United Airlines new portable Urinals...

Not sure about that. But, a lot of mothers have loss of bladder control, which could be relevant to the supposed urgency, as would also be the case if the lady in question was pregnant. When you have to go, you have to go, but if you are in that group, you would think planning would be a huge focus to avoid urgent situations.

I don't personally believe this story or any accounts of any women choosing to use a cup or other collection device around others rather than just run to the restroom. You can't really do that secretly...has anyone heard a girl pee?

I'm sure they did a full medical evaluation before writing the story and creating the headline.
 
Evidently the woman has had the problem for years, and her 2 children are young, so it probably pre-dates the pregnancies. She says she had spoken with an FA about her condition earlier in the flight, and I think I read of delays in the schedule. Sphincter muscles are not all created equal, female or male.

This flight was operated by Mesa, a fact that one person above mentioned, but has largely been ignored in the stories. Most of the footage used on TV news stories has featured mainline aircraft in United paint, up to and including Dreamliners. TV News editors evidently have SJS Syndrome, also.
 
Evidently the woman has had the problem for years, and her 2 children are young, so it probably pre-dates the pregnancies. She says she had spoken with an FA about her condition earlier in the flight, and I think I read of delays in the schedule. Sphincter muscles are not all created equal, female or male.

This flight was operated by Mesa, a fact that one person above mentioned, but has largely been ignored in the stories. Most of the footage used on TV news stories has featured mainline aircraft in United paint, up to and including Dreamliners. TV News editors evidently have SJS Syndrome, also.

None of this matters.

The seatbelt sign exists for a reason. Sometimes you gotta do your business even though it's on. I've done it. But if the FA says "it's ok" and then you get bounced off the ceiling it's going to be their ass.
 
None of this matters.

The seatbelt sign exists for a reason. Sometimes you gotta do your business even though it's on. I've done it. But if the FA says "it's ok" and then you get bounced off the ceiling it's going to be their ass.

This. Somewhere along the line people forgot we're hurtling through tin cans at crazy speeds through the air. Yet they want the same amenities and physics as their living room.
 
None of this matters.

The seatbelt sign exists for a reason. Sometimes you gotta do your business even though it's on. I've done it. But if the FA says "it's ok" and then you get bounced off the ceiling it's going to be their ass.

This is a conflict between an irresistible force and an immovable object. Something's gotta give.

People could exchange the laptops they can't carry on, for catheters and leg bags. Numba Two? Require colostomies and abdomenal bags. We've solved most of the airsick problem by building jets that fly at smoother altitudes, but just in case, there's that green bag in the seatback pocket. Next problem...?

Soon, somebody will build a aisle-size wet & dry vacuum, and sell an aviation version for $125K - Extruded aluminum wheelie case surrounding works from Home Depot, with anatomical input devices, storage, and Blue Ice coolant.

Holding back Mother Nature only works in the short run. Just ask the Army Corps of Engineers about how close to 100% they get with flood control.
 
This is a conflict between an irresistible force and an immovable object. Something's gotta give.

People could exchange the laptops they can't carry on, for catheters and leg bags. Numba Two? Require colostomies and abdomenal bags. We've solved most of the airsick problem by building jets that fly at smoother altitudes, but just in case, there's that green bag in the seatback pocket. Next problem...?

Soon, somebody will build a aisle-size wet & dry vacuum, and sell an aviation version for $125K - Extruded aluminum wheelie case surrounding works from Home Depot, with anatomical input devices, storage, and Blue Ice coolant.

Holding back Mother Nature only works in the short run. Just ask the Army Corps of Engineers about how close to 100% they get with flood control.

No, it's really simple.

Obey the seat belt sign when you can. If you're reaching the point where it's a matter of where vs if, just get up and go.

You can't expect the flight attendants to straight up tell people it's ok to get up when it's not.
 
No, it's really simple.

