RA's?

CapnJim

Well-Known Member
RA\'s?

Just curious how many RA's ya'll get in a typical year. I've been on the line for 7 months, and I've had three, which seems like a lot. It might not be in reality, but when the little dots on the metal detector go red, and Bitchin' Betty starts up it tends to stand out in memory, particularly considering I'm an FNG.

And no, none were my fault. All three were near terminal areas with some goofball on a VFR flight plan veering onto a collision course.
 
Re: RA\'s?

I've only had one in the past year in the ERJ. On final, EWR, PA helicopter.

At the previous job, I probably had over a dozen in a year. One trip, we had two in one day, and two more on subsequent days of the four day! One was a Cessna that did what we believed to be a chandelle right into us, considering we climbed 3000 feet before the TCAS let us recover.

Another time we got "buzzed" by a T-6 Texan enroute to DSM from MDW. Crusing at 16,000 feet, got an RA, climb climb, and see this bright yellow Texan whiz by. We were livid. Why? Because I saw him looking at us and waving.
mad.gif
That close.
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]

Another time we got "buzzed" by a T-6 Texan enroute to DSM from MDW. Crusing at 16,000 feet, got an RA, climb climb, and see this bright yellow Texan whiz by. We were livid. Why? Because I saw him looking at us and waving.
mad.gif
That close.

[/ QUOTE ]

He's just being friendly!
grin.gif


That's weird.....a T-6 at 16,000............would be sorta like me being low level on a VR route in the A-10, and passing a 777 at 200 AGL going the opposite direction.
grin.gif
 
Re: RA\'s?

I can't remember if it was 16,000 feet. That was our normal altitude on that route, so I figured. Who knows! Could have been 22,000 feet.
tongue.gif
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]

That's weird.....a T-6 at 16,000............would be sorta like me being low level on a VR route in the A-10, and passing a 777 at 200 AGL going the opposite direction.
grin.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

I had a T-6 come in sunday, he filed for fl250 leaving out.
 
Re: RA\'s?

When I was based in San Juan, I averaged 1 a week. The inter-island flights gave the most (between STX-STT), sometimes 1 a day.
 
Re: RA\'s?

OK, it sounds like mine are higher than normal, but not extreme. All three of mine have been in the Newark/New York area, either with approach or departure control. Normally those guys are the finest in the world, but not a lot you can do when a chickenhawk decides to 'trade airspeed for altitute' or a VFR Pilatus at 14,000 makes an unexpected and problematic leftie.
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]
...All three of mine have been in the Newark/New York area

[/ QUOTE ]
9 out of 10 are in the NY area. It never fails to amaze me, the number of people (with low IQs) that do airwork at 3000 MSL in the middle of the NY arrival corridors. It would also help if ATC would not insist on all 100,000 departures using the same initial fix.

To the C172/PA-28 drivers near CDW, MMU, etc: STOP DOING YOUR AIRWORK ON THE VOR DME A COURSE TO KTEB.
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]
It would also help if ATC would not insist on all 100,000 departures using the same initial fix.



[/ QUOTE ]

lol......bet that makes deconfliction fun.
grin.gif
 
Re: RA\'s?

I've had 2 so far in a little over 400hrs in the jet. The first one was on IOE descending into SMF. We were descending to 11,000 and a King Air headed the opposite direction was climbing to 10,500. We never saw him, so we had to respond. The second one was when we were being vectored for the ILS to 35R at DEN. Another plane was being vectored to 35L. We were in the clouds on that one. Going into SFO, nearly every time we get paired up next to another plane it goes off, but that's expected.
 
Re: RA\'s?

I had a serious no sh*t, thought I was going to buy the farm RA about three years ago.

Climbing out of Louisville towards CVG and departure had us climbing to 11,000 feet and called out traffic 1,000 feet above.

During the climb, the TA/VSI starts screaming. "Traffic, traffic, monitor vertical speed...Descend! Descend! Descend!"

I can't see the guy the captain starts asking departure control about the traffic and I freak and follow the RA descentg guidance off the bat.

Let's put it this way, it was a guy in a Navajo wearing a red shirt with David Clarks on.

"Oh yeah, Navajo 1234, say altitude" (and you can hear the 'BleeBleeBleeBlee' in the background as he's speaking)

"Level 11,000 as assigned..."
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]
Do I dare ask... whats an RA?
confused.gif


[/ QUOTE ]

Resolution Advisory. Its when the TCAS says you're really freakin close to another airplane and it tells you what to do to not hit them.
 
Re: RA\'s?

Resolution Advisory.

it's when the TCAS computer figures out that you're going to lose separation between aircraft and starts giving you climb/descend commands to escape the converging paths.

Basically, in layman's terms, you're basically going to collide or come very close to doing it if you don't climb or descend as commanded.
 
Re: RA\'s?

Even had TIS save someone's bacon today at GKY. It's not as precise as TCAS and doesn't tell you to climb or descend, but it does get your attention. And it avoided a head on collision between a 172SP and a Seminole.....
 
Re: RA\'s?

My god please tell me when that tower is going to come online at GKY. My love for flying at night is just encouraged by the fact that I know I've had a couple "RAs." TCAS pings other transponders to give it targets and resolutions, does it have anything else for non-squawking targets with or without mode C?
 
Re: RA\'s?

[ QUOTE ]
...does it have anything else for non-squawking targets with or without mode C?

[/ QUOTE ]
Nope.
 
Re: RA\'s?

In fact, you see the occasional boat on arrival into KBOS. Of course no vertical information from the transponder...
smile.gif
 
Back
Top