Top Ten Airlines

olkev

New Member
I'm an outsider looking in. Always been interested in aviation, even thought about it but could not afford all of the training and my eyes weren't/aren't the greatest. My dad was a corporate pilot, I have a private pilot ticket but haven't flown in a long time. I mention this as I don't have a a dog in the fight but, as an enthusiast I am wondering . . .

I see a lot of pilots talk of the poor pay at the regionals. (Frankly I'm shocked at the pay given the responsibility and the training required). The difficulty getting hired by the majors. I think many long for the days of the 60's - 70's not only in terms of pay but in the conditions as well. Flying seemed to be more of an event rather than a roundup and loading cattle, if you get my drift.

According to Skytrax, the Top Ten Airlines list has none from the United States. Most are Pacific rim with three from the Middle East and Africa.

Why don't carriers from America make the list? What do the foreign airlines do that US carriers can't or won't and why?
 
I'm an outsider looking in. Always been interested in aviation, even thought about it but could not afford all of the training and my eyes weren't/aren't the greatest. My dad was a corporate pilot, I have a private pilot ticket but haven't flown in a long time. I mention this as I don't have a a dog in the fight but, as an enthusiast I am wondering . . .

I see a lot of pilots talk of the poor pay at the regionals. (Frankly I'm shocked at the pay given the responsibility and the training required). I think many long for the days of the 60's - 70's not only in terms of pay but in the conditions as well. Flying seemed to be more of an event rather than a roundup and loading cattle, if you get my drift.

According to Skytrax, the Top Ten Airlines list has none from the United States. Most are Pacific rim with three from the Middle East and Africa.

Why don't carriers from America make the list? What do the foreign airlines do that US carriers can't or won't and why?

The majority of customers don't care about service anymore, unless by somehow complaining about it they can get some more free miles. The majority of American's see air transport differently that 90% of the globe, which may not be a terrible thing, it's just different.
 
Bottom line. As a CEO how am I going to show a profit to my beloved shareholders. Cut meals(done). Charge for checking a suitcase(done). Tell the fuel companies and dispatchers to give the pilots the minimum to save $$$(done). Have only one gate agent to work a flight(done). Etc. Americans seem to be okay with this as long as we can catch a round trip ticket from JFK-LAX for $99 each way.
 
Also, these top 10 airlines offer their plots better terms and conditions that US pilots could only dream of... Why? They are profitable! Why are they profitable? Their ticket prices are not cheap, they have a personality, and care about service, and do not nickle and dime passengers. Their passengers are willing to pay for service weather in coach, business, or first. A colleague of mine works at a middle east carrier, and was explaining that their ticket prices are 10-50% higher than their US competitors in all classes on the same route. Yet have a higher load factor!

I still do not understand why US carriers or US passengers are willing to make 3 stops on an NYC -> Florida flight to save 5 dollars. Now that AMR is in bankruptcy, maybe they will figure this out!

Cheers!
 
Also, these top 10 airlines offer their plots better terms and conditions that US pilots could only dream of... Why? They are profitable! Why are they profitable? Their ticket prices are not cheap, they have a personality, and care about service, and do not nickle and dime passengers. Their passengers are willing to pay for service weather in coach, business, or first. A colleague of mine works at a middle east carrier, and was explaining that their ticket prices are 10-50% higher than their US competitors in all classes on the same route. Yet have a higher load factor!

I still do not understand why US carriers or US passengers are willing to make 3 stops on an NYC -> Florida flight to save 5 dollars. Now that AMR is in bankruptcy, maybe they will figure this out!

Cheers!

Nope. It's not just raising ticket prices. History has shown that consumers will look for the bottom dollar almost every time on leisure routes. It's hard to stay individual in this industry when every single carrier offers the same product and similar pricing structure. Increasing the value of the same far paid at other airlines is going to seperate the winners and losers. The airline industry turmoil is a product of it's own being. Theres so much competition, it's just a matter of time till people start ticking off in existance and some supply gets reduced. Until then, welcome to the spiral to the bottom.

One thing I always find interesting is how every airline views fuel as a fixed expense, it will always be there. However, labor is discreationary. Airlines and management have no problem just accepting the fact that fuel is (insert price here) and then bitch they need concessions from the labor group. Maybe one day the employee group can have the testosterone to pretend to be united and insert their fixed price just as something that doesnt have existance can do. Wait, the bankruptcy courts wont allow that...I forget, the issue here isn't just the airlines and the management, it's the practices allowed by our own government.

We are the child of our own capitalism and free market theory. It gets dirty when the bottom line is chased.
 
I just had this debate with my brother last week.The way I see it? If you want good service with a smile purchase the more expensive ticket in first or business class on one of the 5 legacy airlines. If you think about it, that is what a standard coach ticket cost back in the day when the airlines actually charged the cost to operate the flight. If the public demands cheap tickets then that's exactly what they'll get.
 