Obey the seat belt sign when you can. If you're reaching the point where it's a matter of where vs if, just get up and go.

You can't expect the flight attendants to straight up tell people it's ok to get up when it's not.

Agreed with where vs if. The ones I find annoying are the ones doing it for convenience, and of course picking the worst possible time to get up and go.

And sadly yes, if an FA happened to say its ok....even if just trying to be understanding and helpful....and a pax gets injured for even something unforeseen, what are the chances the pax will assume the responsibility for the risk they chose to take? Zero, I'd say. They would 100% try to throw the FA under the bus with "....but he/she told me it was ok!".

I seriously wonder how cabin crews maintain their sanity sometimes, what with some of the pax they have to deal with.
 
This. Somewhere along the line people forgot we're hurtling through tin cans at crazy speeds through the air. Yet they want the same amenities and physics as their living room.

That's a tough one...my living room exists in a strong improbability field where every channel on cable has a commercial and my toast always lands buttered side down on the carpet.
 
No, it's really simple.

Obey the seat belt sign when you can. If you're reaching the point where it's a matter of where vs if, just get up and go.

You can't expect the flight attendants to straight up tell people it's ok to get up when it's not.

I don't expect them to do more than a sympathetic shrug or wink at this reality-check moment. If a confluence between turbulence and urology causes injury, lawyers can fight it out, but should probably settle quickly and quietly with a win-win approach.

My problem is with those (I hope, few) FAs who yell and scream to get back in your seat and buckle up. Those regulation-over-reality Nazis are the real problem. Might as well tell a baby not to urp on the upholstery (and yes, I've had delays while maintenance replaces a seat cushion under just those circumstances).

The present climate of respect for customer service should result in training to reduce the conduct & frequency of the extremists. And that must also include the front-line supervisors.
 
I don't expect them to do more than a sympathetic shrug or wink at this reality-check moment. If a confluence between turbulence and urology causes injury, lawyers can fight it out, but should probably settle quickly and quietly with a win-win approach.

My problem is with those (I hope, few) FAs who yell and scream to get back in your seat and buckle up. Those regulation-over-reality Nazis are the real problem. Might as well tell a baby not to urp on the upholstery (and yes, I've had delays while maintenance replaces a seat cushion under just those circumstances).

The present climate of respect for customer service should result in training to reduce the conduct & frequency of the extremists. And that must also include the front-line supervisors.

Ok, but after a 16 hour workday in a cramped tube with often poor temperature control dealing with several hundred different people with several hundred requests, multiple plane swaps, rude people, non compliant passengers, pushy gate agents, being asked 80 times about connections even though its literally all over the airport and the internet, and literally being shaken, pushed and tripped while serving hot beverages.... one cant be expected to put on the happy face for every single instance of noncompliance or be threatened with national media outrage.
 
Last edited:
Ok, but after a 16 hour workday in a cramped tube with often poor temperature control dealing with several hundred different people with several hundred requests, multiple plane swaps, rude people, non compliant passengers, pushy gate agents, being asked 80 times about connections even though its literally all over the airport and the internet, and literally being shaken, pushed and tripped while serving hot beverages.... one cant be expected to put on the happy face for every single instance of noncompliance or be threatened with national media outrage.
I know one who had a medical emergency, guy had barfed in the lav sink and was sprawled across the galley floor,white as a ghost, being attended to, some guy stepped over him to use the lav, then during deplaning yelled at her for not cleaning up the puke. I really can't fathom how people can be such jackwagons.
 
I don't expect them to do more than a sympathetic shrug or wink at this reality-check moment. If a confluence between turbulence and urology causes injury, lawyers can fight it out, but should probably settle quickly and quietly with a win-win approach.

My problem is with those (I hope, few) FAs who yell and scream to get back in your seat and buckle up. Those regulation-over-reality Nazis are the real problem. Might as well tell a baby not to urp on the upholstery (and yes, I've had delays while maintenance replaces a seat cushion under just those circumstances).

