Wow....I spend months away from this place and I come back to a discussion on the definition of the word “OR”.
First, there is an FAA legal interpretation, I believe the Powell interpretation, which essentially says the FAA screwed up, and the word “OR” means “AND”. So both forecasts and the current forecasts must indicate weather is going to be above the required minima to land.
At my shop, we have a 90 minute rule, where the enRoute time to a destination is less than 90 minutes, we can throw out the TAF and use the METARs —-so long as there is a positive trend—to light the fires and roll the tires. Dispatchers hate this rule and we hopefully will get rid of it. I don’t think the Feds are a big fan of it either.
To whoever said they redispatch based on a METAR. I ask you, what is the validity time of a METAR? Here’s a hint....it’s not one hour. It’s until the next METAR is issued.
You can back yourself into a tight corner and have to answer to the Feds for RDA-ing a flight based on that.
Luckily, if you have a CAT3 bird, there shouldn’t be a reason why you can provide a redispatch....just have a good alternate that’s within the fuel range of the aircraft.
The ONLY time I haven’t made redispatch is when we had a wind bust at cruise. It’s happened twice to me, and only a couple times at my current carrier.
As far as the segue to aircraft accidents, I’m just here to read what the latest NTSB investigators have to say.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk