Ramblings of a flight school owner

It is a tough industry. Really it is an extension of the regionals. Why would anyone want to sit around a flight school and bill 60 hours a months at $20 an hour, with no benefits? Flight time... they are paid $100 in flight time and $20 to eat...
When they can escape to the next step they will. I know some flight school owners that are top notch (as you seem to be), but they are constrained by the market and industry norm where the cut throat operators set the market. If you can pay a salary (or a minimum)of $3000 a month, benefits and treat them right, you would have no problem retaining outstanding career oriented CFIs. If you can't or won't then please don't take it personally. You are in a tough business, but really I don't blame any CFI for leaving in a heartbeat. Perhaps if the president can get universal health care through, the lack of benefits may not be such a detriment to retention for flight schools.
I will point out, as I have before that a FI in Europe can command a figure comparable with a Regional Captain in the US in a reputable Ab Initio academy. Many do it for a career. But there, regulation makes GA as a business a rare thing indeed.

Of course the first thing anyone looks for in a flight school is... cost. Yeah, you could pay them $3000+ a month, plus benefits, but you would not be in business very long. Speaking of the FI pay in Europe... how is that industry doing over there? I know we have rated European pilots who come over here just to get checked out and get some hours every year or so. It's too expensive in Europe and cheaper for these pilots to pay for airfare to the US, hotel, rental car and everything else than to pay for their flight time in Europe. There is a rather large industry in the US based upon this. As for universal health care... well, it is not "free" health care and the money will come from somewhere. "Some one else" maybe for a while, but then their money will run out so flight school owners will be hit in one way or another.
 
Autonomy? Usually I don't get too concerned about the grammar, but we're talking two very different words and meanings.

I do get concerned about grammar, and we are talking about very different meanings.

I do appreciate the correction as I was thinking "atonomy" and wrote "animosity." Thank you for the correction.


/splithairs.
 
Its a jump to conclusions mat!
70384439_ba1fd5b9de.jpg
 
You see, it would be this mat that you would put on the floor... and would have different CONCLUSIONS written on it that you could JUMP TO.
 
Coming from someone who spent 3 years as a CFI, working for a flight school that had just opened...I'll include some experiences here as well.

Where I started flying, we had 4 training aircraft when I started. New 172Sp's and a cherry 182RG. I had my CFI/CFII and I started at $22/hour with a 10 hour guarantee a week. That was very nice to have at the time. We were a Cessna Pilot Center, so we had a standardized syllabus and something for a students to work with.

The owner of the flight school I worked for is an airline pilot and was a great mentor for me. He was really good about keeping you busy when you weren't flying and finding other ways to earn your keep (marketing, helping get Part 135 and Part 141 certs, charter sales, etc). It was good to see the business side in addition the CFI side.

After about a year and half, I was the only CFI left of an original group of 4 that wasn't going to an airline (I didn't feel like I was prepared enough experience wise). I agreed to give the owner another year, and for that I was moved to Asst. Chief Flight Instructor, Manager of Maintainence and Check Airman. I got to go to Cessna's Independance factory for G1000 Training, test fly 2 new airplanes that we bought, and bring one of them home. I also had my MEI paid for by the flight school. All of this came with a nice raise up to $25/hour (+$15 for multi), extra $100/week for taking card of mx in addition to a now 15 hour weekly guarantee.

As great as the job was and how great my QOL was...I felt like I had hit a plateau. We had a 421/414 that we managed/flew charters with. I had wrote most of our Part 135 books for multi-pilot/airplane, and thought I would be the next up for a checkride with the FAA. However, it became apparent that I wasn't going to get to take the next step with the flight school.

After lots of thinking, I made the decision to make the jump into the airline world.

This is where it got interesting. Dispite having been at this flight school for a quite a while and working pretty much everyday, when I broke the news to my boss that I was going to interview for a job with Horizon, I became public enemy number one. I was pretty much told I wouldn't be getting any more multi time, even though I had 3 students to finish up with either multi training or Baron Checkouts (I was the only Baron MEI). Even now, when I go visit the flight school...I don't get the feeling that I'm welcome.

I'd caution against this type of approach to those that move on. If you have a quality CFI, treat them as such. If they decide to move on, more times than not it's nothing against you or your company. If you pay them well, provide with quality airplanes and tools to succeed...you will find they will go above and beyond for you, and in turn you'll have a successful flight school.

One of the best things Cessna did for the CPC's is the CPC meetings where they talked about selling the program, managing risks and providing the best service for your customers. The owner I worked for made sure all CFI's went to atleast one of these meetings...mainly help you with marketing the program to gain more students.

