United 93

Status
Not open for further replies.

FlyingNole

New Member
I was wondering if anyone here has heard the ATC tape between Cleveland Center and United 93 on 9/11.

A few months after that horrible day my friend sent me the recording. Although it sounded chopped up/edited, the one thing I'll never forget is the pilots screaming on one of the transmissions.

After: "United 9-3 checking in flight level 3-5-0" there was a shrill and what sounded like one of the pilots screaming "get out! Get out of the cockpit!"

Following multiple calls from center, the next thing we hear from 93 was something about "remain in your seats...we have a bomb on board"

What I'm wondering is, did I get a copy of the transmission that most people were not supposed to hear? Or was it a fake edit? I ask this because I tried to download the clip again (from multiple sites) and the screaming part is missing.

I hate listening to it, and it gets me angered and upset when I hear it, but I was trying to play it for a friend, and the "new" clip seemed a lot more toned down.

Anyone have any info on this? Does anyone have the sound clip I'm talking about?


I'm sorry if this upsets anyone, I was curious as to if there was some sort of prior restraint used by the government in editing the screaming out before the general public could hear it.
 
The term "morbid curiosity" comes to mind....



grin.gif
 
Funny Steve, and ya I guess there is some morbid curiosity. Kind of like watching a train wreck even though you really don't want to.

I dont care about the sound byte, just if those screams were real or fake, and if someone made a point to cut them out.
 
Considering I knew LeRoy Homer from OBAP, (the FO on UAL 93), your curiosity is a little disturbing.
 
I dont want to anger anyone, my cruiosity is based on whether someone didn't want us to hear what I heard.

It sucks, I feel for everyone that was involved, or knew them. I wish it never happened
 
One of my good mates lost his wife and his daughter on that date - those events are something I think we should all just let be, and not keep bringing them up.
 
Ok, once again. Not really where I wanted a post to go.

A simple:

"It was an edit" or "I don't know where you got that clip" would have sufficed.


once again I'm sorry for upsetting everyone.
 
See that is the edited copy I was talking about. I don't buy into the consipracy theory stuff, but it sucks. I get chills just hearing the edited version.

I made a mistake though, the last transmission before the screams is "negative contact, we're looking"....However in the version you sent to me, Center responds "someone call cleveland?" However no one made an unusal call in that clip. Yet it seems that there definately was a transmission I was speaking of, because another UNited and American aircraft claimed they heard "yelling" over the comm.
 
Anyone who says they know, probably doesn't.

Besides, it's pretty easy in 2005 to edit almost anything. Want to buy some gin-u-wine pictures of Gore and Bush playing dueling pianos at Howl At The Moon in Orlando?
 
[ QUOTE ]
Want to buy some gin-u-wine pictures of Gore and Bush playing dueling pianos at Howl At The Moon in Orlando?

[/ QUOTE ]

Mmmmmm. $.05 beer.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I hate listening to it, and it gets me angered and upset when I hear it,

[/ QUOTE ]

And the reason you want it is.....
banghead.gif


[ QUOTE ]
but I was trying to play it for a friend

[/ QUOTE ]

And he can't look for himself because......

[ QUOTE ]
I'm sorry if this upsets anyone,

[/ QUOTE ]

By making this statement, it seems that you knew this was going to upset more than a few people here.
confused.gif
Commonsense would be in order here. I don't know of one person that this would not upset here. I know you are new here, but think for a second before you press the enter key.
 
well if there was a better way of asking a group of pilots about this, I would have done it.

And I've been on this thing for over a year, I just screwed up at first by mentioning the $$$ issue. Obviously it's a sore spot with a lot of people, so I did my self in from the get-go.
 
[ QUOTE ]
well if there was a better way of asking a group of pilots about this, I would have done it.

And I've been on this thing for over a year, I just screwed up at first by mentioning the $$$ issue. Obviously it's a sore spot with a lot of people, so I did my self in from the get-go.

[/ QUOTE ]

Water under the bridge.

About the 93 tape, that's a fair question. I don't know if the actual 93 tape has been released, in the sense that the NTSB rarely releases actual cockpit voice recordings, but will always release a transcript (like you read in the back of the accident reports). It's true that today, recordings of anything can likely be altered, and in that sense, I'd consider the source of where the recording came from. But the question is interesting since we still really don't know what actually happened aboard 93. I'm not talking the shoot-down conspiracies, but am referring to what actually happened onboard regards whether pax actually ever had control of the aircraft, whether they ever really made it into the cockpit, and/or whether the terrorists deliberately crashed the plane, or not.
 
[ QUOTE ]
NTSB rarely releases actual cockpit voice recordings, but will always release a transcript

[/ QUOTE ]
The tape he is refering to was an ATC transcript, not the CVR. The CVR has NOT been released. I have heard the "tower tape" he is talking about and it is, to say the least, disturbing. One of our planes was included in the transcript and heard the transmission also.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
NTSB rarely releases actual cockpit voice recordings, but will always release a transcript

[/ QUOTE ]
The tape he is refering to was an ATC transcript, not the CVR. The CVR has NOT been released. I have heard the "tower tape" he is talking about and it is, to say the least, disturbing. One of our planes was included in the transcript and heard the transmission also.

[/ QUOTE ]

Ah. Well that explains it. Thanks.
 
Yeah, I was wondering about that too, I've heard a 'recording' of the CVR from 4184, but it's just people reading the transcript. It's not the actual crew themselves.


And yes, we are rather touchy about 9/11. Some of us lost friends, co-workers, and even our careers that day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top