Unlicensed instructors giving flight training?

Agreed, I've given an endorsement without having an instructor rating in category/class, and that was legal.

Giving instruction is fine as long as it isn't used for a certificate/rating.

In having dealt with the FAA, I would predict the following could happen with this "instructor".

1. He will be called into the local FSDO and be oral examined on part 61 requirements since he seems to have a different view about part 61 than the rest of us.

2. Those log books that he signed off for students to solo cross country will be gathered up and the FAA will catalog each and every signed solo endorsement. Each one is a violation. Each one could have been a disaster. That is not going to sit will with the FAA.

3. This guy will be fined for each and every endorsement violation the FAA does find.

4. He will be asked to surrender all of his certificates and if he doesn't they will start the process to take those certificates. If he surrenders his certificates he can start working on them again in 12 months. He would have to take each written test again and also take each practical test again.

Once the FAA has their claws into you, they usually do not let go. Frankly this guy deserves everything the FAA is going to throw his way.

On the other hand, since the flight school is not licensed, the FAA probably can not do anything to the school since the FAA has absolutely no jurisdiction over the flight school.

The sad thing is that if this bogus flight instructor was not an FAA licensed pilot, the FAA would have no jurisdiction over him and would not be able to do anything to him even if one of those cross country students had crashed a plane on a cross country. Scary ain't it? This is one loophole that really does need to be closed with these outdated decades old FAA regulations.

Joe
 
I would not expect the FAA to gain any teeth for unlicensed pilots any time soon since they don't seem to have the will to back up flight crews with random inspections of airline pax. I'd love to see an inspector write a passenger a violation for disregard of the seatbelt sign or noncompliance with crew instructions.

Fig. B-3-p. Unruly passengers
Civil Penalty
Certificate Action
(1) Interference with crewmember (14 C.F.R. 91.11, 121.580, 125.328, 135.120)
Maximum

(2) Physical assault of flight or cabin crewmember
under 49 U.S.C. § 46318
$1,100 – $8,000

(3) Physical assault of individual other than a crewmember under 49 U.S.C. § 46318
$500 – $5,000

(4) Threaten to physically assault flight or cabin crewmember under 49 U.S.C. § 46318
$1,100 – $5,000

(5) Threaten to physically assault individual other than flight
or cabin crewmember under 49 U.S.C. § 46318


$500 – $5,000

Fig. B-3-p. Unruly passengers cont.
Civil Penalty
Certificate Action
(6) Acts in a manner that poses imminent threat to safety of aircraft or other individuals on aircraft under 49 U.S.C. § 46318
$5,000 – $25,000
($5,000 - $27,500 for violations after 6/15/2006)


Fig. B-3-q. Other Violations by Passengers
Civil Penalty
Certificate Action
(1) Smoking while No Smoking sign is lighted
Maximum

(2) Smoking in aircraft lavatory
Maximum

(3) Tampering with smoke detector
under 49 U.S.C. § 46301(b)
$1,800 to
$2,200

(4) Failure to fasten seat belt while seat belt sign is lighted
Minimum to Moderate

(5) Failure to occupy an approved seat or berth with a safety belt, and, if installed, shoulder harness properly secured during movement on the surface, takeoff, or landing
Minimum to Moderate

(6) Operating a portable electronic device
Maximum

(7) Drinking alcoholic beverage not served by carrier
Maximum $850-$1,100
Moderate $650-$849
Minimum $500 $649
 
This guy's name rings a major bell with me. I wonder if he was training in the one of the flying clubs I was using when I lived in Dallas? I know I've seen his name somewhere before and potentially have met him.
 
Sooooo, He did have a commercial SEL?

I was under the impression that he can teach all he wants for money with a CSEL. With no CSEL he CAN teach, just not for money. He can't make endorsements or recommend students for certificates. Also, his students time could not count towards the required time with an authorized instructor for a certificate. For example a private pilot requires only 20 hrs with an authorized instructor.

Am I wrong?
 
Sooooo, He did have a commercial SEL?

I was under the impression that he can teach all he wants for money with a CSEL. With no CSEL he CAN teach, just not for money. He can't make endorsements or recommend students for certificates. Also, his students time could not count towards the required time with an authorized instructor for a certificate. For example a private pilot requires only 20 hrs with an authorized instructor.

Am I wrong?

I can think of at least one endorsement a PPL ASEL can give...
 