Good luck with your business!
 
Thanks for all the replies.. There is some interesting ideas there but I guess I wasn't clear enough in one point: 3 people that left are not the people who left with some time in their hands.. They left a week or four weeks after their check out.. With not a single notice and with not a single response to the emails or phone calls..
Imagine hiring someone and then not seing that person.. The online scheduling turns into 'unavailable' and the excuse becomes 'I am sick'..

Check out costs $1500 because we are using Cirrus airplanes only and a Seneca III. In addition I order business cards for my instructors, tshirts and name tags for their cubes, had to update the 'staff' section of the website for which I am charged $200 by the company that maintains the site.

I used to think 'if you pay me more I'd give you more' when i was a full time instructor too, but I can see the other side of the things.. I have to maintain certain margin for airplanes and instructors so that I can cover my fixed costs. Variables take care of themselves.. When you are paying $7,000 /month for facilities rent and close to $5000/month for insurance, that puts a lot of pressure on the school. All of our airplanes are in top shape, they are getting maintained perfectly by the maintenance shops, but at the same time that doesn't mean anything to people when they go to next door for $3/hr difference in price..

Anyways, it's getting really late and getting really tired..

I didn't start this thread to bitch about things but I'd like people know that this is a really hard business and there is always the other side of the story.
 
Of course the first thing anyone looks for in a flight school is... cost. Yeah, you could pay them $3000+ a month, plus benefits, but you would not be in business very long. Speaking of the FI pay in Europe... how is that industry doing over there? I know we have rated European pilots who come over here just to get checked out and get some hours every year or so. It's too expensive in Europe and cheaper for these pilots to pay for airfare to the US, hotel, rental car and everything else than to pay for their flight time in Europe. There is a rather large industry in the US based upon this. As for universal health care... well, it is not "free" health care and the money will come from somewhere. "Some one else" maybe for a while, but then their money will run out so flight school owners will be hit in one way or another.
1. Thanks for your economics lesson, but I have owned a business and had employees. If you want to retain employees you must pay them well, and if the microeconomics of the biz makes that difficult, then plan for turnover the second they can bail. Coming on a public board to rant about it won't help him.
2. Not going to get in a dong swingin' contest with you on the pros and cons of European system as I doubt you have any first hand experience with the JAA world. But to answer your question as far as Europe goes there are at least two types of flight schools. The keys to getting a good airline job often come from a high quality ab-initio academy and FI there can make good money. These flight schools make a lot of money. Do you have a problem with this? Other schools pretty much do private pilot training and maybe a modular license here or there. The big part of the JAA industry in florida is time building... BTW, you can't get a JAA instrument rating here in the States and there are schools that just do that conversion and make a mint.
3. Concerning the health care issue, I did some project management for one of those "European" flight schools a while back. One of the issue of CFI retention was health care or lack thereof. The regionals offered it, and was one of the reasons people pushed on... I wasn't really making a comment pro or con about Obama's plan, simply stating that it may help out the retention issue, but your response was interesting. Have you ever owned a business, a house, or worked as an expatriate (civilian) in a industrialized democracy to see how different systems work? Funny how the USA is the only major democracy where healthcare is a political "issue".
 
SurferLucas: Sounds like we've had very similar experiences. Except I'm not dumb enough to go to an airline ;)

FlightSchoolOwner: I've been managing a small flight school for about a year now. It's a tough business, but I think running any small business is tough. I'd be happy to talk more through private message if you want to kick around ideas for successful schools, but in response to your original post, I think it all comes down to this--very few CFIs see the big picture of running a business.

Don't take it personally. They just don't get it. Until I became a manager, I thought I got it, but I didn't *really* get it.

What helped bring me around was the school owner's openness with me even when I was a regular staff instructor. We'd be sitting around the office during dead times, shooting the breeze, and he'd do things like show me his Excel spreadsheet for calculating break even points for the aircraft. We'd talk about different marketing ideas and boil it down to measurable returns...how much revenue could we generate compared to how much we spent on various forms of marketing. We'd talk about what we could do to make our school better than every other operation on this side of the state. Those kinds of things.

He almost treated me like a business partner. I started to see the logic behind his decisions and it hit home how every choice has an impact on other areas of the operation. It gave me a healthy respect for the balancing act that it takes to run a business.

But most importantly, it gave me a realistic picture of what I could expect from working there. If there was no extra money coming in, there's no money to give me a raise. How do I get a raise? Generate more revenue by being a good instructor/salesman. If the business is successful, I'm successful. If it goes under, I'm out of a job. Pretty direct cause and effect.

