Well if you don't think I'm an idiot you sure don't know how to state your opinion!
That was one of the most inflammatory posts I've seen to date. I feel like an idiot, a heel, a jerk, and a pompous ass all rolled in to one after listening to that! Why don't you tell me what you
really feel???
Anyway I'll respond to some of your "statements:"
The jaded comment was in reference to MAPD I believe. Or the word jaded didn't mean to me what it means to you. I mostly was tired.
Regional airline flying is a classic "grass is greener" scenario. It looks great until you do it for three months.
If I could live where I was based and be sure the base wasn't going to close, it might be more fun. Commuting is very draining and very stressful. When I was hired at Mesa, Orlando was the largest base in the country. 2 1/2 years later it was closed. If I was happy being a vagabond hobo who lived from crashpad to crashpad I suppose I would enjoy it more.
The comraderie is probably the best thing about it. Most of the pilots share that feeling and you learn to avoid those that don't.
You misinterpret me when you say that I discourage everyone. If you are young and free and unattached and don't mind staying that way for a while, then commuter/regional airlines can be a blast. I highly suggest having a back up plan if it doesn't work though. Besides not liking it there is always the possibility of not making it through training. Attrition at some airlines is higher than others, but all have their occasional failures.
I am not at this time relying 100% on aviation for income, which allows me to enjoy it much more. It's much less stressful when you can say "no" and it won't cost your job.
If you can get in that situation then aviation is a great second income