Should gliders have transponders and mode c?

Sorry, that argument holds as much water as a screen door in a submarine.

Sec. 91.113

Right-of-way rules: Except water operations.
(b) General. When weather conditions permit, regardless of whether an operation is conducted under instrument flight rules or visual flight rules, vigilance shall be maintained by each person operating an aircraft so as to see and avoid other aircraft. When a rule of this section gives another aircraft the right-of-way, the pilot shall give way to that aircraft and may not pass over, under, or ahead of it unless well clear.
....
(2) A glider has the right-of-way over an airship, airplane, or rotorcraft;

Seems pretty clear to me.
 
good you looked that reg up, you can quote it the next time there is a midair that a simple transponder could have prevented.

It isn't that I think transponders are a bad idea, just that it really isn't practical right now. Transponders that are small enough to physically fit in a glider's panel are hard to come by. They also drain so much power that they are likely to go out during a flight (hence, they will end up getting turned off to conserve power for the vario)

ADS-B is probably the better long term solution, but even the airlines are complaining about having to pay for adopting it.

And finally, glider-turbojet midairs are incredibly rare. I think the money would have a bigger safety impact if spent elsewhere.
 
Too Bad. That is like a bungee jumper complaining the rope is too heavy or interferes with the fall.


That is ridiculously absurd. According to your interpretation, that would be gliding without a glider, or parachuting without a parachute.



Sec. 91.113

Right-of-way rules: Except water operations.
(b) General. When weather conditions permit, regardless of whether an operation is conducted under instrument flight rules or visual flight rules, vigilance shall be maintained by each person operating an aircraft so as to see and avoid other aircraft. When a rule of this section gives another aircraft the right-of-way, the pilot shall give way to that aircraft and may not pass over, under, or ahead of it unless well clear.
....
(2) A glider has the right-of-way over an airship, airplane, or rotorcraft;


Seems pretty straightforward to me, perhaps what we have here is an over dependency on technology, does TCAS and Mode C transponders assist in traffic avoidance? Absolutely. However I would venture to say that there has been way more midair's and near midair's involving TCAS and Mode C equipped aircraft than any incidents involving gliders.

Perhaps a little common sense on all sides of the aviation spectrum and we could easily mitigate the proposed "problem."
 
Seems pretty straightforward to me, perhaps what we have here is an over dependency on technology, does TCAS and Mode C transponders assist in traffic avoidance? Absolutely. However I would venture to say that there has been way more midair's and near midair's involving TCAS and Mode C equipped aircraft than any incidents involving gliders.

Perhaps a little common sense on all sides of the aviation spectrum and we could easily mitigate the proposed "problem."

Assuming functioning tcas and proper responses, point me in the direction of mid airs with tcas II equipped aircraft.

You have skywest in your name, so I assume you fly into Denver frequently. How many gliders have you seen coming down the tomsn and ramms arrival? There is a slew of them up there near daily, and near impossible to spot.
 
Perhaps a little common sense on all sides of the aviation spectrum and we could easily mitigate the proposed "problem."
You mean common sense like turning on a transponder? Common sense like installing a transponder and making due with a shorter glide?
Turbines were mandated to install TCAS in order to improve safety, and yes it cost a lot of money. No one is asking gliders to install TCASII, we are asking that you to use equipment that others can see you with.

No one said gliders didn't have right of way. But I'm sure both sides would prefer a jet see a glider at 5 miles instead of 1/4 mile.
 
I don't know that I buy the composite being invisible to radar. I was in a Remos LSA out over Tampa Bay at about 500 and approach asked me what the plane was made from. They then asked me to shut the transponder off, to see if they could pick me up as a primary target, all while no more than probably 8 or so miles from MacDill. They said they could get a primary return, so I think they do bounce something back.
Carbon fiber is partially radar reflective, fiberglass is not. What they most likely saw as return from your LSA was the engine.
 
Depends where they are operating. If they are in a busy arrival corridor or routinely have aircraft whizzing by, it'd be nice. If they are in an area surrounded by cornfields for 100 miles and the only other thing flying around are birds and bugs, let em' be.

I would agree with that. I do believe they need a transponder with mode C when they are soaring near any controlled or busy field. For example they do some soaring maybe 30 miles South of SLC right around some of the arrival gates. I really hate when ATC tells me they have a primary target only and it is believed to be a glider. All it takes is a good thermal and they might be up near me at 13 or 14000 feet.
It makes me nervous every time.

Switching the subject just a bit, I believe that mode C transponders are good idea for everyone in a powered aircraft. Yeah it costs more to do it, but it is still cheaper than a midair.