It's time consuming to mentor your instructors this way, but I think the more exposure you can give them, the better. It might not make them want to become career instructors, but they'll at least understand better where you're coming from and might work harder/be more loyal since they can see how they're only shooting themselves in the foot with selfish actions.
 
You're getting ripped off by the people managing your website if they charge you $200 every time they modify it to put the new instructor on. That's like 10 minutes of work. Not many places can boast of an hourly rate of like USD$1200.
 
SurferLucas: Sounds like we've had very similar experiences. Except I'm not dumb enough to go to an airline ;)

FlightSchoolOwner: I've been managing a small flight school for about a year now. It's a tough business, but I think running any small business is tough. I'd be happy to talk more through private message if you want to kick around ideas for successful schools, but in response to your original post, I think it all comes down to this--very few CFIs see the big picture of running a business.

Don't take it personally. They just don't get it. Until I became a manager, I thought I got it, but I didn't *really* get it.

What helped bring me around was the school owner's openness with me even when I was a regular staff instructor. We'd be sitting around the office during dead times, shooting the breeze, and he'd do things like show me his Excel spreadsheet for calculating break even points for the aircraft. We'd talk about different marketing ideas and boil it down to measurable returns...how much revenue could we generate compared to how much we spent on various forms of marketing. We'd talk about what we could do to make our school better than every other operation on this side of the state. Those kinds of things.

He almost treated me like a business partner. I started to see the logic behind his decisions and it hit home how every choice has an impact on other areas of the operation. It gave me a healthy respect for the balancing act that it takes to run a business.

But most importantly, it gave me a realistic picture of what I could expect from working there. If there was no extra money coming in, there's no money to give me a raise. How do I get a raise? Generate more revenue by being a good instructor/salesman. If the business is successful, I'm successful. If it goes under, I'm out of a job. Pretty direct cause and effect.

It's time consuming to mentor your instructors this way, but I think the more exposure you can give them, the better. It might not make them want to become career instructors, but they'll at least understand better where you're coming from and might work harder/be more loyal since they can see how they're only shooting themselves in the foot with selfish actions.

Very good advice, especially seeing how things have to operate on the other side of the fence.

Agree that you can retain motivated CFIs this way. However am afraid that the typical SJSer CFI wouldn't have the interest or the attention span to want to get involved with this......just wants every 0.1 he can get his hand on. And thats too bad.

I do wonder though, as an aside, that if airlines had this kind of open and frank discussion with their pilots/unions as you did with your boss, if there'd be the strife/rift we see today between management and the pilots/union.

Maybe it'd be worse.......:D
 
3 people that left are not the people who left with some time in their hands.. They left a week or four weeks after their check out.. With not a single notice and with not a single response to the emails or phone calls..
Imagine hiring someone and then not seing that person.. The online scheduling turns into 'unavailable' and the excuse becomes 'I am sick'..

I don't want to come off as harsh, but it sounds like you need to seriously evaluate your interview/selection process for instructors. My philosophy is that it's better to have nobody and be shorthanded than to have a bad employee. Be picky, even if it's hard. Wait for the perfect match.

Check out costs $1500 because we are using Cirrus airplanes only and a Seneca III. In addition I order business cards for my instructors, tshirts and name tags for their cubes, had to update the 'staff' section of the website for which I am charged $200 by the company that maintains the site.

I used to think 'if you pay me more I'd give you more' when i was a full time instructor too, but I can see the other side of the things.. I have to maintain certain margin for airplanes and instructors so that I can cover my fixed costs. Variables take care of themselves.. When you are paying $7,000 /month for facilities rent and close to $5000/month for insurance, that puts a lot of pressure on the school. All of our airplanes are in top shape, they are getting maintained perfectly by the maintenance shops...

Wow. That's a lot of overhead. I don't know what to tell you...running a school with Cirri and big facilities is a risky business. I would want to be VERY sure of my business plan before expanding to that level.

...but at the same time that doesn't mean anything to people when they go to next door for $3/hr difference in price..

Again, don't want to sound harsh, but what are you doing to prove you're worth the extra cash? Most people don't mind if it costs more, as long as they get more. That might be the best aircraft, most experienced instructors, or whatever, but it has to be something. When I'm selling a prospective student on our program, I don't even try to compete on price. I show them what a solid operation we have and explain why they're going to have a great experience with us. They end up investing about $9-10k and we take really good care of them. I show them the value of what they're getting.

Anyways, it's getting really late and getting really tired..

I didn't start this thread to bitch about things but I'd like people know that this is a really hard business and there is always the other side of the story.

