US House passes $63 million FAA bill.

So let me get this straight, because ATN Pilot stated an opinion and a reaseon for that opinion, you all are going to start attacking him personally?

Sure, but I think part of that stems from his past. Because you know darn well that if one of the younger members here would have done what he did, the same stuff would be happening to him.

I now remember why he was on ignore for the longest time. He is doing nothing but looking out for number one.
 
User fees would kill GA.

The government shouldn't be in the business of subsidizing your hobby.

Besides buying a job like you did at Gulfstream, where would the US get its pilots from?

You know, GIA no longer exists. You may want to find a new weird obsession. Regardless, the US would get its pilots by the airlines having to pay for training from the ground up, just like airlines like Cathay do with their ab initio program.
 
Soooooo, if that is your argument shouldn't the rich pay less taxes, not more in dollar amounts than the poor? Seeing as how they use government services much less frequently? I don't see many rich people using food stamps, collecting welfare or using medicare/medicaid, but then again that goes against the Democrats agenda, right because the rich are evil?

Eating and having a roof over your head isn't a hobby. Flying a Cessna on the weekends is. Little bit different. Things like food stamps are a safety net.
 
You know, GIA no longer exists. You may want to find a new weird obsession. Regardless, the US would get its pilots by the airlines having to pay for training from the ground up, just like airlines like Cathay do with their ab initio program.

Yay indentured servitude!
 
Eating and having a roof over your head isn't a hobby. Flying a Cessna on the weekends is. Little bit different. Things like food stamps are a safety net.

Well, I don't fly IFR all the time either but I still pay into the fuel tax every time I fuel up. If I land at a larger airport there is a landing fee also, so I am paying more than my fair share into the system.
 
Yay indentured servitude!

How is that indentured servitude? Sounds like a pretty good deal to me. Pass an aptitude test, have good grades in school, and get a slot at a great airline who pays for all of your training and expenses, then gives you a job. Sounds a lot better than what we do.
 
The government shouldn't be in the business of subsidizing your hobby.



You know, GIA no longer exists. You may want to find a new weird obsession. Regardless, the US would get its pilots by the airlines having to pay for training from the ground up, just like airlines like Cathay do with their ab initio program.

We aren't China. I don't want America to be like China and I don't think many here to either.

I don't have an obsession for it. You're misguided on how things are paid for in this world. Maybe if you spent some time hanging around the airpot chatting with people, instead of paying to sit in the right seat of a 1900, you'd understand where the government gets its money from. We have 100 million people in the US that don't pay federal income tax. Start with that.

Using your stupid hobby retort, why don't we charge people to drive cars? Oh wait we do, via a gas tax. We pay policemen to patrol the streets, cleaners to clean them, guys to fix roads, etc. This is why we have a gas tax, to pay for things like this. Weekend warriors aren't using the ATC system like you say they do. You have zero idea what GA because you don't do it. Stop pretending you do.
 
How is that indentured servitude? Sounds like a pretty good deal to me. Pass an aptitude test, have good grades in school, and get a slot at a great airline who pays for all of your training and expenses, then gives you a job. Sounds a lot better than what we do.

Do you honestly think an airline is simply going to foot the bill passing none of the costs back onto the trainee? Don't most Cadet programs include some sort of reimbursement clause where they pay you X each year after passing training but Y% of that goes back to the airline to cover training costs in addition to a training contract requiring a certain number of years of service or have to pay them back a early termination fee? That is called indentured servitude, no different than you paying for someone to move here then live with you and clean to work off the debt.

Also, there will even be less job mobility, read downward pressure on wages, when airlines have control of supply and demand. No need to worry about a pilot shortage or having to raise wages to attract talent, simply hire those starry eyed kids with dreams of flying a jet that now populate ATP and other puppy mills.

I see it killing the profession.
 
Maybe if you spent some time hanging around the airpot chatting with people, instead of paying to sit in the right seat of a 1900, you'd understand where the government gets its money from.

It's been a decade since I've been in the right seat of a BE1900. It would be cool to fly one again. Maybe you can subsidize my hobby and pay the rental costs for one?

We have 100 million people in the US that don't pay federal income tax. Start with that.

Ahh, I see. You want to tax the poor so they can subsidize your hobby. How magnanimous of you.

Those damn poor people. Always living the high life! :sarcasm:

Weekend warriors aren't using the ATC system like you say they do.

In that case, you should be in favor of user fees! If you don't use the ATC system, then you won't be charged. What a deal! But we all know that that's not true. You use the ATC system quite a bit. You just want to do it for a fraction of what it costs, while the airlines subsidize your hobby, and my company pays out the ass in taxes in an industry where profit margins are razor thin. Seems like you're the ones "looking out for number one."
 
In that case, you should be in favor of user fees! If you don't use the ATC system, then you won't be charged. What a deal! But we all know that that's not true. You use the ATC system quite a bit. You just want to do it for a fraction of what it costs, while the airlines subsidize your hobby, and my company pays out the ass in taxes in an industry where profit margins are razor thin. Seems like you're the ones "looking out for number one."

Ahh, so the truth comes out. If your company can pay less into the system, then there is more bargaining room for pilot wages, so more money in your, and ALPA's, pocket. Got it.

Not a problem, but just be honest, it is for purely selfish reasons you want user fees. You dont fly GA so they wont affect you, but you may be able to squeeze a few extra dollars out of your airline so it is a win win.
 
Ahh, so the truth comes out. If your company can pay less into the system, then there is more bargaining room for pilot wages, so more money in your, and ALPA's, pocket. Got it.

