US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

A few cents in gas tax cover the use of the highway system, no? Why should aircraft be any different?

Radar, TACAN, VORs, NDBs, ILSs, landlines, Sheet Cake, NexGen, inspectors, VORTACs, chart publications, TERPS, The FAA Chorale, all things the state DOT doesn't have to fund. Just a thought.
 
Why do you expect my company and my customers to fund your airport with a 1,500 foot runway that I couldn't even use in an emergency?

This can't be said for all airports in the country, but surely you can recognize the value of reliever airports. No, citrus doesn't actually land at GA fields like Teterboro, NJ, Palwaukee, IL, Van Nuys, CA, and so on, but the reduction in traffic that directly affects your company and your customers is pretty apparent.
 
User fees would create yet another superfluous government agency to collect them and arbitrarily decide to up them XX% each succeeding year until general aviation in the US mirrors that in Europe, i.e. everyone is flying gliders since that's all they can afford. No thanks! You want more "financial stake" from pilots into the system? Then increase the fuel tax.

BTW I love gliding.
 
adk said:
This can't be said for all airports in the country, but surely you can recognize the value of reliever airports. No, citrus doesn't actually land at GA fields like Teterboro, NJ, Palwaukee, IL, Van Nuys, CA, and so on, but the reduction in traffic that directly affects your company and your customers is pretty apparent.

Actually most airports in this country are not funded by general tax payers. They are their own entity and usually break even or even bring in more revenue that is then put back in airport projects. Not saying that no airport has never ever received some type of government grant, but that is not as common. Large airports make lots of money from landing fees, fuel surcharges, gate rentals, concessions, and the like. They make tons of money from vehicle parking. Even smaller GA airports cover their operating expenses through tie down fees, hangar fees and rentals, and other fees the FBO might charge.

Large construction projects are usually funded by selling bonds, such as new terminals. Airlines also chip in for terminals as well in many cases. When you buy a ticket, you see that PFC, or passenger facility charge, which goes to the airport for improvement projects.

So I don't think it's really fair to say that a huge sum of taxpayer money is going to airports, because they really aren't. Again, some have received grants, such as from the stimulus package from 2009, but thats not really the case overall.
 
KSCessnaDriver said:
A few cents in gas tax cover the use of the highway system, no? Why should aircraft be any different?

Actually, they don't cover the cost of highway building either. Since 2007, Congress has had to "bail out" the Highway Trust Fund because the 18.4 cents per gallon no longer covers the need to build new or keep up existing highways. The last time it was raised was in 1993 to adjust for inflation. This is one reason why almost every new highway being built is a toll road.

But in reality, the gas tax has almost always gone to other uses as well, so it's not really a "user fee" either. It was first established in 1932 to help with the deficit.
 
Actually most airports in this country are not funded by general tax payers. They are their own entity and usually break even or even bring in more revenue that is then put back in airport projects. Not saying that no airport has never ever received some type of government grant, but that is not as common. Large airports make lots of money from landing fees, fuel surcharges, gate rentals, concessions, and the like. They make tons of money from vehicle parking. Even smaller GA airports cover their operating expenses through tie down fees, hangar fees and rentals, and other fees the FBO might charge.

Large construction projects are usually funded by selling bonds, such as new terminals. Airlines also chip in for terminals as well in many cases. When you buy a ticket, you see that PFC, or passenger facility charge, which goes to the airport for improvement projects.

So I don't think it's really fair to say that a huge sum of taxpayer money is going to airports, because they really aren't. Again, some have received grants, such as from the stimulus package from 2009, but thats not really the case overall.
shhhh ATN doesn't want to hear facts. All he wants to hear is that airlines are god and GA is evil
 
The thing to think about when doing tax is not on the 737 pays (x) ammount for this service, how about we say each person or possible person is paying (x) ammount for tax's.

Add up the ammount one person pays in tax's on a flight from someplace like Oakland to Texas, then add up the ammount of tax's that the baron with 6 seats pays per person.
 
Radar, TACAN, VORs, NDBs, ILSs, landlines, Sheet Cake, NexGen, inspectors, VORTACs, chart publications, TERPS, The FAA Chorale, all things the state DOT doesn't have to fund. Just a thought.