Why don't carriers from America make the list? What do the foreign airlines do that US carriers can't or won't and why?

Federal subsidies in most cases. Looser (or no) labor laws in some cases. Different societal expectations in most.
 
Federal subsidies in most cases. Looser (or no) labor laws in some cases. Different societal expectations in most.

Also a great point, are continually subsidized in many countries by their government as opposed to US models where we, the government, subsidizes the airline by bailing them out after they've failed in one big lump sum.
 
People have the ridiculous notion that they're going to get white glove, Singapore Airlines A380 service, first class, from Dallas to Lubbock if we just relax cabotage laws. All for a sweet $49 fare.

More like Virgin Nigeria with a burned out A300b6 (if you're lucky) with a Kazakhstani PFT crew.
 
I've flown business class on some of the more "prestigious" foreign airlines in the past 6 months (Cathay, Emirates, JAL, Lufthansa) and also the oft maligned US legacies (AAL, DAL, UAL). I find the difference in service levels to be overhyped. In fact, I think business class service is often BETTER on US airlines (especially those with only 2 classes of service, making business the highest).

I know, some people will call me delusional for saying that, but the difference is really not as huge as most pundits make it out to be. The main difference is the appearance of the F/A's; yes they are almost always very attractive young females on the asian/middle eastern carriers, but that doesn't necessarily equate to better service (only eye candy).

The catering is as good if not better on the US lines and the F/A's are often more attentive, believe it or not. Plus there is just something nice about being able to communicate in plain English with the cabin crew.

In my mind, the main benefit of flying on the asian carriers, especially in J or F, is that the load factors are often insanely low (I was the only business class customer on a JAL flight between ICN and NRT last week on a 763 with 30 seats up there). This give you a ton of space and a lot of attention from the cabin crew.

In economy, again, the difference between foreign and domestic carriers is really minimal to non-existent in my experience.

Overall I would compare the bashing of US airlines' service to the bashing of the domestic auto industry.....really there are plenty of good american cars out there; they just aren't as stylish, popular, or "classy" as a BMW or Mercedes. The US brands have been damaged by decades of bashing through the media and word of mouth, whether justifiable or not.
 
I'd agree with that.

It used to cost $300 to fly from Visalia, CA to San Francisco, CA in the 1970's. Adjusted for 2011 currency from 1978 when I flew the trip, it's roughly the equivalent of ~$1,500 in today's dollars.

But if you charged a fare of $1,500 (in 2011 dollars) to fly from SFO to DFW, people would stroke-out and demand congress preserve their constitutionally-protected right to fly cheap.

Bag fees, which I think are brilliant because they generate ancillary revenue are under attack by DC. Hell, why not have Congress declare illegal exorbitant charges for cheese on a hamburger. A slice of American Cheese (-product) surely ain't valued at $1.25 at the local brewpub. I demand cheaper cheese!
 
Hell, why not have Congress declare illegal exorbitant charges for cheese on a hamburger. A slice of American Cheese (-product) surely ain't valued at $1.25 at the local brewpub. I demand cheaper cheese!

Andy Clement would agree with you. However he'd just bring his own.
 
Bottom line. As a CEO how am I going to show a profit to my beloved shareholders. Cut meals(done). Charge for checking a suitcase(done). Tell the fuel companies and dispatchers to give the pilots the minimum to save $$$(done). Have only one gate agent to work a flight(done). Etc. Americans seem to be okay with this as long as we can catch a round trip ticket from JFK-LAX for $99 each way.

It doesn't seem like most US airline CEOs are interested in making money for the company. As long as they get their bonus checks, everything is gravy.
 
I just had this debate with my brother last week.The way I see it? If you want good service with a smile purchase the more expensive ticket in first or business class on one of the 5 legacy airlines. If you think about it, that is what a standard coach ticket cost back in the day when the airlines actually charged the cost to operate the flight. If the public demands cheap tickets then that's exactly what they'll get.

Customer Service need not be something that costs "extra." Amazon has fantastic customer service, and lower prices generally. Being innovative is a good way to make money and win customers too.

I mostly sit up in First, but wouldn't say the service is worth the price in most cases (I am not paying for it either though)
 
I think one of the issues that prevents the US carriers from getting into the top ten is the fact that they have a domestic network. The domestic product is what most are basing their opinions on. The people demanded cheap air travel and that is what they got. Internationally I have had very pleasant flights on US carriers in BusinessFirst, especially CAL. However, F class on my airline is a whole different animal as it is still a real F premium product.
 
Also, these top 10 airlines offer their plots better terms and conditions that US pilots could only dream of... Why? They are profitable!

Don't be so sure. Companies on the top 10, like Etihad for example, have never been profitable.
 
Back
Top