This is why pax don’t like flying on prop planes

I know very little about helicopters.

Is that mostly due to hard landings? Where do you get structural damage on helos?

Flights at high Gross weights over years, track & balance within acceptable norms but still near limits, harmonic resonance, just general vibrations…

MSPUs have made a massive change in the amount of observed fatigue tracking in components and really expanded the understanding that just because something is far away from the shaky parts, doesn’t mean it isn’t being structurally damaged.

You can readily exceed limits in many cases, and the aircraft will survive, but the post maintenance required will be driven by a summery examination of a lot of data provided by computers.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 
Flights at high Gross weights over years, track & balance within acceptable norms but still near limits, harmonic resonance, just general vibrations…

MSPUs have made a massive change in the amount of observed fatigue tracking in components and really expanded the understanding that just because something is far away from the shaky parts, doesn’t mean it isn’t being structurally damaged.

You can readily exceed limits in many cases, and the aircraft will survive, but the post maintenance required will be driven by a summery examination of a lot of data provided by computers.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

This is why Robinson Helicopters require a complete teardown and airframe overhaul every 2,200 hours (vibration/ operator induced damage) or 12 years (corrosion and life limited components like rubber). Even the airframe is disassembled and stripped to bare metal for magnetic particle inspection and the aluminum components get dye penetrant.
 
This is why Robinson Helicopters require a complete teardown and airframe overhaul every 2,200 hours (vibration/ operator induced damage) or 12 years (corrosion and life limited components like rubber). Even the airframe is disassembled and stripped to bare metal for magnetic particle inspection and the aluminum components get dye penetrant.

I’d believe it. Low cost of assembly and maintenance doesn’t come without a to be paid price.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
This is why Robinson Helicopters require a complete teardown and airframe overhaul every 2,200 hours (vibration/ operator induced damage) or 12 years (corrosion and life limited components like rubber). Even the airframe is disassembled and stripped to bare metal for magnetic particle inspection and the aluminum components get dye penetrant.

same with Airbus/Eurocopter/Aerospatiale and whatever new name they will become. Their line of birds have the big inspections every 600 hours and at the 12 year. I think we own one of the highest hour ones in our fleet at TUS, at something like 16,000ish. I’m not a particular fan of their line of aircraft, but they are popular.
 
I concur. In a previous life I did NDT for a propeller shop (FAA repair station). If anyone flies propeller airplanes and hasn’t visited their local prop shop - I highly encourage it. All kinds of voodoo and sorcery happening.

Also, Hartzell had a similar problem to the original post with their steel hub systems, including at least one blade separation that penetrated a Commander 500 fuselage and killed someone.
I also used to work in a prop shop years ago as a Level II NDT inspector, but we didn't work on "small" props. Most of our stuff was surplus military, C-130/P-3/all of the DC piston powered airplanes/ and warbirds, mostly Hamilton Standard. I worked exclusively on prop controls but the stuff the prop shop did was pretty amazing. I remember just after I started I walked in and there was what looked like a pile of mud on a pallet in the shop, upon closer inspection it revealed a prop that had been driven into the ground at high speed. The crash had formed the spinner into a "skin" of the dome and hub. It was a P-51 propeller so the customer decided to salvage it. The blades were all twisted and to me it looked like scrap. They took it apart, annealed the blades, straightened them, retwisted them, ran them through the NDT process, ground off any defects, overhauled the hub and dome and balanced it. It looked brand new when it left the shop. I was flabbergasted and knew I was probably in the right place for at least a little while.
 
I also used to work in a prop shop years ago as a Level II NDT inspector, but we didn't work on "small" props. Most of our stuff was surplus military, C-130/P-3/all of the DC piston powered airplanes/ and warbirds, mostly Hamilton Standard. I worked exclusively on prop controls but the stuff the prop shop did was pretty amazing. I remember just after I started I walked in and there was what looked like a pile of mud on a pallet in the shop, upon closer inspection it revealed a prop that had been driven into the ground at high speed. The crash had formed the spinner into a "skin" of the dome and hub. It was a P-51 propeller so the customer decided to salvage it. The blades were all twisted and to me it looked like scrap. They took it apart, annealed the blades, straightened them, retwisted them, ran them through the NDT process, ground off any defects, overhauled the hub and dome and balanced it. It looked brand new when it left the shop. I was flabbergasted and knew I was probably in the right place for at least a little while.

The largest we regularly worked on were Beech 1900/99 propellers, and the 5 blade Hartzell props off of Air Tractors and Irish Concords. Occasionally we'd get a Hamilton Standard off of a T-6 or Stearman, but only disassembled it and shipped it off to another vendor that specialized in Hams.

NDT is almost a secret society that not many people know about. I really enjoyed working in that field.
 
The largest we regularly worked on were Beech 1900/99 propellers, and the 5 blade Hartzell props off of Air Tractors and Irish Concords. Occasionally we'd get a Hamilton Standard off of a T-6 or Stearman, but only disassembled it and shipped it off to another vendor that specialized in Hams.

NDT is almost a secret society that not many people know about. I really enjoyed working in that field.
The cool thing about NDT is, if your situation is correct, someone else gets to take apart and clean what you're going to inspect. Nice and clean, easy peasy.
 
Back
Top