Time Logging Question

When it says you can log sole manip in any aircraft you're rated in, it means 'rated'. A CFI signoff to fly a particular model of airplane is not a rating. A rating is what it says on your pilot certificate. If your pilot certificate says airplane single engine land, then you can log PIC anytime you are sole manipulator of the controls in a single engine land airplane. That includes any single engine land airplane which does not require a type rating. Go up for an hour with a buddy in a C210, you can legally log it. Go up for an hour with a rich Cougar in her Pilatus PC12, you can legally log it. Do an hour in a Stearman, you can legally log it.

Now that I've written that, the joy police will be along to remind you of all the wonderful and quite hypothetical reasons why you shouldn't log any of it even though its perfectly legal to do so. Suffice it to say that I do not agree with their reasoning and I have yet to meet anyone personally whose career was ruined due to logging this type of time.
explain to me what EXACTLY is a type rating. I am vaguely familiar with the term but after you mentioned SEL as a rating i got confused.

Say with the 767. the 767 is the TYPE and i have to be 767 rated to fly that particular aircraft. Am I correct? That means that even though i may have a MEL rating, i have to get a 767 MEL rating.....becasue the 767 is a TYPE of MEL aircraft.

It seems with the exapmle above, that the 767 aircraft is way too complex to be considered as just an MEL aircraft and therefore one must have TYPE rating for it. I think I understand. Am i correct in my thinking process?
 
Let me get this straight; I have a SEL certificate with taildragger endorsement. My wife, a SEL pilot but no taildragger endorsement, and I take off in a Cub. She flies from chock to chock so I never touch the controls. We fly for 2 hours even so we each log 2 hours PIC.

Oh, I forgot; it's Tuesday and there is a full moon that night, so did we land with enough reserve? :)
 
explain to me what EXACTLY is a type rating. I am vaguely familiar with the term but after you mentioned SEL as a rating i got confused.

Say with the 767. the 767 is the TYPE and i have to be 767 rated to fly that particular aircraft. Am I correct? That means that even though i may have a MEL rating, i have to get a 767 MEL rating.....becasue the 767 is a TYPE of MEL aircraft.

It seems with the exapmle above, that the 767 aircraft is way too complex to be considered as just an MEL aircraft and therefore one must have TYPE rating for it. I think I understand. Am i correct in my thinking process?

A type rating is generally required for aircraft weighing 12,500 lbs or
more, jet aircraft, and certain other specific aircraft. Therefore, if I want to fly a Piper Twin Comanche, a MEL rating is sufficient. However, if I want to fly a Boeing 737 (as PIC), a type rating is required IN ADDITION to the basic MEL rating.
 
Let me get this straight; I have a SEL certificate with taildragger endorsement. My wife, a SEL pilot but no taildragger endorsement, and I take off in a Cub. She flies from chock to chock so I never touch the controls. We fly for 2 hours even so we each log 2 hours PIC.
She logs two hours PIC, you log nothing.
 
Let me get this straight; I have a SEL certificate with taildragger endorsement. My wife, a SEL pilot but no taildragger endorsement, and I take off in a Cub. She flies from chock to chock so I never touch the controls. We fly for 2 hours even so we each log 2 hours PIC. under 61.51(e)9i)
Berkut is right. Your wife logs 2 hours PIC under 61.51(e)(i).

You log zip because there isn't a 61.51 box you fit into.

Forget "what makes sense" in the global sense. These rules are completely artificial and reflect only one thing - how the FAA has decided to let people count time toward certificates, ratings, qualifications and currency. They don't mean anything more than than.

Oh, I forgot; it's Tuesday and there is a full moon that night, so did we land with enough reserve? :)
Even on Tuesday with a full moon.
 
I would hazard a guess and say this is one of those rare moments when it is possible to ACT as PIC and NOT log it.

The real question is...are you really NOT going to log it as PIC?
I don't know. I guess the real question is ... are you going to follow the rules as they are or figure, "what the heck, I'll falsify my logbook; they'll never find out anyway."

I know my choice. Yours may vary.
 
The answer to that one is pretty obvious.

But, unless the 61.51 box you are in says acting as PIC matters, it's irrelevant to the logging question.

I disagree about the irrelevancy since it pertains directly to the topic thread. As pointed out in previous responses there is a difference between logging PIC and acting PIC. In this scenario, I was the PIC even though my not-qualified-to-act-as-PIC wife was flying the aircraft.

This particular scenario was about taildragger endorsements, but it is exactly identical under the regulations as the high power and complex aircraft endorsements.

