To some people, an airplane is an airplane. To some pilots 65K is a raise, especially if you are coming from a regional. What would you rather do? Make 30-35K flying a Beech or Metro in crappy weather with no autopilot and no flight attendant; or make twice that flying a modern jet aircraft above the weather, and be able to ring the call button and get a copy of coffee or bottle of water.
Unfortunately, you may be right....look at Extra (casino express) and Allegiant's payscales; they seem to have enough pilots. This isn't a dig at Allegiant or Extra, just an observation.
However it can't be denied that, as a group, the folks flying the big jets for the big bucks have an interest in ensuring that the the rest of the pilot population not fly big jets, or even small jets for little bucks.
How does this put Doug and Don at odds with the average pilot? I don't want to fly any plane for "little bucks", although some would argue that I already am. I would have zero interest in flying for skybus, especially at that propsed payrate, and I dare say most of my contemporaries would feel the same. I make more than that flying a plane 1/3 the size....and I already feel like I'm close the bottom of the barrel as far as airline wages go. There are pilots making double what I make flying planes half the size of the ones I fly.....
Personally, I think anyone with the qualifications to be an airbus street captain should have the common sense to know they're hurting the profession by flying an an A319 at that payrate. Someone with those kind of qualifications should have an easy enough time finding a better job.....
One need look no further than the mainline RJ scope clauses to find evidence of that. If the mainline pilots had their way, all the guys at the regionals would be zipping around in 30 seat turboprops for the rest of their careers, thereby denying those guys a chance to have a decent career. Why should I as a little guy, support that?
If mainlines hadn't scoped out RJ's, many of the current RJ pilots would be at the majors instead of the regionals....the furloughs after 911 at Delta, USair, American, Continental, Northwest, Independnce, Mesaba and others might have never happened, or at least they would've been a lot less severe. After 9/11, you more or less had RJ's flying ex-mainline routes in response to the reduced demand that occured in a lot of markets.....regionals were hiring while their mainline partners furloughed.
The mainline pilots that want strong scope clauses are looking out for the "major airline career", and if that's your goal, then they're helping you. If not, then yeah, it's probably not helping you. For the vast majority of regional pilots, I would venture to say that a "major airline career" is the goal.