US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

If a modest increase in the taxes you pay would kill your business, then I'm sorry, but survival of the fittest. My company shouldn't be subsidizing yours. That is my problem with this entire situation.

The 47% number that the wing nuts like to throw out is nothing but a distraction. Those people make a pittance and spend every dime of their income on just getting by. Your frothing at the mouth to force the poor to pay taxes is disgusting.

I would really like to know how you rectify these two opposing statements. :confused:
 
If a modest increase in the taxes you pay would kill your business, then I'm sorry, but survival of the fittest.

If a market will only support a price of $250/ticket, and we're required to pay $60 of that in taxes, then we're only getting $190. We can't simply charge $310 to absorb the taxes, because demand would fall off and overall yield would be lower, reducing our profits.

Now, you are just using circular logic. Hypocritical, much?


Why would you waste energy getting upset about an idea that hasn't even been committed to paper yet? Seems kind of funny to me, but then again, I am a "funny guy" apparently. ;)

Now we are finally getting somewhere! Because the only other models of user fees in aviation have killed GA in those countries. That is exactly the reason I have my job now.

With no concrete proposals, with no numbers, and no real assurances that "small" aircraft won't be affected with landing fees, approach fees, weather briefing fees, "controlled airspace fees" (everything but G?), the only thing we have to use as a comparison are those countries which have basically killed an entire sector of industry that keeps a large number of people employed in the USA, including myself.
 
Now, you are just using circular logic. Hypocritical, much?

My company already pays more than its fair share. If 98.4% of the revenue isn't enough, then I don't know what is. Your sector of the industry does not. So I'm not sure how that's "circular logic."

Now we are finally getting somewhere! Because the only other models of user fees in aviation have killed GA in those countries. That is exactly the reason I have my job now.

With no concrete proposals, with no numbers, and no real assurances that "small" aircraft won't be affected with landing fees, approach fees, weather briefing fees, "controlled airspace fees" (everything but G?), the only thing we have to use as a comparison are those countries which have basically killed an entire sector of industry that keeps a large number of people employed in the USA, including myself.

No, you can compare all of the bills that have actually been proposed in this country for user fees, and all of them have excluded you. That seems to be a more valid comparison to me than what has happened in other countries.
 
No, you can compare all of the bills that have actually been proposed in this country for user fees, and all of them have excluded you.

That's because no actual bill has been drafted yet. It's just an idea. The bill, if proposed, would include the definitions.

:bang: Which is it?




My company already pays more than its fair share. If 98.4% of the revenue isn't enough, then I don't know what is. Your sector of the industry does not. So I'm not sure how that's "circular logic."
So why not just increase the fuel tax? That seems like an easier, more direct way of increasing the revenue to me. It also seems quite a bit more equitable.

Oh wait, we can't do that because the airlines would cry about paying their fair share of tax revenue. The airlines get charged .04 a gallon, whereas GA gets to pay 5x that. All of this money grab is to fund NextGen, which airlines wanted, not necessarily GA. If you guys wanted it, you pay for it.
 
:bang: Which is it?

Well, both. :) There is no current bill. The only thing that has even been mentioned lately is a vague idea from the white house about a $100 per flight fee, to exclude recreational aircraft. But no bill has been proposed for it. It's all just a nebulous idea that will probably never see the light of day. But if you go back a few years, you'll find many bills that have been proposed in the past. You can reference those to see what is likely to be included in a user fees bill in this country, and it would not affect your operation.

So why not just increase the fuel tax? That seems like an easier, more direct way of increasing the revenue to me. It also seems quite a bit more equitable.

I'm ok with that. A gas tax increase on Jet-A for non-airline operations and for 100LL would be a fine alternative.

Oh wait, we can't do that because the airlines would cry about paying their fair share of tax revenue.

Oh, you want to increase our gas taxes too? Sorry, but that's ridiculous. We pay 98.4% of the revenue. Increasing everyone's gas tax will keep that ratio the same, which doesn't fix the problem. The problem is that we pay all of the taxes, and everyone else gets a free ride. That's BS.
 
ATN_Pilot said:
If a modest increase in the taxes you pay would kill your business, then I'm sorry, but survival of the fittest. My company shouldn't be subsidizing yours. That is my problem with this entire situation.​
​
ATN_Pilot said:
The 47% number that the wing nuts like to throw out is nothing but a distraction. Those people make a pittance and spend every dime of their income on just getting by. Your frothing at the mouth to force the poor to pay taxes is disgusting.​
​
I would really like to know how you rectify these two opposing statements. :confused:




The problem is that we pay all of the taxes, and everyone else gets a free ride. That's BS.

Add that one too.
 