Yes sheet cake! We have to commemorate 15th year of service for the guy who makes 150K a year for bringing out pens and boxes of strip paper. It is a momentous occasion.


And for those of you that haven't had to suffer the pleasure of the FAA Chorale I present you the FAA anthem.

 
You know as well as I do that a minuscule number of flights depart from private airports. It doesn't skew the numbers at all. Let's deal in reality, and it doesn't support your argument. You're "looking out for number one," which I certainly understand, but don't pretend that your fight is a righteous one.

In 2010 there were a total of 19,802 airports in the US, 5,175 were public use, 14353 were private use and 274 were military. It is impossible that a miniscule number of flights depart from private airports as they make up the majority of airports in the US. 72% actually.
http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_03.html

In a previous post you claimed that GA (business and GA) comprised 80% of flights daily. You admitted that it wasnt all IFR traffic, but still didnt seem accurate to me. So, here is the real data based on FAA stats. http://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/admin/fbYSum.asp
GA does use the system, but it is hardly 80%, where did you get that stat from?
That document shows Air carriers amount for 59% of daily system use, GA accounts for 35% and Military accounts for 6%.

So with that, if as you stated earlier A only pays 1.2% into the fund, sorry I dont believe you as you used complimentary findings not realistic findings for your other arguments so you'll need to support it, it appears that it is deserved. They make up 60% of the usage but that is going to only 28% of the airports nationwide. So the other 72% of the airports are funding themselves. If you factor in the costs associated with running the private airports that the FAA does not support, which would be the fair way to go, you would see that % contribution rise to be more inline with system usage %.
 
In 2010 there were a total of 19,802 airports in the US, 5,175 were public use, 14353 were private use and 274 were military. It is impossible that a miniscule number of flights depart from private airports as they make up the majority of airports in the US. 72% actually.
http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_03.html

In a previous post you claimed that GA (business and GA) comprised 80% of flights daily. You admitted that it wasnt all IFR traffic, but still didnt seem accurate to me. So, here is the real data based on FAA stats. http://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/admin/fbYSum.asp
GA does use the system, but it is hardly 80%, where did you get that stat from?
That document shows Air carriers amount for 59% of daily system use, GA accounts for 35% and Military accounts for 6%.

So with that, if as you stated earlier A only pays 1.2% into the fund, sorry I dont believe you as you used complimentary findings not realistic findings for your other arguments so you'll need to support it, it appears that it is deserved. They make up 60% of the usage but that is going to only 28% of the airports nationwide. So the other 72% of the airports are funding themselves. If you factor in the costs associated with running the private airports that the FAA does not support, which would be the fair way to go, you would see that % contribution rise to be more inline with system usage %.
let me remind you ATN does not want to hear logic don't expect him to respond
 
In 2010 there were a total of 19,802 airports in the US, 5,175 were public use, 14353 were private use and 274 were military. It is impossible that a miniscule number of flights depart from private airports as they make up the majority of airports in the US. 72% actually.
http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_03.html

In a previous post you claimed that GA (business and GA) comprised 80% of flights daily. You admitted that it wasnt all IFR traffic, but still didnt seem accurate to me. So, here is the real data based on FAA stats. http://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/admin/fbYSum.asp
GA does use the system, but it is hardly 80%, where did you get that stat from?
That document shows Air carriers amount for 59% of daily system use, GA accounts for 35% and Military accounts for 6%.

So with that, if as you stated earlier A only pays 1.2% into the fund, sorry I dont believe you as you used complimentary findings not realistic findings for your other arguments so you'll need to support it, it appears that it is deserved. They make up 60% of the usage but that is going to only 28% of the airports nationwide. So the other 72% of the airports are funding themselves. If you factor in the costs associated with running the private airports that the FAA does not support, which would be the fair way to go, you would see that % contribution rise to be more inline with system usage %.

