Ramblings of a flight school owner

I support your comment 100%. In my interaction with most pilots in the 121 environment, they are cheap bastards who would fly half way across the country if it meant a free meal.

There's a joke I once heard that went.......a pilot once took his son to the supermarket. When they got to the soap aisle, his son watched in amazement as saw row after row of giant sized soap bars. The truth was his father was so cheap, he had brought home hotel soap for the entire kids life.

This has been post a lot of places but never gets old:
http://acaptainslog.blogspot.com/2008/03/cheap-bastards.html
 
I support your comment 100%. In my interaction with most pilots in the 121 environment, they are cheap bastards who would fly half way across the country if it meant a free meal.

Chicken or the egg? Pilots are cheap because if we're not we'll be bankrupt after instructing for 2 months due to the low pay.
 
1. Thanks for your economics lesson, but I have owned a business and had employees. If you want to retain employees you must pay them well, and if the microeconomics of the biz makes that difficult, then plan for turnover the second they can bail. Coming on a public board to rant about it won't help him.
2. Not going to get in a dong swingin' contest with you on the pros and cons of European system as I doubt you have any first hand experience with the JAA world. But to answer your question as far as Europe goes there are at least two types of flight schools. The keys to getting a good airline job often come from a high quality ab-initio academy and FI there can make good money. These flight schools make a lot of money. Do you have a problem with this? Other schools pretty much do private pilot training and maybe a modular license here or there. The big part of the JAA industry in florida is time building... BTW, you can't get a JAA instrument rating here in the States and there are schools that just do that conversion and make a mint.
3. Concerning the health care issue, I did some project management for one of those "European" flight schools a while back. One of the issue of CFI retention was health care or lack thereof. The regionals offered it, and was one of the reasons people pushed on... I wasn't really making a comment pro or con about Obama's plan, simply stating that it may help out the retention issue, but your response was interesting. Have you ever owned a business, a house, or worked as an expatriate (civilian) in a industrialized democracy to see how different systems work? Funny how the USA is the only major democracy where healthcare is a political "issue".

First, you were the one ranting about someone not paying people "what they are worth". I was pointing out the reality of running a flight school- margins are thin.
I have lived, flown, and/or traveled in every continent in the world (except for Antarctica), and have seen the different systems, both as a member of the military and as a civilian... nothing like that 23% unemployment rate in Spain when I was there in the 1990s. Boy, that was awesome. To paraphrase Winston Churchill, what we have in the US is the worst that I have seen... except for all the others.
Health care is not a political issue, medical care is a political issue. While the health of Americans may not be the best (too much McDonalds, driving on the roads, too much damb freedom to kill yourself), the medical care is top notch. Do you really want to compare survival rates for cancer (the US survival rate leads the world). Since my wife is a doctor, I will put it to you in terms anyone could understand. When she begins to be taxed at a 70% rate to pay for government mismanaged care, she will need to decide if she wants to work longer or go home and see her family. She will decide to go home. When she does, she will send home the receptionist, the x-ray technicians, the nurses, the surgical staff, etc. These are middle class workers who will be sent home and will make less. Less income for the economy. Then, if you want to see an orthopedic surgeon, you will wait... a long time. Why should she work longer?
Another good example. As a military doctor (essentially socialized medicine), my wife would see maybe 3-4 knee and hip replacements in a week. It was not that people in the military do not need them (active duty and veterans), it is that there was no incentive for the military hospitals to do them quickly or efficiently. Take your time on each case. If it's close to quiting time, put off the next case. Why stay late for it? You get paid the same. On the civilian side she would do eight in a day. Not just Americans, but patients from "industrialized democracies" where they would have to wait years for the same operation, if they could get it at all. In the civilian hospital there was the incentive to be productive- an empty OR does not make money. Of course I find it ironic that the world still comes to the US for the medical care the "industrialized" countries will not give them, as well as their flight training.
"We all declare for liberty; but in using the same word we do not all mean the same thing. With some the word liberty may mean for each man to do as he pleases with himself, and the product of his labor; while with others, the same word may mean for some men to do as they please with other men, and the product of other men's labor. Here are two, not only different, but incompatible things, called by the same name - liberty. And it follows that each of the things is, by the respective parties, called by two different and incompatible names - liberty and tyranny."
 
I don't want to come off as harsh, but it sounds like you need to seriously evaluate your interview/selection process for instructors. My philosophy is that it's better to have nobody and be shorthanded than to have a bad employee. Be picky, even if it's hard. Wait for the perfect match.

I agree with this as well. It's a criteria I use to evaluate jobs. I'd rather have to interview for 20 than thake one bad one.

Wow. That's a lot of overhead. I don't know what to tell you...running a school with Cirri and big facilities is a risky business. I would want to be VERY sure of my business plan before expanding to that level.