The present climate of respect for customer service should result in training to reduce the conduct & frequency of the extremists. And that must also include the front-line supervisors.
Let's throw this scenario out. You're deadheading in an aisle seat, Mr. Impatient thinks the rules don't apply to him, gets up, and falls on you injuring you. Then you're potentially not going to work, not getting paid, and so on.
 
Nothing makes me stop listening quicker than "well, as a mother..." unless it actually involves kids or parenting.

Even then I've found what comes next is typically dubious content at best. To be fair, I've seen plenty of dads do this as well; there's something particularly annoying about someone trying to make a point using a natural part of being a human as relevant experience.

I think I'm going to start responding like this: "as someone who has mitochondria, I disagree."
 
I know one who had a medical emergency, guy had barfed in the lav sink and was sprawled across the galley floor,white as a ghost, being attended to, some guy stepped over him to use the lav, then during deplaning yelled at her for not cleaning up the puke. I really can't fathom how people can be such jackwagons.

People are weird and go into shock. The guy might have literally been too out of it to fathom what was going on. People do weird things because we're big dumb animals.

Of course, events like these are also why I prefer my passengers are intubated or sedated for flight /s...kind of
 
People are weird and go into shock. The guy might have literally been too out of it to fathom what was going on. People do weird things because we're big dumb animals.

Of course, events like these are also why I prefer my passengers are intubated or sedated for flight /s...kind of
I don't buy it. This was WELL after the fact.
 
I don't buy it. This was WELL after the fact.

Maybe - but people are weird. I've found life for me is a lot better when I assume people aren't coping well when they're • - and as I've found out this is mostly the case. I'm probably wrong in this case but yeah - I've seen some absolutely absurd stuff from people.
 
121.311 Seats, safety belts, and shoulder harnesses.
(a) No person may operate an airplane unless there are available during the takeoff, en route flight, and landing -

(1) An approved seat or berth for each person on board the airplane who has reached his second birthday; and

(2) An approved safety belt for separate use by each person on board the airplane who has reached his second birthday, except that two persons occupying a berth may share one approved safety belt and two persons occupying a multiple lounge or divan seat may share one approved safety belt during en route flight only.

(b) Except as provided in this paragraph, each person on board an airplane operated under this part shall occupy an approved seat or berth with a separate safety belt properly secured about him or her during movement on the surface, takeoff, and landing. A safety belt provided for the occupant of a seat may not be used by more than one person who has reached his or her second birthday. Notwithstanding the preceding requirements, a child may....

It's all spelled out right above. Pretty cut and dry and could be considered a violation by an inspector who just might be riding in the back and according to the piece they were LANDING. The problem is that most of these people only fly once a year if not a decade and once upon a time they read in Cosmo or Men's Health that you have to hydrate when you fly soooooooo two one liter bottles of water later topped off with a Venti latte we have folks who can't hold their water.
 
This. Somewhere along the line people forgot we're hurtling through tin cans at crazy speeds through the air. Yet they want the same amenities and physics as their living room.

X-0491-200.jpg


It wasn't always about 17" wide seats and 28" of seat pitch, with flight attendants who shout at people trying to use the bathroom. There is a better way!
 
Not sure about that. But, a lot of mothers have loss of bladder control, which could be relevant to the supposed urgency, as would also be the case if the lady in question was pregnant. When you have to go, you have to go, but if you are in that group, you would think planning would be a huge focus to avoid urgent situations.

I don't personally believe this story or any accounts of any women choosing to use a cup or other collection device around others rather than just run to the restroom. You can't really do that secretly...has anyone heard a girl pee?
I'm not going to argue whether she may a medical problem or not, but if she knew about this why did she fly? Did she think the airline revolves around her and would change standard procedure and safety laws because she has bladder control issues?

It baffles me the logic of people. This new world of "ME, ME, ME" is getting real old.
 
Back
Top