Just today going into Saint George we had several aircraft on TCAS that were mode A only. So I can tell where they are, but not how high. One got kind of close to us and because it took some time to get them to talk on the radio and to actually aquire them visually we altered our course just to be safe. No big deal, but mode C would have been helpful.
 
You mean common sense like turning on a transponder? Common sense like installing a transponder and making due with a shorter glide?

Many glider pilots have never used a transponder. To them, installing a foreign piece of equipment in an aircraft that isn't required to have it involves as much common sense as installing a toaster oven in your jet. It'd be handy every now and again but most of the time it's simply pointless.

But I'm sure both sides would prefer a jet see a glider at 5 miles instead of 1/4 mile.

Very well said. I think that's something upon which everyone can agree.

We're each entitled to our unique opinion. I've seen the issue from the cockpit of a jet and the cockpit of a glider. To me, it seems that the cost and complexity of mandating ALL gliders at ALL times to be equipped with Mode C outweighs the benefit. How about a compromise by saying that gliders operating above certain altitudes or within certain distances from certain airports should be equipped? That seems pretty reasonable.
 
Well let's just make every airplane, vintage, glider, light sport, ultralight, hang glider, trike, gyrocopter, balloon have them... and use them all the time, even when not required by the FARs. :sarcasm:

The FARs say when a transponder/ mode C (and soon ADS-B) is required. A Katana C1 is just as (in)Visable as a glider, but if in class G < 10,000 MSL it can turn it off if it wants... Singling out gliders makes NO sense.

(Bandit, just quoted you 'cause you were the next one up...)
(Just re read my first post and the FARs and gliders do not need them for that section above... Long night at work)

You're right, they should be installed in any aircraft that conflicts with faster traffic or in higher density areas.

Just because the FARS say you can do something doesn't make it safe. Not all jets have great visability. The 727/737 have huge blind spots out in front and below it. Also how much time do you think we would have to avoid a glider if it was 5sm and haze. Maybe a second or two if we are lucky.

the average jet has the same number of sectionals on board as the average glider has transponders on board.

LOL

Weight is not really the issue - more often than not I am putting ballast in gliders.

If there were an easy way to put transponders in gliders, I would be all for it. The reality is that they consume more electricity than a solar panel can power reliably. And they are expensive.

I don't think it would matter anyway. The biggest risk of midairs for gliders is with other gliders. Otherwise, it is in the traffic pattern, where a transponder isn't going to help you.

Gliders are not actually that hard to spot, no more so than other aircraft. And they almost always have radios. If you make traffic calls, they will tell you where they are (or ask a tow plane if they are in the area - they will know too)

Knowing where to look for them helps as well. If you see cumulus clouds with a dark, well defined concave base near a glider port, there is a good chance there are multiple gliders beneath it.

TCAS receives all the transponders around and can prevent a conflight in the pattern and prevent a jet from descending on top of lower and slower traffic. It also is a usefull tool in helping to know where to look. Given just a hazy sky you could have a hard time spotting a 747 that isn't in a contrasting color.
 
Midlothian is within the mode C veil of the DFW area. I don't know the specific regulations for equipment requirements for gliders, but I do think all aircraft within the mode C veil should be required to have it.

Another problematic area near Midlothian is the TSA gliderport. The GPS 34 approach into Arlington has a course reversal outbound leg of 4 NM from ESIKE. This brings IFR traffic within 2-3 NM from that gliderport.
 
Midlothian is within the mode C veil of the DFW area. I don't know the specific regulations for equipment requirements for gliders, but I do think all aircraft within the mode C veil should be required to have it.

Another problematic area near Midlothian is the TSA gliderport. The GPS 34 approach into Arlington has a course reversal outbound leg of 4 NM from ESIKE. This brings IFR traffic within 2-3 NM from that gliderport.

They were out of the TSA gliderport which is just out side of the class B. I know the area well and went a ways west of the gliderport. I went to Midlothian schools as a kid and was invited out to the gliderport back in 1980 and rode in a glider and the tow plane some, it was a lot of fun.

As far as the FARs see below, from 91.215.

1) All aircraft. In Class A, Class B, and Class C airspace areas;
(2) All aircraft. In all airspace within 30 nautical miles of an airport listed in appendix D, section 1 of this part from the surface upward to 10,000 feet MSL;
(3) Notwithstanding paragraph (b)(2) of this section, any aircraft which was not originally certificated with an engine-driven electrical system or which has not subsequently been certified with such a system installed, balloon or glider may conduct operations in the airspace within 30 nautical miles of an airport listed in appendix D, section 1 of this part provided such operations are conducted--
(i) Outside any Class A, Class B, or Class C airspace area; and
(ii) Below the altitude of the ceiling of a Class B or Class C airspace area designated for an airport or 10,000 feet MSL, whichever is lower; and
 
Back
Top