scratch it off to is that thing we should all do when we preflight 'ourselves'..and my head and heart was not to be in an airplane yesterday. i was too down about personal matters. it just makes one think that had things in my life been okay at that time then this tragedy would most likely been avoided. but you guys are saying the same thing that i'd say..how could i have known? you're right and i appreciate the supportive words. please remember this member of our aviation family in your prayers..
 
Perhaps you had "bad vibes" that were telling you to stay on the ground?

had things in my life been okay at that time then this tragedy would most likely been avoided.

Maybe, or maybe not. Once there was a plane that had a squawk on it. I could have grounded it, but I trusted my judgment in letting it go. The plane crashed less than 24 hours later. Had I grounded it, perhaps the plane wouldn't have crashed. Or, perhaps the crash would have only been delayed. The squawk had nothing to do with the crash, but those three days before that determination were not fun.

The "what if" questions will destroy you if you let them.

You made the best decision for the situation presented. We are only human, not all-seeing, and can't forecast the future despite our best efforts. These crashes make me become that much more of a 'by-the-book' hard-nosed instructor, and the training I give becomes that much more realistic and situation-based. That is all we can do.

Hang in there!
 
[FONT=&quot]Exleardriver, don't beat yourself up over it. You did nothing wrong. Everybody who flies knows that it's inherently dangerous and deaths do happen from time to time. This is at least the 3rd crash with fatalities out of RVS this year. I don't know what happened to your friend. He was about 250 yards short and offset about another 150 yards from the end of 19L. He clipped power lines and landed inverted. The plane didn't actually start on fire. There was a grass fire from a power line that broke and sparked. My instructor was actually on downwind for 19R in a Seminole and saw the whole incident. It's a very sad situation and I wish the best for your friend’s recovery and hope his father and wife R.I.P. I couldn't even imagine what he's going through right now.
[/FONT]
 
I just read this man, sorry to hear about it. I know you are beating yourself up, but imagine how your friend is going to feel (or does feel aleady). I am sure he will need you to be there for him. May his family RIP.
 
Back
Top