Roger Cohen, former Regional Airline Association President

SpiceWeasel

Tre Kronor
So this guy comes across my LinkedIn profile and it turns out the guy who advocated so vociferously that regionals pay well during the Colgan inquisition (and PBS Frontline Special), was VP of regional affairs at AOPA!

Holy conflict of pilot-interest. I'd say AOPA failed miserably hiring him and any desire I had to support that organization is now gone.
 
Was, or is, with AOPA? If before his time at the RAA, then I don't see the problem. If he's been hired since then, I still don't see how AOPA members should be upset. They are for GA, not airlines.

If ALPA hired him, then I definitely see a conflict of interest.
 
Was, or is, with AOPA? If before his time at the RAA, then I don't see the problem. If he's been hired since then, I still don't see how AOPA members should be upset. They are for GA, not airlines.

If ALPA hired him, then I definitely see a conflict of interest.

He worked for AOPA previously. Never ALPA. I guess it just proves that AOPA is a conflict of interest with a career in aviation.

I will never ever be an AOPA member again, as a result of this.
 
He worked for AOPA previously. Never ALPA. I guess it just proves that AOPA is a conflict of interest with a career in aviation.

I will never ever be an AOPA member again, as a result of this.
How is him having worked there prior any conflict of interest? He was a paid mouthpiece for the RAA, in other words, told what to say. It doesn't reflect anything on AOPA as far as I'm concerned. I haven't been a member in a while, but they do some good things for GA.

Maybe I'm not seeing your picture, but what does AOPA have to do with a subsequent job for an individual?
 
AOPA isn't just a conflict of interest for professional aviators, it is also a rip off for anyone who isn't a rich guy with a fancy turbine airplane. AOPA caters to that crowd and cons the little guy into funding their efforts. It's like a Koch brothers super PAC for aviation.
Bingo. Entry level GA to them is a doctor or lawyer who buys a bonanza to fly around on weekends.

My money goes to EAA.
 
AOPA isn't just a conflict of interest for professional aviators, it is also a rip off for anyone who isn't a rich guy with a fancy turbine airplane. AOPA caters to that crowd and cons the little guy into funding their efforts. It's like a Koch brothers super PAC for aviation.
Not defending AOPA. That's almost the same thing you could say about having a Regional Airline ALPA MEC's and Major Airline APLA MEC's talk about two factions af the same "group" wanting completely different goals. Or would be more comparable to the time ALPA shoved age 65 down the groups gullet at a time when the membership apposed it? Little guys got screwed with stagnation to pay for five mores years at the top of the pay scale for the minority. Hmmmmm.
 
Not defending AOPA. That's almost the same thing you could say about having a Regional Airline ALPA MEC's and Major Airline APLA MEC's talk about two factions af the same "group" wanting completely different goals.

That would only be true if one was ignorant of how ALPA is structured and wasn't aware that individual MECs make their own decisions and aren't controlled by the international union.

Or would be more comparable to the time ALPA shoved age 65 down the groups gullet at a time when the membership apposed it?

You might want to go look at that polling data again.
 
That would only be true if one was ignorant of how ALPA is structured and wasn't aware that individual MECs make their own decisions and aren't controlled by the international union.



You might want to go look at that polling data again.
Yes local MEC's are their own "entity". So why in my regional new hire class was this whole spiel about how "ALPA national was best" your a local MEC but you "have the full backing of national" Not once was there ever talk about how "you're only as good as your local MEC" or any of that. If it truly was the case that local MEC's operate without influence of the mothership, then each one could've voted down age 65 in their respective shops. But we both know it doesn't work like that. When things are going great, ALPA National takes the responsibility. When things are going horrible at a particular airline, ALPA National says "well jeez, sorry bout your luck, but you're only as good as your local MEC".

I also have seen age 65 data broken down airline by airline in chart format but I can't seem to find it right now.

From https://www.alpa.org/portals/alpa/pressroom/testimony/2005/2005-7-19_Woerth-Written.htm

The results of the survey show that a majority of ALPA pilots favor maintaining the Age 60 Rule. Consider the following statistics from the survey:

  • When asked in a straight-forward yes or no format, “Do you favor changing the FAA Age 60 Rule?” 56% of ALPA pilots support maintaining the current rule; 42% want it to change.

  • When we asked pilots specifically about changing the rule to age 65, support for maintaining the current rule rose to 58% and support for change dropped to 39%.
 
Yes local MEC's are their own "entity". So why in my regional new hire class was this whole spiel about how "ALPA national was best" your a local MEC but you "have the full backing of national"

"Backing" is not the same thing as national making decisions for you. You make your own decisions, and ALPA provides the resources.

If it truly was the case that local MEC's operate without influence of the mothership, then each one could've voted down age 65 in their respective shops.

In fact, each MEC did have a vote. The Executive Board vote (each MEC gets one vote) was split 80/20. Obviously, the 80% wanted to support the change. I was opposed, but my side lost. Such is democracy.

But we both know it doesn't work like that. When things are going great, ALPA National takes the responsibility. When things are going horrible at a particular airline, ALPA National says "well jeez, sorry bout your luck, but you're only as good as your local MEC".

Not really, but nice rhetoric.

I also have seen age 65 data broken down airline by airline in chart format but I can't seem to find it right now.

From https://www.alpa.org/portals/alpa/pressroom/testimony/2005/2005-7-19_Woerth-Written.htm

The results of the survey show that a majority of ALPA pilots favor maintaining the Age 60 Rule. Consider the following statistics from the survey:

  • When asked in a straight-forward yes or no format, “Do you favor changing the FAA Age 60 Rule?” 56% of ALPA pilots support maintaining the current rule; 42% want it to change.

