Too Disabled to Fly

GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (WOOD) - Johnnie Tuitel has criss-crossed the country hundreds of times as a motivational speaker; racking up about 500,000 air miles over the past couple years.

But the Grand Rapids man, who has used a wheelchair almost his entire life, has never been asked to fly with a companion. And that's exactly what he says happened when a U.S. Airways agent told him he's "too disabled to fly by himself" and asked him to exit the plane before takeoff.

Tuitel, who has cerebral palsy, boarded a flight from West Palm Beach International Airport on Sept. 23. He was heading out to speak at the 2010 National Self Advocacy Conference in Kansas City.

When he checked in, the airline agent offered to help him board the plane. After he was seated, the employee came back and told Tuitel had had to get off the plane, he said.

"I immediately thought something was up with my family," he told 24 Hour News 8 on Thursday. "I let him take me off the plane -- didn't know why, a little apprehensive, a little confused. He proceeded to tell me, he said I am too disabled to fly by myself."

Tuitel eventually arrived in Kansas City through Delta Airlines with no problem, but missed his speaking engagement.

On its website, U.S. Airways says: "For safety-related reasons, if a passenger has a mobility impairment so severe that a person is unable to physically assist in his or her own evacuation of the aircraft, U.S. Airways requires that the passenger travel with a safety assistant" at their own expense.

Tuitel understand the policy but said he thinks it's overreach.

"We're sitting together on a plane, something happens -- are you going to help me?" he asked. "Of course you are."

Tuitel flies alone to keep costs down, he said. He believes it was a personal decision by the agent who changed his mind about Tuitel's disability when he seated him on the plane. The incident goes beyond violating the American Disabilities Act, said Tuitel, who is considering legal action.

"This is a flat out issue of civil rights," he said.

US Airways confirms that it did receive a complaint but says the flight information Tuitel put in his press release does not match their records.

The airline says it is in their discretion to determine if a passenger needs a companion.

A spokesperson says in this case it was concern by the airline agent, a manager who assisted Tuitel and a flight attendant.

Tuitel is also the author of the Gun Lake Adventure Series of children's books.

"We're sitting together on a plane, something happens -- are you going to help me?" he asked. "Of course you are."

Um, no. He's probably never figured out that most people are selfish and self-preservationists when it comes to emergencies. I think he has a 50/50 shot at getting help or trampled.
 
"We're sitting together on a plane, something happens -- are you going to help me?" he asked. "Of course you are."

Um, no. He's probably never figured out that most people are selfish and self-preservationists when it comes to emergencies. I think he has a 50/50 shot at getting help or trampled.


I agree with you 100%. If it's that severe that he needs help boarding, then he needs an assistant, thats it. Although he probably has figured it out, he chooses to believe everything will be alright, and is taking his chances on that. I say let him fly, and if he ends up getting trampled to death in an emergency, then it's his fault, not the airlines. Because you know if the airplanes on fire and he's blocking the only exit, he WILL be moved out of the way. Whether it's of his own doing, or him being moved out of the way forcefully, he will move. And thats if he can even make it to the door on his own.
 
Wow. I had lots of wheelchair folks travel by themselves.

Just because someone is in a wheelchair doesn't mean they're an imbecile!

Often, people in wheelchairs are quite capable of "assisting in their own evacuation". They can pull themselves, yell, grab, unbuckle their seatbelts, and listen to & follow instructions. That, to me, IS "assisting in their own evacuation". Now, someone who is catatonic or a full-out quadriplegic who can't move at all.. then I can understand how they really would need a travel companion. But being in a wheelchair doesn't automatically make someone completely helpless.

We (Eagle) used to transport the U of I wheelchair racing team from BMI to ORD. Those men were strong, aware, and perfectly capable of traveling alone. They needed an aisle chair to get from their wheelchairs plane-side through the aisle of the plane to their seat row, but once they got to their seat row, they needed NO assistance at all to get from the aisle chair to their seats. Those guys had arms and abs of steel.
 
Wow. I had lots of wheelchair folks travel by themselves.

Just because someone is in a wheelchair doesn't mean they're an imbecile!

Often, people in wheelchairs are quite capable of "assisting in their own evacuation". They can pull themselves, yell, grab, unbuckle their seatbelts, and listen to & follow instructions. That, to me, IS "assisting in their own evacuation". Now, someone who is catatonic or a full-out quadriplegic who can't move at all.. then I can understand how they really would need a travel companion. But being in a wheelchair doesn't automatically make someone completely helpless.


I whole heartidly agree with your post. But judging from the video, it appears that he is handicaped enough that someone has to physically put him in his seat. So this one passes the sniff test. While not catatonic, it seems as though he can not move around w/out his wheelchair, and would be stuck in his seat should an emergency arise. BTW, yelling and un-buckling your seatbelt shouldn't count as assisting yourself. You are still stuck in your seat at that point, and just making a lot of noise.
 
Back
Top