US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

You don't answer to me, but you do answer to your coworkers whom you may represent as a union official. I mean that in a completely non-confrontational manner; I simply hope you realize what deregulation has done for your career, and the careers of your fellow pilots.

As a sidebar note, SWA is still SWAPA though, is it not? Not ALPA there?
 
I know that things were decent under the CAB (for a select few airlines), however, I'm talking about the effects of re-regulation today. The overabundance of supply would have to be taken care of in some manner, and that would require removing airlines from a number of markets. SWA would undoubtedly be affected, adversely.

Unlikely. Stagnation for a few years would be the likely result of re-regulation today. The airlines are currently making money, with the exception of bankrupt AMR, so simply stopping everything in its tracks and preventing new entrants to the market would allow things to stabilize nicely, and any new routes would have to be approved by the CAB with each airline submitting bids and providing justification for the service. There is no reason to believe that anyone would be affected adversely.

You may not believe much in capitalism

I'm a big fan of capitalism. Just not the laissez faire variety.

Without deregulation, SWA would be just that little airline in Texas, perhaps already passed from memory.

That's nothing but speculation.

You don't answer to me, but you do answer to your coworkers whom you may represent as a union official.

I don't represent anyone at SWA.

I simply hope you realize what deregulation has done for your career, and the careers of your fellow pilots.

Oh, I realize it, and it isn't good. Deregulation decimated this profession. You should read Flying the Line, Volume II.
 
I would like to add my 2c as a poor weekend warrior. Here you can get Airport Improvement Program (AIP) Grant Histories: http://www.faa.gov/airports/aip/grant_histories
AIP 2011, For California we have:
Total: 238,586,791.00
Primary (read, big airports): 190,873,001.00 (80%!)
...
...
More or less pure GA are "Reliever" (19,694,425.00) and "General Aviation" (25,966,220.00). Together
they make about 19% of the total sum.

For all states, "Reliever"+"General Aviation"make 22% of all AIP grants.
 
Funny how capitalists look down on how Todd got the job at GIA... That's capitalism at its finest. You all should be proud.

That and I keep reading arguments for supporting GA so it doesn't turn out like Europe, from people against societal programs meant to help folks in need. Do you guys read your own stuff?

Privatizing ATC would be purely capitalistic, and whatever the market price is for your airplane to participate, so be it.
 
Funny how capitalists look down on how Todd got the job at GIA... That's capitalism at its finest. You all should be proud.

That and I keep reading arguments for supporting GA so it doesn't turn out like Europe, from people against societal programs meant to help folks in need. Do you guys read your own stuff?

Privatizing ATC would be purely capitalistic, and whatever the market price is for your airplane to participate, so be it.

I never brought up ATN's PFTing, but buying a job is not capitalism. Capitalism is the exchange of your services for a paycheck, for the furtherance of the business that's employing you. If someone wants to PFT that's their decision, but it's nothing at all to be proud of, nor is it anywhere near "capitalism at its finest."

If ATC were to privatize and charge user fees, that's their prerogative as a private entity. The government charging user fees is entirely another matter; the government is not a profit-motivated business, though, some would argue (including me) that the distinction is minimal these days.

I really wish some of you guys could see how empty GA ramps are all over Europe. It's destroyed a lot of business.
 
I really wish some of you guys could see how empty GA ramps are all over Europe. It's destroyed a lot of business.

I agree with dasleben, I didn't start this thread to debate user fees though... but that said, not having user fees and redtape in our airspace system in the United States causes pilots from literally every corner of the globe to do they're primary and often they're secondary training (type ratings etc) here in the United States. I know this because I've trained pilots from over 30 countries now and counting. By increasing taxes on GA you would just kill more businesses and decrease tax revenue overall in the midterm-longterm, so it would make the problem worse not better.

Furthermore, the fighting is always over runway space, as a PC-12 driver I was flying one the largest GA aircraft around. Our ceiling was FL300 (which we rarely went up that high) and we could still do 160 KIAs up to short final at the rare occasion we did go into LGA or JFK. The other 95% of GA aircraft never get anywhere near a Class Bravo airport or above FL180 we'd they're paying for a huge portion of the total ATC system they're not using.
 
I'll?
Funny how capitalists look down on how Todd got the job at GIA... That's capitalism at its finest. You all should be proud.

That and I keep reading arguments for supporting GA so it doesn't turn out like Europe, from people against societal programs meant to help folks in need. Do you guys read your own stuff?

Privatizing ATC would be purely capitalistic, and whatever the market price is for your airplane to participate, so be it.

I'll bite.

It has nothing to do with capitalism. It has everything to do with the fact that through taxes, we already fund the ATC system. The user fee is an egregious, punitive and largely uncessessary measure aimed at the perceived wealthy (look at AOPA's stats on who actually owns and flies planes - it isn'the uber wealthy, capitalistic monsters that you're referring to).