Your link doesn't work, so I can't see what you're saying. But in any case, your facts are wrong. GA (which includes corporate aviation) accounts for 77% of all traffic in the United States. There are tons of sources for this if you do a simple Google search, but here's one source from the TSA: http://www.tsa.gov/what_we_do/tsnm/general_aviation/index.shtm
 
In 2010 there were a total of 19,802 airports in the US, 5,175 were public use, 14353 were private use and 274 were military. It is impossible that a miniscule number of flights depart from private airports as they make up the majority of airports in the US. 72% actually.
http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_03.html

In a previous post you claimed that GA (business and GA) comprised 80% of flights daily. You admitted that it wasnt all IFR traffic, but still didnt seem accurate to me. So, here is the real data based on FAA stats. http://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/admin/fbYSum.asp
GA does use the system, but it is hardly 80%, where did you get that stat from?
That document shows Air carriers amount for 59% of daily system use, GA accounts for 35% and Military accounts for 6%.

So with that, if as you stated earlier A only pays 1.2% into the fund, sorry I dont believe you as you used complimentary findings not realistic findings for your other arguments so you'll need to support it, it appears that it is deserved. They make up 60% of the usage but that is going to only 28% of the airports nationwide. So the other 72% of the airports are funding themselves. If you factor in the costs associated with running the private airports that the FAA does not support, which would be the fair way to go, you would see that % contribution rise to be more inline with system usage %.


OHHHH SSSAAAANNNNAAAAAAPPPPPPP!

I just love it when someone actually does research and shows how it actually is. I fly GA. Usually either pt135 pax charter or "Lifegaurd." I use the crap out of the system. But 9 out of ten times, when I am using the system, and get a call for "Traffic, 10o'clock, 1000ft above opposite direction" it's an airline.

Would you rather user fee's be implemented, and most of the reliver airports be shut down due to lack of funding ATN? Because I sure would love to take cuts in front of you, like ATC usually does for me when I am under the "Lifegaurd" call sign because user fee's were implemented and now I am forced to use major airports that you always fly into. Or how about me getting direct from 50 miles out from my destination on a 1000nm flight, and you having to either get vectored or fly a hold becuase I get preferential treatment into LAS now instead of heading for HND because it was not only closer to the hospital, but also a reliver to LAS? Do you really want a bunch of "Lifegaurd" guys jamming you up? What a bunch of incosideriate pricks, right? Everyday there is a ton of us out there doing good things for very sick people. About a month ago, the company I work for had our ENTIRE FLEET (2 Lear55's, three Citation 5's) go out on a call to harvest organs from someone, and ALL of those organ went to the Childrens hospital in LA. Is that what you want? The way I see it, you can pay a little more in taxes and save a bunch in fuel because we aren't clogging up your precious airports, and your precious NAS, or you can pay your user fee's, and a crap ton more in fuel because we are now forced to because many of the reliver airports were shut down due to lack of funding like Europe is a prime example of.

And I know that Lifegaurds would be exempt from the fee's. Thats not the point of my post. My point is that the impact non-lifegaurd flights will have will diminish the amount of money being brought in to pay for the system as it exists right now. Our current system isn't broken. For the amount of passengers hauled by the airlines vs the amount of passengers hauled by other means, it seems to me like the system is actually in favor of the airlines. They haul a lot more asses around than the other types of flying. Pass that cost on to the customer, just like we do in the 135 world. It's not our fault that an airline is only charging $138.00 to get from LAX to DEN. Talk to your management, have them raise the fairs, and you won't have to operate on razor thin margins. Because contrary to pouplar belief, 135 pax charter is the exact same. Hell, even most of the fractionals are the same. Did you know that Avantair has yet to post a profit? Bring any argument against that, because the same will be able to be said about the razor thin profit margins that airlines are making.
 
Your link doesn't work, so I can't see what you're saying. But in any case, your facts are wrong. GA (which includes corporate aviation) accounts for 77% of all traffic in the United States. There are tons of sources for this if you do a simple Google search, but here's one source from the TSA: http://www.tsa.gov/what_we_do/tsnm/general_aviation/index.shtm

Again, that stat is incorrect as you make it seem as they GA flights make up 77% of the system usage each day, which they dont. The report I linked to, which maybe this will work summary of dec 10 through dec 11 and select https://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/admin/default.asp shows as stated above, system use, which is what we are talking about, Airlines dominate. It doesnt matter if Joe Six pack takes off from a private field lands at a private field and never talked to ATC, that shouldnt be counted in system use, but you are trying to use those types of flights as a reason to charge GA more money to support Airlines. It doesnt and shouldnt work that way.
 
