Should gliders have transponders and mode c?

Corporate Pilot

Well-Known Member
I came back from KILE to KADS today and over Midlothian there were 3 gliders. I saw 2 of them but not the third. Approach was giving me traffic reports for them on primary targets only
 
Depends where they are operating. If they are in a busy arrival corridor or routinely have aircraft whizzing by, it'd be nice. If they are in an area surrounded by cornfields for 100 miles and the only other thing flying around are birds and bugs, let em' be.
 
I didn't vote because it depends on where they operate. If it's anywhere near busy airways, the it'd be a smart idea. But if it's in the middle of nowhere land, let 'em be.
 
Depends where they are operating. If they are in a busy arrival corridor or routinely have aircraft whizzing by, it'd be nice. If they are in an area surrounded by cornfields for 100 miles and the only other thing flying around are birds and bugs, let em' be.
First, if they are near a busy corridor.....they shouldn't be there in the first place. EVER.
Second, even if they are in the middle of a 100 mile corn field, they should still have an operating xponder/C. Period.

I don't have a beef with gliders, but the "battery" excuse is lame.

Cubs are painted bright yellow for visibility but rarely fly higher than 1000 AGL. Gliders are usually white, very hard to see, appear motionless in flight and are not rare in the teens. I would prefer to have a sporting chance at avoiding them in a jet.
 
Depends where they are operating. If they are in a busy arrival corridor or routinely have aircraft whizzing by, it'd be nice. If they are in an area surrounded by cornfields for 100 miles and the only other thing flying around are birds and bugs, let em' be.

I should have said that it was near Class B airspace, DFW.
 
I think most aircraft should have transponders. I nearly hit a C180 that did not have a transponder in a Cj2.

It doesn't really have much to do with gliders. Other than the fact they don't have a way to recharge a battery.

It is just another reason to stay vigilant and keep doing a visual scan instead of totally relying on TCAS.

Here is some reading:

http://jeremy.zawodny.com/blog/archives/007288.html
 
I guess it depends where they are operating like almost everyone else said. Where I did my did my training, other aircraft were just vectored around the "glider operations area" so it was never a large problem.
 
They can get pretty thick at times, ELM, UNV, etc. Pretty much anywhere. I would like to see transponders.
A biz jet hit one not too long ago out west. IIRC, fatal for the glider, but may be wrong. Fractional Jet maybe? To lazy to look it up.
 
"Unless otherwise authorized or directed by ATC..." (Powerful statement)
and 91.215...

5) All aircraft except any aircraft which was not originally certificated with an engine-driven electrical system or which has not subsequently been certified with such a system installed, balloon, or glider—

(i) In all airspace of the 48 contiguous states and the District of Columbia at and above 10,000 feet MSL, excluding the airspace at and below 2,500 feet above the surface; and

(ii) In the airspace from the surface to 10,000 feet MSL within a 10-nautical-mile radius of any airport listed in appendix D, section 2 of this part, excluding the airspace below 1,200 feet outside of the lateral boundaries of the surface area of the airspace designated for that airport.

They have their rules... <10,000 MSL, <2,500 AGL, > 10 nm away from class B surface area or under 1,200 AGL then NO. Otherwise YES (unless authorized by ATC)
 
Regarding the battery problem, it would be interesting if it could remain charged with a small solar panel (the dashboard battery trickle-charge type) or ram air turbine. The most cost effective solution would probably be to just remove the battery and charge it between flights.

The biggest problem I see is battery + transponder + mode c encoder = more weight and MONEY.

Edit: I'm voting yes, because I think if a smaller combination transponder/mode c encoder unit were offered specifically for the glider market it wouldn't be as big of a deal.
 
I came within 500' laterally of a glider along a ridgeline, IFR, in radar contact with ATC on a passenger-carrying flight. ATC never saw him.

They really really need to have transponders with mode C. Same goes for hot air balloons.
 
I voted no, because well, why make them go to Mode C, when in less than 10 years ADS-B is going to be mandatory for a good portion of the country?
 
I voted no. There are always going to be isolated incidents of near-midair collisions with gliders but how many near-midairs have occurred where both aircraft were equipped with Mode C? Take a gander at the historical data.

The logic behind the glider exemption in the quoted regulation is that the vast majority of glider operation takes place in uncontrolled airspace over sparsely populated areas. In addition to that, it seems like anyplace a glider has ever operated is depicted as a gliderport on the sectional chart.

Adding things like transponders, batteries, wind generators, etc. greatly increases weight and drag, both mortal enemies of the glider.
 
They can get pretty thick at times, ELM, UNV, etc. Pretty much anywhere. I would like to see transponders.
A biz jet hit one not too long ago out west. IIRC, fatal for the glider, but may be wrong. Fractional Jet maybe? To lazy to look it up.
Not fatal for the glider pilot, the airframe was a loss though. It was a Hawker and an ASG-29 near Carson City, NV.

Another angle on the Transponder thing with gliders: they are not certified with electrical systems. Radios, gps, ect., for standard airworthiness certificates need to be "non-permanent" installations. Frankly, until there is a mid-air with a glider and a 121 aircraft I don't see the FAA doing anything. I chose to fly with a transponder, but to mandate that a club, or commercial operator install and maintain them in their fleet (which will most likely never be above 5000 AGL) would be an undue burden.
 
I voted yes...There's no reason not to have them installed in gliders today. I am sure they have the technology for a small solar rechargable battery to run the xpndr.

I almost ran over one in the Saab years back near SCE/UNV.
 
I voted yes...There's no reason not to have them installed in gliders today. I am sure they have the technology for a small solar rechargable battery to run the xpndr.

I almost ran over one in the Saab years back near SCE/UNV.

Well let's just make every airplane, vintage, glider, light sport, ultralight, hang glider, trike, gyrocopter, balloon have them... and use them all the time, even when not required by the FARs. :sarcasm:

The FARs say when a transponder/ mode C (and soon ADS-B) is required. A Katana C1 is just as (in)Visable as a glider, but if in class G < 10,000 MSL it can turn it off if it wants... Singling out gliders makes NO sense.

(Bandit, just quoted you 'cause you were the next one up...)
(Just re read my first post and the FARs and gliders do not need them for that section above... Long night at work)
 
Yes. Gliderports on sectionals are easier to spot than gliders in the air. I always seem to get traffic alerts approaching Tuscon from the Northwest (as do some of the 121 carriers) and never heard anyone report them in sight.
 
In addition to that, it seems like anyplace a glider has ever operated is depicted as a gliderport on the sectional chart.
.

the average jet has the same number of sectionals on board as the average glider has transponders on board.
 
Back
Top