Nobody is asking to not pay their share of the ATC system - that's you liberal types that like stuff for
free. Once you start a fee based system, it won 't stop. Again, I cite Europe and a great example of an un-friendly, GA toxic environment which is mostly user-fee based and candidly, out of reach for not just the "middle class" but for most people.

As for Todd going to GIA, right. Blame the "capitalists" (this has to be the weakest argument I've ever read).

From Europe, Tot Ziens!
 
And I don't think reasonable user fees are going to put you out of a job.

The reason I have the job I have is DIRECTLY attributed to the fact that we DON'T have user fees. Our customers come to us because it is significantly cheaper for them to come to the USA than it is to do their flight training in Europe, Africa, Asia, and Central/South America.
 
The reason I have the job I have is DIRECTLY attributed to the fact that we DON'T have user fees. Our customers come to us because it is significantly cheaper for them to come to the USA than it is to do their flight training in Europe, Africa, Asia, and Central/South America.

And with the kind of user fees that have been proposed, that wouldn't change. Not even close. Unless you're training these guys in a Citation or a King Air. :rolleyes:
 
And with the kind of user fees that have been proposed, that wouldn't change. Not even close. Unless you're training these guys in a Citation or a King Air. :rolleyes:

You were the one who specifically took at jab at Cessna pilots and brought them to the discussion, not me. Not to mention choice jabs like these


Basing taxation on the amount of fuel that one consumes is ridiculous. A Cessna 172 takes up the same resources in Atlanta airspace that my B717 does. Time to pay up.


You use the ATC system quite a bit. You just want to do it for a fraction of what it costs, while the airlines subsidize your hobby, and my company pays out the ass in taxes in an industry where profit margins are razor thin. Seems like you're the ones "looking out for number one."


Why do you have Cessna 172's so much? If they aren't even part of your argument, why do you continue to take jabs? Again, you are the one who keeps taking shots at Cessna pilots and GA.

Anyways, what about this?

To reduce the deficit and more equitably
share the cost of air traffic services across the
aviation user community, the Administration
proposes to establish a new mandatory surcharge for air traffic services� This proposal
would create a $100 per flight fee, payable to
the FAA, by aviation operators who fly in controlled airspace� Military aircraft, public aircraft, recreational piston aircraft, air ambulances, aircraft operating outside of controlled
airspace, and Canada-to-Canada flights would
be exempted

It says recreational aircraft would be exempt, but there is no definition of the term "recreational". This is what is scary to me and other GA pilots, and why it is more than an unsubstantiated slippery slope BS. Vague definitions with vague limits.
 
You were the one who specifically took at jab at Cessna pilots and brought them to the discussion, not me. Not to mention choice jabs like these

Yes, I personally would like to impose user fees on them as well. But no official proposals have ever actually included that. They've always been exempt. As far as the user fees I would be in favor of proposing, they wouldn't be anywhere close to enough to kill the training market in this country when compared to the cost in other countries.

It says recreational aircraft would be exempt, but there is no definition of the term "recreational". This is what is scary to me and other GA pilots, and why it is more than an unsubstantiated slippery slope BS. Vague definitions with vague limits.

That's because no actual bill has been drafted yet. It's just an idea. The bill, if proposed, would include the definitions. In the past, the definition has always excluded non-turbine aircraft at weights below 12,500 lbs.
 
As far as the user fees I would be in favor of proposing, they wouldn't be anywhere close to enough to kill the training market in this country when compared to the cost in other countries.

See, that is the problem. You are using a few various tactics to disguise your argument try to deflect arguments to support your position. Here is how the discussion has gone:

Random: User fees will kill GA
ATN: We shouldn't support your hobby. PAY YOUR FAIR SHARE
Random: This isn't a hobby for me. In fact, user fees would put me out of business
ATN: No one has proposed taxing you. (Except me, in this very thread).

So now that we are clear that you are FOR user fees for small aircraft, please explain to me how the "user fees you would be in favor of proposing" wouldn't be a nail in the coffin for business like mine. You can't make that argument, because you have no idea what you are talking about. As others have said, it is easy to sit in your 717 and make decisions that further your career and kill others.


That's because no actual bill has been drafted yet. It's just an idea. The bill, if proposed, would include the definitions. In the past, the definition has always excluded non-turbine aircraft at weights below 12,500 lbs.

LOL. So let me get this straight. It is just an idea, with no definitions, numbers, or data, and you wonder why GA pilots are upset? Are you serious? You are a funny guy.
 
So now that we are clear that you are FOR user fees for small aircraft, please explain to me how the "user fees you would be in favor of proposing" wouldn't be a nail in the coffin for business like mine.

If a modest increase in the taxes you pay would kill your business, then I'm sorry, but survival of the fittest. My company shouldn't be subsidizing yours. That is my problem with this entire situation.

LOL. So let me get this straight. It is just an idea, with no definitions, numbers, or data, and you wonder why GA pilots are upset? Are you serious? You are a funny guy.

Why would you waste energy getting upset about an idea that hasn't even been committed to paper yet? Seems kind of funny to me, but then again, I am a "funny guy" apparently. ;)
 
Back
Top