I'm not really sure what you find to be conflicting. Are you comparing a company to a poor person? Because despite what Mitt Romney wants you to believe, corporations are not people (my friend).

Were not talking about just corporations here, and you know it.
 
Were not talking about just corporations here, and you know it.

In that case, I'm not really sure what you're getting at. Can you expound on what you find to be conflicting? My position is pretty simple here: airlines are subsidizing everyone else's use of the NAS and all aviation facilities. It is fundamentally unfair, and the tax burden on the other users should be increased to be more equitable. What exactly do you find to be conflicting within that position?
 
In that case, I'm not really sure what you're getting at. Can you expound on what you find to be conflicting? My position is pretty simple here: airlines are subsidizing everyone else's use of the NAS and all aviation facilities. It is fundamentally unfair, and the tax burden on the other users should be increased to be more equitable. What exactly do you find to be conflicting within that position?

So then, you would be OK to raise taxes on the poor, since they should pay their fair share and all. I can't make it any more clear than that.
 
So then, you would be OK to raise taxes on the poor, since they should pay their fair share and all. I can't make it any more clear than that.

No, of course not. But again, I don't see how you're connecting those two things. A part 135 charter company is not a poor person. A rich guy who owns a business jet is not a poor person. And yes, a weekend warrior who owns a C-172 is not a poor person. The social safety net is to prevent people from starving, from sleeping out in the cold, from not getting health care, etc. What you're implying (it seems to me) is basically that the airlines should provide a "safety net" of sorts for GA to be able to use the system without contributing. I think that's a pretty big stretch.
 
Should boat owners and operators pay for the Coast Guard as they are the ones using it? Should only states with international borders pay for border agents as they are the ones with the entry problems?
 
Should boat owners and operators pay for the Coast Guard as they are the ones using it? Should only states with international borders pay for border agents as they are the ones with the entry problems?

You're still missing the point. The problem here is that one user of the system is paying for it, and others aren't. The Coast Guard is paid for out of the general fund. If you want to start funding the Aviation Trust Fund and the FAA out of the general fund, and stop the ridiculous taxes on the airlines, then I'll drop my support of user fees and support that plan 100%. But as long as the users have to pay, everyone using it needs to pay, instead of leeching off of the airlines.
 
You're still missing the point. The problem here is that one user of the system is paying for it, and others aren't. The Coast Guard is paid for out of the general fund. If you want to start funding the Aviation Trust Fund and the FAA out of the general fund, and stop the ridiculous taxes on the airlines, then I'll drop my support of user fees and support that plan 100%. But as long as the users have to pay, everyone using it needs to pay, instead of leeching off of the airlines.

Everyone is paying into it. What are you not understanding?

You and your fat cat union bosses want to put a tax on some starving CFI or some barely getting by FBO. Come to my home town, pal, and see how many CFIs and students exist due to a user-fee based airspace system. You're clearly an idealist with no real understanding of the matter who loves to semi-troll this website.

Anyways, carry on!
 
ATN, what's with the constant push to tax everyone, even at the expense of jobs (ref: "Survival of the fittest" comment)? I thought the reason behind raising taxes was to provide a positive environment for everyone? What type of positive environment exists when jobs are being lost to increased taxation? Where is that money going, if it's just being taken out of the economy and handed to the government?

You can't tax just to tax; there has to be a reason behind it, and a loss of jobs as a result is NOT acceptable when considering a new tax.
 
No, of course not. But again, I don't see how you're connecting those two things. A part 135 charter company is not a poor person. A rich guy who owns a business jet is not a poor person. And yes, a weekend warrior who owns a C-172 is not a poor person. The social safety net is to prevent people from starving, from sleeping out in the cold, from not getting health care, etc. What you're implying (it seems to me) is basically that the airlines should provide a "safety net" of sorts for GA to be able to use the system without contributing. I think that's a pretty big stretch.

Safety net still applies in business in this case, as without it, eventually, the tax burden would go to 100% airline 0% GA when GA ceases to exist. It wouldn't happen over night but eventually GA would be gone. Some operators like Netjets or larger Corporate flight departments could absorb the costs, but smaller less profitable companies would go out of business with a $100 per flight fee. Tax revenues would suffer, taxes would have to go up to cover the loss, more companies go out of business....eventually GA is dead and the airlines are stuck with the tab. However, it wouldn't just be the taxes they would have to pay, with GA dead, they would also need to now cover training expenses for new pilots, more money they need to spend.
 
Back on topic;

The National Airspace System is like our interstate highway system, our fuel tax dollars pay for it, and then it is free for anyone to use. The user fee model is like having toll roads every where.

If the FAA requires more funding, then a modest increase in fuel taxes is fine by me, but fundamentally changing the whole "free skies" concept is a really bad idea.
 
Back
Top