I only visit those establishments once.I'm the same way. I don't particularly care for the forced gratuities some restaurants impose either. On more than one occasion, servers have, in my view, taken advantage of this and have just given piss poor service because they knew regardless of what happened, they'd get a 18% tip from everyone at the table. One time that happened, I made the manager remove the forced gratuity.
Even on cruises, I make them take off the automatic gratuities. I tip the room steward, wait staff, bar staff, etc. personally. It works out better for them when they do a good job. Last year our wait staff was phenomenal. We left the waiter and his assistant each $100 from each of us. Considering normally they would have gotten $3/day/person, I'd say they probably preferred the personal tip.
-mini