US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

Safety net still applies in business in this case, as without it, eventually, the tax burden would go to 100% airline 0% GA when GA ceases to exist. It wouldn't happen over night but eventually GA would be gone. Some operators like Netjets or larger Corporate flight departments could absorb the costs, but smaller less profitable companies would go out of business with a $100 per flight fee. Tax revenues would suffer, taxes would have to go up to cover the loss, more companies go out of business....eventually GA is dead and the airlines are stuck with the tab. However, it wouldn't just be the taxes they would have to pay, with GA dead, they would also need to now cover training expenses for new pilots, more money they need to spend.
law of unintended consequences
 
FYI, this proposal from the President was included in his just-released budget proposal. In it, he excludes all piston aircraft. So much for the panic from all of you claiming that he's going to kill the GA industry. :rolleyes:
 
FYI, this proposal from the President was included in his just-released budget proposal. In it, he excludes all piston aircraft. So much for the panic from all of you claiming that he's going to kill the GA industry. :rolleyes:

He excluded GA & piston for now, proposing a funding scheme that does not cover the bases properly. Its a matter of time until it gets expanded, not a question of "if". :ooh:
 
FYI, this proposal from the President was included in his just-released budget proposal. In it, he excludes all piston aircraft. So much for the panic from all of you claiming that he's going to kill the GA industry. :rolleyes:

Yeah and this is as far as it'll go, right?

guys?

I might remind you that the fee has already increased by 400% and it hasn't even been passed yet.

Speaking of which, Runway Finder just announced that they're shutting down this month. The reason? The new user fee from Aeronav.
 
Ahhh, the "slippery slope" argument. When all else fails and your arguments become irrelevant in light of the policy proposal, just claim that it's a "slippery slope." :rolleyes:
 
Ahhh, the "slippery slope" argument. When all else fails and your arguments become irrelevant in light of the policy proposal, just claim that it's a "slippery slope." :rolleyes:

Not so much an argument but simply a statement of fact in terms of government operations. Once it is imposed it will simply be a waiting game until "I told you so".

How have taxes worked out in general, have any of them not grown from where they began? Sure, eventually you piss enough people off (or buy enough politicians off) and you can get them lowered, but for the most part, taxes only go up.
 
Ahhh, the "slippery slope" argument. When all else fails and your arguments become irrelevant in light of the policy proposal, just claim that it's a "slippery slope." :rolleyes:

It's pretty much a given with anything surrounding big government. If you allow them the ability to legislate themselves more money and more power, guess what happens? This is not conjecture, but rather a statement of fact.

"Funding the government" just to fund the government is not a reason to tax. There must be a reason, and the people must maintain checks and balances.
 
It's nice watching you guys argue and having no one blame me for being a bonehead!

:)

Rage on!

Oh wait. Here it comes! 3... 2... 1....
 
It's nice watching you guys argue and having no one blame me for being a bonehead!

:)

Rage on!

Oh wait. Here it comes! 3... 2... 1....
77477c9b.jpg
 
FYI, this proposal from the President was included in his just-released budget proposal. In it, he excludes all piston aircraft. So much for the panic from all of you claiming that he's going to kill the GA industry. :rolleyes:

Do you honestly think this proposal will pass? How many times have user fees been included in a budget proposal yet never included in the final budget? I dont expect it to stay on this time either.

Im confused on what budget proposal your talking about anyways. They signed into law a four year budget for the FAA in Feb 14th that didnt include user fees or tax increases.http://www.aopa.org/advocacy/articles/2012/120214long-term-faa-bill-signed-into-law.html
 
Hard telling what will make it into the final budget. The amount of horse trading that goes on is incredible. It might end up in there as a trade to the President to get something that the Republicans want, or it may get booted out again. Never know until the end of the budget process.

As far as which budget, this is the regular budget, not the FAA reauthorization that you're talking about. The President submitted his government budget proposal, and it included this $100 per flight fee.
 
Hard telling what will make it into the final budget. The amount of horse trading that goes on is incredible. It might end up in there as a trade to the President to get something that the Republicans want, or it may get booted out again. Never know until the end of the budget process.

As far as which budget, this is the regular budget, not the FAA reauthorization that you're talking about. The President submitted his government budget proposal, and it included this $100 per flight fee.

I need some education here. I thought the FAA reauthorization bill is what mandated how the FAA is funded. So I thought that user fees were off the table for the next four years with the bill passing. Now your saying the president can still get user fees added on with his general budget?
 
The FAA reauthorization is basically just Congress telling the FAA where to put the money. A full budget for the government still has to be done yearly, and the President has made his proposal. The Republicans will have their own (possibly several competing versions), and after much arguing and political posturing, a final budget will be crafted. User fees can technically be added not just as part of a budget, but as part of any bill, really. You can have a completely unrelated bill that has user fees tacked on as a rider. That's pretty typical for how any smaller issues are handled in Congress nowadays.
 
Just in case there wasn't enough debate on this topic, I'll just throw a different angle into the mix. I fly a small turboprop for a small but successful company. We often fly four or five legs a day over pretty short distances. Under the "$100 per flight" proposal, we will need to pay 4 or 5 hundred extra dollars a day (more than my salary, btw) in user fees. I'm not going to debate who pays more or less than their fair share in the current system, or even if that amount of money is appropriate for ATC services for one aircraft that may travel as little as 500-600nm total distance and use mostly county and municipal fields. My major beef with a flat, per flight fee is two-fold: One, it attempts to fix one inequity with another - a corporate jet flying from TEB to VNY will pay $100, while my flights from somewhere in Ohio to PA to WV and back will cost $500. I could easily argue the cross-continent trip requires far more use and coordination of FAA resources, and thus should require a higher fee. Two, a "one size fits all" fee structure such as this shows a fundamental lack of understanding that some policy makers have of the aviation industry and the many ways it is utilized in this country. Frankly, any administration should be embarrassed to forward such a proposal. We don't charge every vehicle the same amount on a toll road...the amount varies depending on the distance traveled on the road, the number of axles, etc. If nothing else, any user fee system would need to incorporate the same types of considerations. But then the bureaucracy you create would be terrifying.

Overall, if funding needs to change, I believe the best course is to revise fuel taxes. The current system works fine as far as collecting money is concerned. If the "powers that be" decree that I'm not paying my fair share, fine. Collect more fuel tax from me, don't create a bloated, new, and inefficient bureaucracy just so you can say you "created" jobs.
 
Back
Top