I can think of at least one endorsement a PPL ASEL can give...

Am I missing something here? What endorsement can a private pilot give without having an instructor(flight/ground) certificate/rating? Please enlighten me.

The student in the article should sue the school for endangering his life.
 
For towing gliders you need an endorsement from a pilot who has accompanied you on three tows (real or simulated). This can be a Private Pilot.

A PP can also give any of the endorsements required for a sport pilot certificate. Admittedly they also need to be a Sport Pilot instructor, but that's a long way from an instructor certificate.
 
Am I missing something here? What endorsement can a private pilot give without having an instructor(flight/ground) certificate/rating? Please enlighten me.

The student in the article should sue the school for endangering his life.

Part 61...

Glider tow endorsement, can be given by an ASEL-PPL.

I have received flight training from non-CFIs. Can't be used for a certificate or rating, but there are a lot of things worth learning you don't need a CFI to teach you (cross country soaring, mountain flying, acro, upset recovery... Lots of things I would prefer to get from someone with a lot of experience over a CFI that has none.)

I did training flights while getting my inst/ppl with pilots working on their CFI. Can't use the time towards a rating, but it doesn't mean you aren't learning something.
 
For towing gliders you need an endorsement from a pilot who has accompanied you on three tows (real or simulated). This can be a Private Pilot.

A PP can also give any of the endorsements required for a sport pilot certificate. Admittedly they also need to be a Sport Pilot instructor, but that's a long way from an instructor certificate.

That explains it. Was thinking about flight training. I'm not up to date on the sport pilot stuff.
 
Part 61...

Glider tow endorsement, can be given by an ASEL-PPL.

I have received flight training from non-CFIs. Can't be used for a certificate or rating, but there are a lot of things worth learning you don't need a CFI to teach you (cross country soaring, mountain flying, acro, upset recovery... Lots of things I would prefer to get from someone with a lot of experience over a CFI that has none.)

I did training flights while getting my inst/ppl with pilots working on their CFI. Can't use the time towards a rating, but it doesn't mean you aren't learning something.

Yes, learning things from a non-cfi can be beneficial but I would be careful using the term "flight training".
 
Any other people without a CFI in here?

Orlando FL, 7/11/2011 8:00AM SHARP at the Airport!
Everyone is welcome to attend the first "Dumb Schmuck Flight Training LLC" directors meeting to commence operations on said day.
U.S. Regulations DO NOT apply to this operation, which is headquartered in some foreign Country that may or may not exist.

Bring your favorite airplane (just rent at some of the surrounding facilities, buy lots of block time, please!
Training Operations start at 9AM Sharp! Student's pay un-certified instructors a previously agreed upon sum + rental retainer.
This is all hidden in some sort of "pro rate share, direct operation expense cluster ahem" which cannot be shared at this time.
Student logbooks are kept strictly online, with a mysterious server crash and fatal loss of all data in case of investigation or unspeakable accident.

Currently, there is a list of 1699 Flight Instructor names with Certificate #'s which can be used to falsify IACRA and other documentation.

It should take the FSDO (right next door) several months to figure it out what the hell is going on, and if no one here blows the whistle, we may all soon be Chet Pilot Chef Captains. It's only $1999.00 to join.

Opportunity knocks again, Mates! Don't let it go to the dogs! All that matters is that you have the time in your logbook, nobody cares how you gots it...

(Whoops! Disclaimer: Parody - no such school exists, and any similarity with existing operations is purely incidental. Please do not contact me per Private Message about the details. Please contact your dentist if the pain persists for more than 6 hours, or you can't sit, stand, lay down and/ or do any other stuff for more than 30 seconds)
 
training_main.gif


This image from their web page would make me not want to go there. I don't want this guy to train me for anything.

Isn´t that from a halloween costume website?
 
I checked out the site and holy crap man, they've got some creepy stock photos!
 
I checked out the site and holy crap man, they've got some creepy stock photos!
Did you check out the financial aid page? Apparently, if you go there you will immediately get a 2nd officer job so you can pay back the loans. Maybe everyone still looking for a job should just go there. ;)
 
DC-10's, 727's, DC-8's probably some old Russian jalopies, not too sure of the numbers.

When MikeD and I disappear into the Peruvian jungle to start the cargo/paramilitary operation, we're going to need loadmasters, door gunners and probably a flight engineer or two
 
Back
Top