Tipping the Van Driver?

Yes bellmen, bartenders and concierges at the NY Marriott Marquee could make over $100,000 a year. Why, tips? We make WAY more than min wage based on our hourly pay, but we are still poor as dirt, just above the poverty line.

Van drivers might make 30,000 a year without tips, add tips it can go up to 50,000 and a livable salary.

That kinda money in MEM will get you a 4 bedroom 3 bath house with a pool. Not every where is the Northeast. $50K is much more than a "liveable salary" down here. Same for places like RIC, CLT, EVV, TYS, etc. Ya know, the places PCL goes. It's not all ALB and HPN. :)
 
I worked at a restaurant while in high school first as a cook, then as a waiter. About 6 months into the job as a cook I told the boss I was leaving for a better paying job unless he paid me $X/hr. Guess what happened, he paid me more money, because I was worth two of the people that worked with me (they were lazy, I was not).

So, your justification for everybody being able to renegotiate is when you were living with mom and dad in HS, you negotiated a $0.50 raise as a cook?

You know as well as I do that renegotiating your pay rate as a hotel front desk clerk is a completely different ball game then renegotiating your contract under the RLA, so you trying to make the connection just well, is stupid.

Apparently, you are not understanding my logic...I am saying you, as pilots, are skilled labor. It takes a lot of money to train you, and have supposed quality employees, than it does a front desk clerk. Most places, if you go in there and say "I'm leaving if you don't pay me $X, then I'm leaving", especially at a low skill job, will say good luck. Have fun at the new job.

If the front desk clerk or mx guy was hired to be a front desk clerk or mx guy, he will be paid a wage that reflects not getting tips. If he gets tips for doing a good job, bonus, that's gas money. My issue, again, is tipping for poor service. If you automatically tip a guy for being late, not warming the van up, etc. where's the motivation to do better? C'mon, I'm not being evil, I'm being realistic. I'm just saying what others are thinking. You can hang me out to dry, but I know there are other people that feel the same way.

Let me tell you a little story...when I first started this run, it was interesting. I always overnight in MDW on Saturday. When I get in, it's usually 0230L, and the airport is dead. I always called the FBO ahead of time, giving them arrival times, even though they know when I was due to get in. The first month, it was like pulling teeth to get a ride to the hotel. I would walk over to the FBO, have to find chalks, etc., and then finally 20 minutes later, I'd be heading to the hotel. I always tipped them anyways, since it's expected, whether you believe in it or not.

Fast forward another two months. We are getting into winter. Now, I still call in to the FBO, and guess what, the van is waiting for me where I park, I have chalks provided (instead of wandering the ramp looking for some to "borrow") by the guys, and the van is always nice and warm.

Why the difference? Was it because it was starting to turn to bad weather? NO. I was tipping, and let them know what I wanted every time. They finally got a clue and the service has been great for MDW (at least on Saturdays, other days are a whole different ballgame :banghead: ).

Now, let's expand on this for a whole pilot group. Your flight arrives at the same time, different crews, but same flight and airline. Some tip, but most don't. How's your service been???

As far as the mx guy running the van, yes, he gets an hourly wage, more than likely. He also has a job to do. Maintain the grounds, rooms, etc. Now, throw in a bunch of crews who gripe and moan about everything, and don't tip while not letting him finish his work. How much thought will you put in to warming the van, stopping your work that must be finished before you go home, and providing whatever else those "elitist, cheap pilots" want. I know after a while, I'd get pretty tired of it, and would provide minimum service.

Also, I'm not trying to hang you out to dry, just trying to understand each other.
 
That kinda money in MEM will get you a 4 bedroom 3 bath house with a pool. Not every where is the Northeast. $50K is much more than a "liveable salary" down here. Same for places like RIC, CLT, EVV, TYS, etc. Ya know, the places PCL goes. It's not all ALB and HPN. :)

Yeah, but Kell, those places are also more than likely near-minimum wage jobs, unlike the bellman in NY, where the COL is outrageous. I know you're hurting and don't have the money for tipping, so I won't get too deep here, but comparing the salaries Seggy is talking about and the COL at each place is like comparing apples to oranges.
 
So, your justification for everybody being able to renegotiate is when you were living with mom and dad in HS, you negotiated a $0.50 raise as a cook?

Well, it was more like $2.50/hr, but who's counting? I was able to negotiate because I was worth the extra money, and I had another job lined up. Good call with demeaning me by saying I was living with mom and dad though.

Most places, if you go in there and say "I'm leaving if you don't pay me $X, then I'm leaving", especially at a low skill job, will say good luck. Have fun at the new job.
I don't agree, IF this person is a good worker and deserves it.

Another story - my fiance told her boss she was leaving for a better paying job. She was offered an $8,000 raise, and she was an "unskilled" secretary. She still left, because she didn't want to continue being a secretary, but you get the point. That's one of the benefits of the non-union world.

Think about it - if you owned a business manufacturing, let's say, chairs. You have 5 employees @ $10/hr, 4 average 20 chairs per day. 1 averages 30. The fast guy comes to you and wants a raise to $12/hr, do you say no? He is worth his salary, even though he isn't "highly" skilled. He works harder, gets more done, and makes you more money. It's a win-win.

Let me tell you a little story...
Hold on, I need to wipe this tear from my eye.

How much thought will you put in to warming the van, stopping your work that must be finished before you go home, and providing whatever else those "elitist, cheap pilots" want. I know after a while, I'd get pretty tired of it, and would provide minimum service.
I guess that's the difference in our thought processes then. I absolutely refuse to encourage bad service. In the service industry, it's his move that gets him tipped. You prefer to tip and hope the service improves. I see a conflict of interest with that, and chances are it won't improve.