I was attempting to be funny, but this same scenario was real and took me a few months to resolve several years ago (before that Internet thing really took off!) when talking to several Feds. Some gave conflicting answers which only goes to show even the Feds can be wrong (they're not Prophets, after all, just folks).
 
It seems we have lost sight of the forest by narrowing our focus down onto a couple of trees, ie. 61.51 Logging PIC, and 1.1 Being PIC, which is also called Acting PIC; The Actual PIC.

If the Actual PIC is not also the Sole Manipulator (or CFI'ing), he/she cannot Log under any of the 61.51 regs.

The main community dis-agreement on the 61.51 logging of PIC time when the sole manipulator is not really the Sole Manipulator. In other words, he/she is not at least trying to act as PIC. In this context, I am using the term "Act" as a training term He/She is 'acting' (training, but not legally Acting) as PIC. Making PIC decisions, handling all conditions, etc. while 'manipulating the flight controls.

So, it really comes down to the pilot logging as to whether or not he/she can honestly say he/she was 'acting' (as in training) as PIC.

That's what it comes down to in a later interview. If you logged 50 hours in a 210 as PIC and you flew them as if you were the PIC, then you will demonstrate the 50 hours of knowledge and skill as if you had the endorsement.

But if the PIC Actual plans the flight, does the T.O. and gets the airplane on the way and lets you be his 'autopilot' while he mainly executes the flight, and you 'hold the controls' for 50 hours and log it PIC, that's the kind of logged PIC time that is not valuable beyond the first couple of times.

Aaand, in my honest opinion, it violates the spirit of the law.
 
So, suppose I'm acting as PIC, but I'm letting my pax fly. Then NOBODY gets to log PIC time! :insane:


...is that the "spirit" of the law?
 
I disagree about the irrelevancy since it pertains directly to the topic thread.

But, unless the 61.51 box you are in says acting as PIC matters, it's irrelevant to the logging question.

You misunderstood. It's not irrelevant to the thread. It's irrelevant to whether you are permitted to log. Logging PIC under 61.51(e)(1)(iii) and 61.51(e)(2) are the only PIC logging rules where "acting as PIC" comes into play.
 
So, suppose I'm acting as PIC, but I'm letting my pax fly. Then NOBODY gets to log PIC time! :insane:


...is that the "spirit" of the law?
Actually, there is an unpublished Chief Counsel opinion I came across (and have never been able to verify) that says that despite the wording of the reg, if there is only one rated pilot on board, that pilot may log the time without being the sole manipulator.

==============================
June 22, 1977

Mr. Thomas Beane

Dear Mr. Beane:

This letter is in response to your recent letters to the FAA Flight Standards Service and to the Chief Counsel inquiring about the logging of pilot-in-command (PIC) time by an airman whenever he is not the sole manipulator of the controls.


Section 1.1 of the Federal Aviation Regulations defines Pilot in Command as:

Pilot in command means the person who:

(1) Has final authority and responsibility for the operation and safety of the flight; (2) Has been designated as pilot in command before or during the flight; and (3) Holds the appropriate category, class, and type rating, if appropriate, for the conduct of the flight.

Section 61.51(c)(2) of the Federal Aviation Regulations provides, in pertinent part:

(2) Pilot-in-Command flight time.

(I) A private or commercial pilot may log as pilot in command time only that flight time during which he is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which he is rated, or when he is the sole occupant of the aircraft, or when he acts as pilot in command of an aircraft on which more than one pilot is required under the type certification of the aircraft, or the regulations under which the flight is conducted.

A pilot may log PIC time in accordance with Section 61.51(c)(2)(I) when he is not actually "flying the airplane", if the airplane is one on which more than one pilot is required under its type certificate or under the regulations under which the flight is conducted and he is acting as PIC. Also, a pilot, rated in category and class (e.g. airplane single-engine) could, as the pilot who "Has final authority and responsibility for the operation and safety of the flight" log PIC time if another pilot, not appropriately rated, was actually manipulating the controls of the aircraft.

It should be noted that more than one pilot may log PIC time for the same flight time. For example, one pilot receiving instruction may log PIC time in accordance with paragraph (c)(2)(I) for the time he is designated PIC, and another pilot may log PIC time in accordance with (c)(2)(iii) for the same time during which he is actually giving flight instruction.

We hope that we have satisfactorily responded to your inquiry on the proper logging of PIC time.

