TOC

FOD

Well-Known Member
I have always used the Time, Fuel, Distance chart to figure where my TOC is at. A checkairmen where I work was saying to use the TFD chart for the fuel and time, but not the distance, since this will change with wind. If thats the cause then what is the appropriate way to figure confused distance?

P.S- I have used the TFD chart in the past for getting fuel and distance, then used the E6B for the time based on winds. Have I been doing this all wrong?
 
I think I figured it out. If so, I was wrong and he was correct. But, will still be looking for comments. Interested in seeing what everyone else does.
 
What kind of airplane are we talking about? If we're talking the typical piston, I think your check airman is adding a correct, but unnecessary factor into the picture. The TFD chart assumes zero wind. But it is there for you top make the calculation based on the information it provides. If you are going to use it at all, there's no good reason to use it only partially.

Your check airman is correct that the distance will change based on the wind conditions. But how much? Run some realistic numbers and take a look. Then consider that the winds for the calculation are forecast, not real, that you'd need to correct for surface winds up to about 1500' and then aloft winds above that, that you will have to have perfect airspeed control, that you will only take off in the direction of travel and that you will never maneuver for traffic on that initial climb.
 
Use your E6B. The time/fuel/distance chart is predicated on climbing at a constant airspeed right???.....so take that airspeed, factor in the winds, and that will give you you're ground speed and distance traveled.

Now, that being said, the chart isn't really all that accurate. It assumes that you are traveling in a straight line and usually climbing at Vy. Well if you are trying to go west, but taking off to the east and tower has you continue out for a while or something, all of a sudden it is not that accurate. Also, you never really climb at Vy either. You are usually climbing at some higher cruise climb speed which is different and thus will yield different climb rates and fuel/time/distance results.

It's more of an FYI kind of chart...
 
And let's not forget that time-honored disclaimer about how the performance data comes largely from flying the aircraft brand new with test pilots.
 
[ QUOTE ]
It's more of an FYI kind of chart...

[/ QUOTE ]I agree (although the chart does need to be used as a training exercise) . It's all estimated anyway. I think the real purpose of the chart is as a check on performance. If based on the density altitude you should be climbing at a certain rate at a certain airspeed, and you're substantially off, it's a sign that something may be wrong.

During my primary training, my CFI told me to forget about calculating =anything= for the climb. Just do the normal ground speed/WCA and add 1 minute to the first leg for each 1000' feet that you need to climb to cruising altitude. The rule of thumb has never missed.
 
I teach my studs to use the TOC chart for planning purposes. If you plan a flight manually, using the TOC chart, it's amazing how close those numbers will cometo a plan from an off-the-shelf piece of flight planning software.
 
Back
Top