Another valid point. While I see the trend moving toward Cirrus as Primary trainers (I'll leave my opinions on that for another thread) one important item in business models forgotten by entrepreneurs is location, location, location

I'm not looking to solve the worlds problems, but I do like to toss in my $3.87 - what major city is this operation located near? That info would help to see the balance of operations vs. incoming descretionary client income. Chester County, PA has much different demographics then Deltona, Fl.

SurferLucas:

FlightSchoolOwner: I've been managing a small flight school for about a year now. It's a tough business, but I think running any small business is tough. I'd be happy to talk more through private message if you want to kick around ideas for successful schools...

FlightSchoolOwner Myself too. Feel free to PM.
 
I think location is important for other reasons. Instructors know they won't be paid much, but paying them bottom of the industry pay at a flight school in the middle of an expensive city just isn't going to work.

If people are prepared to pay to fly new airplanes, then the cost of an instructor is small in addition to that. Try selling your school based on the quality of service offered, rather than comparing it to the competition on price, especially when it's the first thing you see on that expensive website.
 
This is where it got interesting. Dispite having been at this flight school for a quite a while and working pretty much everyday, when I broke the news to my boss that I was going to interview for a job with Horizon, I became public enemy number one. I was pretty much told I wouldn't be getting any more multi time, even though I had 3 students to finish up with either multi training or Baron Checkouts (I was the only Baron MEI). Even now, when I go visit the flight school...I don't get the feeling that I'm welcome.
That is funny because one day on my way home he was sitting next to me and telling me a story about you. He only had great things to say about you and talk about trying to get you to come back as a 135 pilot.
 
Thanks for all the replies.. There is some interesting ideas there but I guess I wasn't clear enough in one point: 3 people that left are not the people who left with some time in their hands.. They left a week or four weeks after their check out.. With not a single notice and with not a single response to the emails or phone calls..
Imagine hiring someone and then not seing that person.. The online scheduling turns into 'unavailable' and the excuse becomes 'I am sick'..

Check out costs $1500 because we are using Cirrus airplanes only and a Seneca III. In addition I order business cards for my instructors, tshirts and name tags for their cubes, had to update the 'staff' section of the website for which I am charged $200 by the company that maintains the site.

I used to think 'if you pay me more I'd give you more' when i was a full time instructor too, but I can see the other side of the things.. I have to maintain certain margin for airplanes and instructors so that I can cover my fixed costs. Variables take care of themselves.. When you are paying $7,000 /month for facilities rent and close to $5000/month for insurance, that puts a lot of pressure on the school. All of our airplanes are in top shape, they are getting maintained perfectly by the maintenance shops, but at the same time that doesn't mean anything to people when they go to next door for $3/hr difference in price..

Anyways, it's getting really late and getting really tired..

I didn't start this thread to bitch about things but I'd like people know that this is a really hard business and there is always the other side of the story.

A couple of suggestions to help cut down the cost of new hires:

1. Don't do a multi-checkout for a new hire. I would tell them they won't get any multi time until they are with you for 3 months.

2. Business cards should cost less than $30. A new instructor won't need more than 100 or so, really. If you are paying more than that, you are getting ripped off.

3. Charge the instructors for the uniform. When I sacked groceries, I had to buy my uniform from a large company. Offer to take a small amount out of each check. Just let them know when they interview and it shouldn't be a problem, especially in this market.

4. LEARN BASIC HTML. You should be able to edit your website to add a new instructor in about 5-10 minutes. It really isn't that hard at all. If you want help in this aspect, PM me and I will be glad to help for free.


I managed a flight school and FBO for about a year and am the Assistant Chief Instructor for a good sized school now, so I know a lot of the frustrations you are going through. Good luck.
 
However am afraid that the typical SJSer CFI wouldn't have the interest or the attention span to want to get involved with this......just wants every 0.1 he can get his hand on. And thats too bad.

There's nobody like that on this forum Mike:D
 
3. Charge the instructors for the uniform. When I sacked groceries, I had to buy my uniform from a large company. Offer to take a small amount out of each check. Just let them know when they interview and it shouldn't be a problem, especially in this market.

i was flying into an airport in FL with a young pilot friend a few months ago. His comment upon arrival - "They don't really make them wear those stupid airline uniforms to fly a 172, do they???"

T-shirts and flip-flops seem to be the most common CFI uniform here in FL..
 
Both my CFI jobs that used company polos gave them to me. In fact I have one on right now, 5 years later...they would pretty good quality! They also had business cards made for me. They both did a checkout in their single for like .6. Total cost to them was probably around $150 total for everything.

I second mojo's comments, save for charging the instructors for the uniform/shirt. Re: web site, the last flight school web site I made included a database tie in that allowed the flight school owner to login and add things like job postings, specials, and change rental rates on their aircraft. This is so they wouldn't have to pay (me) someone to update those things. Maybe ask about including that in your web site. The upfront cost was only $300 to them but it saved them a ton in long term update costs.
 