Not a problem, but just be honest, it is for purely selfish reasons you want user fees. You dont fly GA so they wont affect you, but you may be able to squeeze a few extra dollars out of your airline so it is a win win.

Not really about bargaining leverage. I don't expect pay raises at SWA for many years to come. It's more about stability. The airlines got screwed by the government following 9/11 when President Bush's ATSB wouldn't pay out loans to airlines that were struggling (even the ones that lost airplanes in the attacks), and the taxes keep piling up. We're forced to add numerous taxes to tickets, which force us to reduce the actual fares, because there's only a certain price point that the consumer is willing to pay. Our margins are squeezed to virtually nothing in boom times, and then the bad times hit and we lose billions upon billions. Meanwhile, GA and business aviation use the same ATC services that we do and pay a fraction of their fair share of the taxes to support it. The FAA can't get anymore funding, so NextGen languishes in development hell for decades, and there's still no end in sight. The whole thing is ridiculous.
 
Not really about bargaining leverage. I don't expect pay raises at SWA for many years to come. It's more about stability. The airlines got screwed by the government following 9/11 when President Bush's ATSB wouldn't pay out loans to airlines that were struggling (even the ones that lost airplanes in the attacks), and the taxes keep piling up. We're forced to add numerous taxes to tickets, which force us to reduce the actual fares, because there's only a certain price point that the consumer is willing to pay. Our margins are squeezed to virtually nothing in boom times, and then the bad times hit and we lose billions upon billions. Meanwhile, GA and business aviation use the same ATC services that we do and pay a fraction of their fair share of the taxes to support it. The FAA can't get anymore funding, so NextGen languishes in development hell for decades, and there's still no end in sight. The whole thing is ridiculous.

If a company is struggling then it should make changes to improve its profitability, not look to others to prop it up. User fees will kill one industry to help prop up another. To you that doesnt matter, but to folks at Cessna, Piper, Cirrus and other GA aircraft makers or flight school operators, A&P's, small airport owners who also operate on a shoe string budget it would kill them.

Your goal of pushing fees back onto them (and 91 corporate) to help your airlines profitability would backfire as tax revenue from GA would plummet. There would still be a gap in funding for the FAA, it just wouldnt be your company who is under the burden, but surviving and doing quite well despite the taxes. Well, actually it would be because once GA is dead all the taxes would get shifted back to the airlines by default.
 
I don't believe for a second that modest user fees would "kill" GA or business aviation. But as for the lost taxes you reference, the airlines pay $12 billion per year into the aviation trust fund. General aviation and business aviation pays a whopping $200 million. That's 1.6 percent of what the airlines pay, while comprising nearly 80% of all flights in this country. How anyone can claim that that is fair while keeping a straight face I'll never understand.
 
I don't believe for a second that modest user fees would "kill" GA or business aviation. But as for the lost taxes you reference, the airlines pay $12 billion per year into the aviation trust fund. General aviation and business aviation pays a whopping $200 million. That's 1.6 percent of what the airlines pay, while comprising nearly 80% of all flights in this country. How anyone can claim that that is fair while keeping a straight face I'll never understand.

I dont have the figures to reference, so hopefully you can answer or provide a link. is that 80% all flight, VFR and IFR, or IFR only?
 
If a company is struggling then it should make changes to improve its profitability, not look to others to prop it up. User fees will kill one industry to help prop up another. To you that doesnt matter, but to folks at Cessna, Piper, Cirrus and other GA aircraft makers or flight school operators, A&P's, small airport owners who also operate on a shoe string budget it would kill them.

What changes would you have proposed in the immediate wake of 9/11, a unique event that nobody really anticipated?

Loans and "bail outs" if given intelligently (and not blankly like they were to the banksters) help tremendously, just look at GM and the auto industry -- they would have gone bankrupt, lost thousands and thousands of jobs. Instead, the taxpayers gave them loans... they got back on their feet and paid them back (netting a nice profit for the US treasury) and are doing quite well now.

Don't tell me... you're going to vote for Mitt "Let Detroit go Bankrupt" Romney? ;)
 
I dont have the figures to reference, so hopefully you can answer or provide a link. is that 80% all flight, VFR and IFR, or IFR only?

That's 80% of all flights. Of course, all of those flights may not be using ATC services, but they are using runways, taxiways, and navaids that the Trust Fund also pays for.
 
How about we stop bombing 3rd world countries and funding them to have terrorist camps and hideouts....

The ATC should be covered in taxes. Everybody uses ATC. Even non-pilots. Know why? Because they ride on an airline that got their butt from Point A to Point B with the help or guidance of ATC even if they personally didn't pick up the headset and talk to them. Just like the US Mail, everybody uses it and it should be covered by taxes.


ron-paul.gif
 
Okie, I see what you're saying, but that's not how Congress funds the FAA's budget. Since the AIR21 Act way back in 2000 or so, the Trust Fund has been a "lock box," and it funds the FAA's overall activities. It doesn't come out of the general fund.
 
That's 80% of all flights. Of course, all of those flights may not be using ATC services, but they are using runways, taxiways, and navaids that the Trust Fund also pays for.

Then that metric is useless. What you need to look at is the % of total flights Airline vs Non-airline using ATC services and publicly funded airports.

Not all airports are public, many are private. It is a bit unfair to say airlines pay a lions share of revenue and use a metric that doesnt support your true issue, that they are not using the lions share of the services and instead make it look like airlines are a small fraction of flights.
 
Back
Top