I would rather have a heart to heart talk with the guy, tell 'em if he can be there on time he'll get tips for doing so.
 
Well, it was more like $2.50/hr, but who's counting? I was able to negotiate because I was worth the extra money, and I had another job lined up. Good call with demeaning me by saying I was living with mom and dad though.

I don't agree, IF this person is a good worker and deserves it.

Another story - my fiance told her boss she was leaving for a better paying job. She was offered an $8,000 raise, and she was an "unskilled" secretary. She still left, because she didn't want to continue being a secretary, but you get the point. That's one of the benefits of the non-union world.

Think about it - if you owned a business manufacturing, let's say, chairs. You have 5 employees @ $10/hr, 4 average 20 chairs per day. 1 averages 30. The fast guy comes to you and wants a raise to $12/hr, do you say no? He is worth his salary, even though he isn't "highly" skilled. He works harder, gets more done, and makes you more money. It's a win-win.

Hold on, I need to wipe this tear from my eye.

I guess that's the difference in our thought processes then. I absolutely refuse to encourage bad service. In the service industry, it's his move that gets him tipped. You prefer to tip and hope the service improves. I see a conflict of interest with that, and chances are it won't improve.

I would rather have a heart to heart talk with the guy, tell 'em if he can be there on time he'll get tips for doing so.

As much "fun" as I have with our discussions on here, I will just leave this alone. You are in a fantasy world, where all unskilled labor can just demand whatever they want. You have your ways, I have mine. Look at the poll, btw, and notice who doesn't tip. I wonder who has more life experience and who gets the better service usually???

I was not demeaning you by saying you lived with your parents. You said "...I worked at a restaurant while in high school first as a cook, then as a waiter. About 6 months into the job as a cook I told the boss I was leaving for a better paying job ..." and I put two and two together. Most people in HS live at home (not all, but most). My point by saying this was you had a roof over your head, very few, if any bills, etc. Now, the discussion was talking about desk clerks, van drivers, and mx people. Most are no longer in HS, and, as such, are comparing apples to oranges.

Have fun with this. We will have to agree to disagree with this one.
 
You are in a fantasy world, where all unskilled labor can just demand whatever they want. Y

I never said "unskilled labor can demand whatever they want" but they can certainly receive raise increases if it is warranted. If you're a lazy slacker who doesn't do anything then no, I would say you cannot ask for a raise.

Now, the discussion was talking about desk clerks, van drivers, and mx people. Most are no longer in HS, and, as such, are comparing apples to oranges.

Oh OK, so since I was in high school I was better able to get a pay raise? Now you are making sense.
 
You sure it's not:
To
Insure
Proper
Spelling ??? :D

Thanks for the meaningful contribution, Chris. You got anything better to do, like argue the finer semantics of logging time? Let's see you be perfect on the spelling game after a 3 day adventure in ice and strong crosswinds with a reduced rest overnight tacked onto the end. We can't all be playboys living the high life, ya know. :)
 
Thanks for the meaningful contribution, Chris. You got anything better to do, like argue the finer semantics of logging time? Let's see you be perfect on the spelling game after a 3 day adventure in ice and strong crosswinds with a reduced rest overnight tacked onto the end.

Let me call the wahhhhhhmbulance for you. :)

There is a time for improper spelling. Unfortunately, that time was February 30th. What with modern calendar changes, there will be no rest.
 
Hell i'm not an airline pilot, but i believe in tipping.

Brings me to a case where i was running late in a limo (by myself) but he was on his 30 minute break (it was an unscheduled leave) so i tipped him 30 bucks and said if he could please take me to so and so. He dropped his food, blushed and handed me back the tip. He became so embarrassed that I offered him the money, he said it's his job to drive me, that's why his company is getting paid. He took me regardless of the situation. I did manage to give him the tip after about 5 minutes of telling him i want him to have it.

Anyways
 
I always tip, but kinda resent having to do it while Im at work knowing that the van driver makes twice as much as I do. When I take a shuttle from the parking lot to the terminal, I happily tip, because it is my choice to commute and they are doing me a service. But when I have an overnight in ORD and Im there because of work, I think that the company should pick this up. It'll never happen, but this is an interesting topic.
 
On this current topic, what's up with getting stiffed by flight attendants? I've loaned money to 3 flight attendants so they could tip the van driver and only 1 ever paid me back. Next time I'm just gonna tell them I only have a single dollar bill.
 
On this current topic, what's up with getting stiffed by flight attendants? I've loaned money to 3 flight attendants so they could tip the van driver and only 1 ever paid me back. Next time I'm just gonna tell them I only have a single dollar bill.

Where are you based?
You might just say no problem, you can cover me in the morning. Then, in the morning ask them to take care of your tip. They will either have money for their own tip in the am or they will ask again, when you can say, (in a friendly way) Hey you were going to take care of me today! I have fronted and been fronted and it has never been a problem. Don't be a victim! Remind them you are a first year FO; that should shame them into taking care business.
 
On this current topic, what's up with getting stiffed by flight attendants? I've loaned money to 3 flight attendants so they could tip the van driver and only 1 ever paid me back. Next time I'm just gonna tell them I only have a single dollar bill.

Wow. Surprised Seggy hasn't jumped in with a "You should try flying without a flight attendent!" comment. :) Mark, you know I love ya.
 
Joining this thread REALLY late, but.....

...I always tip the van driver, unless they are extremely late picking me/us up from the airport (generally after 30 minutes = no tip).

I really could care less that they could/do make more than me. In fact, with first year regional pay, it's not going to be that hard for someone to make more than me. ;)

That said, a server at a restaraunt probably makes more than I do, but I still tip them.

But, that's just me.
 
Back
Top