I hear ya!
 
Agree that you can retain motivated CFIs this way. However am afraid that the typical SJSer CFI wouldn't have the interest or the attention span to want to get involved with this......just wants every 0.1 he can get his hand on. And thats too bad.

I agree. Which is why selecting a solid staff is amazingly important. See my comment from above about how it's better to have no employee than a bad employee.
 
This is where it got interesting. Dispite having been at this flight school for a quite a while and working pretty much everyday, when I broke the news to my boss that I was going to interview for a job with Horizon, I became public enemy number one. I was pretty much told I wouldn't be getting any more multi time, even though I had 3 students to finish up with either multi training or Baron Checkouts (I was the only Baron MEI). Even now, when I go visit the flight school...I don't get the feeling that I'm welcome.
Sounds vaguely familiar.[/bitter]
 
Thanks for all the replies.. There is some interesting ideas there but I guess I wasn't clear enough in one point: 3 people that left are not the people who left with some time in their hands.. They left a week or four weeks after their check out.. With not a single notice and with not a single response to the emails or phone calls..
Imagine hiring someone and then not seing that person.. The online scheduling turns into 'unavailable' and the excuse becomes 'I am sick'..

Check out costs $1500 because we are using Cirrus airplanes only and a Seneca III. In addition I order business cards for my instructors, tshirts and name tags for their cubes, had to update the 'staff' section of the website for which I am charged $200 by the company that maintains the site.

I used to think 'if you pay me more I'd give you more' when i was a full time instructor too, but I can see the other side of the things.. I have to maintain certain margin for airplanes and instructors so that I can cover my fixed costs. Variables take care of themselves.. When you are paying $7,000 /month for facilities rent and close to $5000/month for insurance, that puts a lot of pressure on the school. All of our airplanes are in top shape, they are getting maintained perfectly by the maintenance shops, but at the same time that doesn't mean anything to people when they go to next door for $3/hr difference in price..

Anyways, it's getting really late and getting really tired..

I didn't start this thread to bitch about things but I'd like people know that this is a really hard business and there is always the other side of the story.

You need to hire someone like me, that is, when I get my CFI and graduate next year :)
 
I hear a lot of people complaining about flight schools , how bad they treat their employees, how bad the owners are.. The impression that I get at this forum that the owners are no different than the used car salesman who sell the 1990 Geo Metro to a grandma for $5000.

Let me say that I saw many bad owners and many good owners in my 20 years of flying. I think I never lost the sight of being a primary student when I fly with other people. I still remember how bad I felt when I first tried steep turns.. I also remember when I was charged with $10 /hr fuel surcharge and $15/hr more when you are flying solo..

I don't deny that there are some bad examples out there..

On the other hand, I started to fly in 1990. Until right before 9/11 the amount of time you spent in flight instructing was more than a year. Also, until last year, there were people who never spent time instructing because of the boom in the hiring..

When I got my first instructing job , the owner charged me for the aircraft.
I said 'Why would you charge me for the check out because I will be working for you , making you money'... So when I opened my own flight school I said 'instructors don't pay for the aircraft check out'.. Simple as that..

In last 5 years, 3 out of 10 instructors just got checked out in the airplane and then quit out of the blue.. No advance notice, no offers like 'Hey, you paid for my check out, I appreciate it, can i at least cover the fuel?'.. In addition to that some of them even started to bad mouth us..

I was amazed how immoral these people are.. I couldn't even believe people would have the nerve to do that..

Now, every instructor signs a paper that they need to reimburse me for the expenses if they leave within 6 months.. Am I proud of that? No.. Absoultely not.. But you are asking me to spend $1500 on a CFI who doesn't even work more than a week..

So, my motto has always been treat the people like the way you want to be treated.. Unfortunately there are more people without that motto in their lives..

I support your comment 100%. In my interaction with most pilots in the 121 environment, they are cheap bastards who would fly half way across the country if it meant a free meal.

There's a joke I once heard that went.......a pilot once took his son to the supermarket. When they got to the soap aisle, his son watched in amazement as saw row after row of giant sized soap bars. The truth was his father was so cheap, he had brought home hotel soap for the entire kids life.
 
when I broke the news to my boss that I was going to interview for a job with Horizon, I became public enemy number one. I was pretty much told I wouldn't be getting any more multi time,

uncanny

I was dumb enough to give a month notice.
-------
The good news my current flight school is top notch. I couldn't be happier with company ops, mx, the boss, the chief and the knowledge and experience of my fellow flight instructors.

Even if there were jobs available it would be hard to leave this place.
 
Back
Top