It's not that "No pilot can do no wrong" It's the immediate assumption that any pilot who goes outside and arbitrary norm (sick call, flight ops, etc) is wrong and is up to no good. From managers it becomes expected from the pilot group, there is whole host of studies that show when an employee works remotely their boss(es) have a large tendency to view that employee as less than effecient. Pilots are almost the poster child for "remote employee". What has my interest piqued here is a line pilot(s) willing to throw another pilot and themselves under the bus for the sake of making a manager's job easier. That's all blanket policies, like an attendance policy, do. They simply take the job of managing your employees needs, errors, corrections and advancements and make a book do the work.