Interesting thread. As a new CFI in search of work I face the problem on the opposite end. How do I find a good employer. I do my research. How many and type of aircraft, number of pilots, are they currently busy, or even hiring, contact info. Of course word of mouth and recommendation from others is the best way. However you can't know all FBO's and schools. I was going to wait to do my CFII when I got hired, as a investment in my employer. Now I think I'll just stay where I am and do it here. I know the aircraft, school, etc. Nothing new. Once done I'm back to square one, job hunting. I was fortunate that me and my previous employer of 8 years have to this day a great realtionship.(non aviation business) I made alot of money, had unlimited OT and side work, on call 365, great co-workers, etc. I made my choice to pursue a carreer in aviation, and they all fully supported me, however they were perplexed why I was leaving to make so much less money. (I guess only pilots know the reason). Now I hope I can find a employer as great as my previous. Although with so many flavors out there I'm sure I'll run into a Bill Lumburg or two before I find a good one. I made my decision to change careers, and have no regrets. As long as I can keep the bill collectors at bay, fly something & teach, I'll be content. I know I'm a new CFI and have much to learn, but I am not new to work. There are those of use that enjoy and take pride with what we do and have care. You just have to find us, or we have to find you. Good Hunting.
 
i was flying into an airport in FL with a young pilot friend a few months ago. His comment upon arrival - "They don't really make them wear those stupid airline uniforms to fly a 172, do they???"

T-shirts and flip-flops seem to be the most common CFI uniform here in FL..

Another option to save money on uniforms is to have a dress code, but no uniform. Most instructors like this arrangement as well. Our dress code is essentially business casual. Must have a collared shirt with no jeans, no shorts, no athletic shoes. Be clean shaven with no visible tattoos.

To help with this, we provide two polo shirts embroidered with the company logo to each instructor for free. We don't have to wear them, but I think we all usually do. I wear mine because I don't like deciding what to wear in the morning. Grab one of my polos, throw on one of my half dozen pairs of khakis, and roll out.




Also, I think CFIs who wear T-shirts and flip flops look trashy. Oh snap, that's right, I did just open that can of worms! :D
 
I do wonder though, as an aside, that if airlines had this kind of open and frank discussion with their pilots/unions as you did with your boss, if there'd be the strife/rift we see today between management and the pilots/union.

After talking about their horrible losses, didn't BA just ask their pilots to fly a month for free? I don't remember hearing anything about management working for free. Or the finance dept being asked to work for free.

Honestly, I think you are better off working for TSA than being an airline captain.

From TSA's website: Basic rates are limited to $153,200. The above rates do not include locality pay. Pay rates, including locality pay, are limited to $162,900.

Take a look at their website - most of the openings are starting at $70,000+. By the time you would make captain at an airline, you could already be making six figures and have a sizeable savings. Unlike the airlines, you'll have a government pension that you won't lose in a bankruptcy in a few years.

If the GOV'T can tack on $10 to each airline ticket to pay baggage screeners a reasonable wage, the airlines could certainly do the same. If there were a $1 per segment "Pilot Pay Surcharge," I doubt anyone would complain. I wouldn't hold my breath on that happening though.
 
Must have a collared shirt with no jeans, no shorts, no athletic shoes. Be clean shaven with no visible tattoos.
Dang man, that is harsh! :pirate:

My school is business casual with the option to buy a company polo.

Me and a buddy are thinking about doing ties. We look sharp in ties and beards.
 
Also, I think CFIs who wear T-shirts and flip flops look trashy. Oh snap, that's right, I did just open that can of worms! :D

When it's 95 degrees and 100% humidity here, spending 8 hours a day in a Cessna with no AC, I can understand the desire for the beach attire.
 
If the GOV'T can tack on $10 to each airline ticket to pay baggage screeners a reasonable wage, the airlines could certainly do the same. If there were a $1 per segment "Pilot Pay Surcharge," I doubt anyone would complain. I wouldn't hold my breath on that happening though.

They already have that. It's included in the price of the ticket - ie the cost of doing business.
 
Another option to save money on uniforms is to have a dress code, but no uniform. Most instructors like this arrangement as well. Our dress code is essentially business casual. Must have a collared shirt with no jeans, no shorts, no athletic shoes. Be clean shaven with no visible tattoos.

To help with this, we provide two polo shirts embroidered with the company logo to each instructor for free. We don't have to wear them, but I think we all usually do. I wear mine because I don't like deciding what to wear in the morning. Grab one of my polos, throw on one of my half dozen pairs of khakis, and roll out.




Also, I think CFIs who wear T-shirts and flip flops look trashy. Oh snap, that's right, I did just open that can of worms! :D

No shorts!?!? I would die here if I couldn't wear shorts.
 
Dang man, that is harsh! :pirate:

My school is business casual with the option to buy a company polo.

Me and a buddy are thinking about doing ties. We look sharp in ties and beards.

We don't have anything against beards. It's just easier to not allow beards than to try to differentiate between "classy, gentleman" beards and, "Dude, you look like a homeless guy with a dead squirrel on his face" beards.
 
Back
Top