Your link still doesn't work, so I can't see what you're referencing. I will certainly concede that an airplane that uses no public resources shouldn't be charged a user fee, though.
 
Your link still doesn't work, so I can't see what you're referencing. I will certainly concede that an airplane that uses no public resources shouldn't be charged a user fee, though.

Try going through here, then other reports https://aspm.faa.gov/opsnet/sys/Main.asp?force=atads

Either way. If you concede the point that those not using the system shouldnt have to pay for the system it stands to reason that using the 77% should be thrown out as the case maker and replaced with 35% daily system use and worked from there. That is the true representation of GA system use but still does not truly reflect costs associated with supporting GA flights.

With that, you can break it out a number of ways. Cost per passenger, cost per mile, cost per leg...but anyway you slice it airlines will continue to support the majority of the system as they are the majority stakeholder in the system. That will be even more so when NexGen is rolled out and airlines begin using RNP at the major airports, where they are the heavy majority.

It may not make sense for corporate, fractional or personal GA users to become certified in RNP approaches as 5 minutes saved on a single flight is much less valuable than it is to an airline where that can amount to 30 minutes saved over the course of a standard multi leg day.
 
Maybe it's just my browser or something, but I still can't get that link to work.

Here is teh report that is generated by the FAA system.For simplicity I added all the top numbers of each category, added the air carrier and air taxi together for an airline total then compared to GA and Military. I summed the four different sub categories together to get an overall picture of system usage.

Factbook Report
Yearly Summary


Note: All totals are rounded to the thousands
Date Range Air
Carrier Air
Taxi General
Aviation Military Total
TRACON Ops FAA
12/2009-12/2010 14260 10273 14771 2598 41902
12/2010-12/2011 14136 10014 14320 2525 40996
Airport Ops FAA
12/2009-12/2010 13500 8640 16340 1596 40075
12/2010-12/2011 13631 8423 15868 1533 39454
Airport Ops Contracted
12/2009-12/2010 279 1533 11888 1217 14917
12/2010-12/2011 282 1517 11835 1256 14889
ARTCC Ops
12/2009-12/2010 24377 9423 7089 3232 44121
12/2010-12/2011 25543 9771 7016 2166 44495
 
Ahh, I see what you're doing. You're not including air taxi operations in general aviation. That skews the numbers. Air taxi (part 135 and similar) operations do not have the same tax burden that the airlines do. Mshunter's air ambulance flight takes off from a public airport, uses ATC services, and lands at a public airport, using the very same resources that my B717 uses, but his company's tax burden is a tiny, tiny fraction of mine. That's why the airlines pay $12 billion into the trust fund, while everyone else only pays $200 million. Surely you can see the ridiculous disparity in those numbers.
 
Ahh, I see what you're doing. You're not including air taxi operations in general aviation. That skews the numbers. Air taxi (part 135 and similar) operations do not have the same tax burden that the airlines do. Mshunter's air ambulance flight takes off from a public airport, uses ATC services, and lands at a public airport, using the very same resources that my B717 uses, but his company's tax burden is a tiny, tiny fraction of mine. That's why the airlines pay $12 billion into the trust fund, while everyone else only pays $200 million. Surely you can see the ridiculous disparity in those numbers.

Putting air taxi into GA isnt a far assessment either then.

The system is more than just ATC though, you need to factor in airport usage. Airlines use the largest and most expensive airports where I would bet, I can look for supporting data later, that air taxis use smaller less expensive airports or even some private airports.

What is the cost to maintain airports vs the system? Id bet airports are much more expensive, especially with GPS not being the FAA's responsibility and VOR's and NDB's being phased out?

I still say airlines are paying for the system they get much more use out of.

You want to take the tax burden off airlines, but as has already been pointed out, air taxis and charters operate on the same shoe string budget, maybe even tighter.
 
Back
Top