  • When we asked pilots specifically about changing the rule to age 65, support for maintaining the current rule rose to 58% and support for change dropped to 39%.

You realize that you're quoting testimony from several years prior to the age change and the last polling data, right? Captain Woerth wasn't even president when the change came about.

I didn't support the age change, and I wasn't happy about it in the slightest. But at least get your facts straight.
 
"Backing" is not the same thing as national making decisions for you. You make your own decisions, and ALPA provides the resources.



In fact, each MEC did have a vote. The Executive Board vote (each MEC gets one vote) was split 80/20. Obviously, the 80% wanted to support the change. I was opposed, but my side lost. Such is democracy.



Not really, but nice rhetoric.



You realize that you're quoting testimony from several years prior to the age change and the last polling data, right? Captain Woerth wasn't even president when the change came about.

I didn't support the age change, and I wasn't happy about it in the slightest. But at least get your facts straight.
Edit: I've heard that same "Rhetoric " from people on this form. It goes like this; "ALPA sucks, I'm tired of it, rabble rabble!!" An ALPA member(s) comes back with "what have done for your local ALPA, oh you don't volunteer? Sorry can't complain then". Not every can volunteer and ALPA wouldn't know what to do with that many people trying to volunteer. Members get a vote and since they have a vote their voice should be heard.

Yeah Prater was our hero then, I know. The chart I'm really looking for shows the rank and file yes or now votes at each airline. That's the interesting one if I remember.

I get each MEC gets a vote on it. Bottom line is, you have a bunch of regional guys who didn't want it and a bunch of top of the listers that did. Those are the ones running national and those are the ones that got the rule passed. look, ALPA is needed every day to keep the company from taking people's jobs. I get that and support it. What we don't seem to have is a way to protect ALPA from ALPA. We've all heard and seen all the infighting from local MEC's all the way to National. More drama than an eighth grade girls locker room. I know you've had to wittiness it.
 
Last edited:
I get each MEC gets a vote on it. Bottom line is, you have a bunch of regional guys who didn't want it and a bunch of top of the listers that did. Those are the ones running national and those are the ones that got the rule passed.

This is just flat out wrong. Where do you get this stuff? The vote was 80/20% on the Board. And you know who one of the few "no" votes was? The guy from Northwest! The Northwest MEC adamantly opposed Age 65. Most of the regional MECs voted in favor of it! So much for that "the big guys screwed us" nonsense. I proposed a resolution when I was on the Pinnacle MEC urging our MEC chairman to vote against a change. The motion didn't even get a second. This was an airline where almost everyone was under age 45, including most people on the MEC.

Forget the nonsense that you've been fed by the angry malcontents. Age 65 happened because of democracy. I didn't like the result, but democracy doesn't always go your way.
 
This is just flat out wrong. Where do you get this stuff? The vote was 80/20% on the Board. And you know who one of the few "no" votes was? The guy from Northwest! The Northwest MEC adamantly opposed Age 65. Most of the regional MECs voted in favor of it! So much for that "the big guys screwed us" nonsense. I proposed a resolution when I was on the Pinnacle MEC urging our MEC chairman to vote against a change. The motion didn't even get a second. This was an airline where almost everyone was under age 45, including most people on the MEC.

Forget the nonsense that you've been fed by the angry malcontents. Age 65 happened because of democracy. I didn't like the result, but democracy doesn't always go your way.
I totally differ to your expertise in this. I do remember seeing a list that went shop by shop and showed the no/yes votes and it was not in favor of it. I could be remembering wrong as well.

I would like your thoughts on the top part of my last post. I know I'm not the only to have felt that way about ALPA in general.
 
I would like your thoughts on the top part of my last post. I know I'm not the only to have felt that way about ALPA in general.

Everyone does have a vote, and therefore everyone is heard. The problem is that people want to nitpick. They elect someone who they think they want, but then that person doesn't cater to their every little demand, so they claim that their rep "isn't listening" to them. We live in this country in a representative democracy, not a direct one, and ALPA is no different. Both are structured that way because direct democracy simply doesn't work for complex issues. It takes knowledge and experience to make the correct decisions. The USAirways pilots bitch to this day about the MEC voting away their pension, but had their MEC not made that decision, none of them would have jobs today.
 
Everyone does have a vote, and therefore everyone is heard. The problem is that people want to nitpick. They elect someone who they think they want, but then that person doesn't cater to their every little demand, so they claim that their rep "isn't listening" to them. We live in this country in a representative democracy, not a direct one, and ALPA is no different. Both are structured that way because direct democracy simply doesn't work for complex issues. It takes knowledge and experience to make the correct decisions. The USAirways pilots bitch to this day about the MEC voting away their pension, but had their MEC not made that decision, none of them would have jobs today.
I agree with everything you said. Just like in our democracy, some times the best don't run and the worst do. They are also subject to the same political pressures/back room deals etc that our elected reps are. While AOPA isnt a perfect organization some of the same can be said for others.

Also if your a turbine owner operator, you belong to NBAA. :)
 
AOPA isn't just a conflict of interest for professional aviators, it is also a rip off for anyone who isn't a rich guy with a fancy turbine airplane. AOPA caters to that crowd and cons the little guy into funding their efforts. It's like a Koch brothers super PAC for aviation.

Ignorant post.

AOPA has done more for GA than any other organization out there. I don't see it as a conflict of interest. I joined because I support GA and their efforts to keep it affordable, accessible, and as headache-free from the government as possible. They are working on an ADS-B solution that is cheaper/more cost effective for owners and for every pilot, 3rd class medical reform to mirror LSA flying medical rules. I was trained through GA and that's where my roots are.

- Lifetime AOPA card-carrying member, 2006.
 
Pilots are political idiots, part (whatever part this is): failing to understand the revolving door that is Washington, D.C.
 
Back
Top