Sincerely,

ORIGINAL SIGNED BY EDWARD P. FABERMAN

for NEIL R. EISNER Acting Assistant Chief Counsel Regulations & Enforcement Division Office of the Chief Counsel -
==============================
 
Ah, I feel better now. :D
I'm sure you were worried..

But if you're curious, here's

The Unofficial, Unvarnished, and Totally Made-Up Truth About the Bane "Only Rated Pilot On Board" Opinion
(The names have been changed to protect the innocent and guilty alike)

One day the lawyers at the FAA went out drinking after work and started talking about the logging rules (hey, they're lawyers; you were expecting them to talk about something interesting?). One of them said, call him Joe, said, "Can a pilot log PIC time if he lets his dog fly the airplane?"

Betty, who was a real stickler for strict readings, replied, "No. Since the dog had its paws on the controls, the pilot wasn't the 'sole manipulator of the controls.' So he can't log anything."

Peter rolled his eyes and said, "I know these rules are a bit convoluted, but really! That is the stupidest thing I ever heard! OF COURSE the pilot can log the flight! He's the ONLY ONE who can!"

"So what?" said Betty. That's what the reg says!"

"Oh BULL!" he said, "The guys who wrote 61.51 couldn't cover EVERY possible situation. A flight in which NO ONE can log PIC is ridiculous.

Fortunately, in addition to being sensible, Peter really knew his stuff. "There's a rule of law that's been around for a long, long time. It applies to both statutes and regulations." Peter continued, "'An interpretation that would lead to an absurd or unreasonable result should be avoided.' A flight on which NO ONE can log PIC is absurd."

The others had to agree.
 
So, it really comes down to the pilot logging as to whether or not he/she can honestly say he/she was 'acting' (as in training) as PIC.

That's what it comes down to in a later interview. If you logged 50 hours in a 210 as PIC and you flew them as if you were the PIC, then you will demonstrate the 50 hours of knowledge and skill as if you had the endorsement.

Ah yes, the ominous 'later interview' that everyone is always so worried about when this topic comes up. Here's my take on it. Let's say that back when I had 100TT, I had the opportunity to fly some trips with someone in their C210 and I ended up logging 30-50 hours of time even though I didn't actually have a HP or complex endorsement. But I flew the trips with the guy, did the takeoffs, did the landings, tuned the radios, the whole bit.

I've heard over and over in these discussions that if I were to do what I described above, I'd better count on getting asked about later in a job interview, and I'd better be able to tell the interviewer all about the planes systems or they'll put me on some sort of blacklist and I'll never work in the industry again. :sarcasm: But here's the thing. At this point in my life, if someone asked me for v speeds for a plane I haven't flown since I had 200TT, I wouldn't have the slightest hope of being able to tell them. If they asked me about the gross weight or total/usable fuel in each tank, I'd be just as clueless. And I'm talking about planes where I actually was PIC. I just couldn't do it. Those sorts of facts and figures go out of my head almost as soon as the wheels are in the chocks. Heck, I couldn't tell you the gross weight, v speeds or fuel burn for any plane that I flew more than 50 logbook hours ago.

But as I've said all along, hours get you jobs. Period. If 50% of the airlines out there will throw out any non acting as PIC hours, that means the other 50% won't care. And very few of the part 91 or 135 employers are going to care at all. And even if they do throw out the non-acting-as-PIC hours, so what? So make sure you have at least 50 over mins before you apply for any job at a company where they might care about such things. For most people, that's going to mean working an extra month at whatever job you're working at before you start applying to 121 operators. If having those 50 hours get you your first job that much quicker, you'll still come out way ahead of the game time and money wise.


Aaand, in my honest opinion, it violates the spirit of the law.
The regs are what they are. The text is very clear and pretty easy to understand once you parse it all out. If the hours are legal, they're legal. Period. In situations like this, trying to understand and adhere to spirit of the regs are not my responsibility or concern.
 
In situations like this, trying to understand and adhere to spirit of the regs are not my responsibility or concern.
...especially when they are someone else's personal interpretation of what the spirit of the regs should be.

My take is that after 30 years (probably more) of consistent interpretation, it is the spirit of the regs.
 
...especially when they are someone else's personal interpretation of what the spirit of the regs should be.

My take is that after 30 years (probably more) of consistent interpretation, it is the spirit of the regs.

Yes, you're right. I should have made that disclaimer before, if I didn't. This is how I think it should be. Not that my personal opinion is really that important, but frankly the FAA's take on logging flight time is really messed up. But as the cliche goes, it is what it is.

Good luck! And log away!
 
Back
Top