Is Cogscreen really a smoke screen?
I want to go out on a limb, speculate and suggest that this is less about cognition and more about confidence.
The six neurocognitive psychological tests to include COGSCREEN AE, Trails A/B; Stroop Test; CCPT, PASSAT, Wisconsin Card Sorting Test that collectively cost about $4000 are really a subterfuge, a diversion, a smoke screen to give this an illusion of an objective looking process. When in fact, determining mental fitness for flight is all a subjective decision that will be made by the HIMS trained AME.
Do a Google search to find studies that show a correlation between taking anti-depressants and loosing cognitive function. I found one. There might be more, but my point is that there should be lots and lots of studies suggesting this correlation. If it were really a problem, we would hear more about it, see it first hand and State Bureau of Motor Vehicles should be very concerned about people driving cars while taking anti-depressants.
If we could see our cognitive test results, I suspect most, if not all of us, would all fit under the normal bell curve. What would this say with regards to who should get a special waiver to fly? Nothing.
I can find no objective way to measure depression, no complex algorithm, no neat number scale and a chart. Depression as I’ve read is determined by a list of symptoms. Someone has to make the subjective judgment.
The HIMS trained AME has to decide if each applicant is mentally fit to fly and whether that applicant has the confidence of the AME and worth the risk of the signoff as a sponsor . The FAA will grant a special waiver based on this recommendation. The test results will get anonymously added to a huge data base, then archived.
Comments?