Ramblings of a flight school owner

I hear a lot of people complaining about flight schools , how bad they treat their employees, how bad the owners are.. The impression that I get at this forum that the owners are no different than the used car salesman who sell the 1990 Geo Metro to a grandma for $5000.

Let me say that I saw many bad owners and many good owners in my 20 years of flying. I think I never lost the sight of being a primary student when I fly with other people. I still remember how bad I felt when I first tried steep turns.. I also remember when I was charged with $10 /hr fuel surcharge and $15/hr more when you are flying solo..

I don't deny that there are some bad examples out there..

On the other hand, I started to fly in 1990. Until right before 9/11 the amount of time you spent in flight instructing was more than a year. Also, until last year, there were people who never spent time instructing because of the boom in the hiring..

When I got my first instructing job , the owner charged me for the aircraft.
I said 'Why would you charge me for the check out because I will be working for you , making you money'... So when I opened my own flight school I said 'instructors don't pay for the aircraft check out'.. Simple as that..

In last 5 years, 3 out of 10 instructors just got checked out in the airplane and then quit out of the blue.. No advance notice, no offers like 'Hey, you paid for my check out, I appreciate it, can i at least cover the fuel?'.. In addition to that some of them even started to bad mouth us..

I was amazed how immoral these people are.. I couldn't even believe people would have the nerve to do that..

Now, every instructor signs a paper that they need to reimburse me for the expenses if they leave within 6 months.. Am I proud of that? No.. Absoultely not.. But you are asking me to spend $1500 on a CFI who doesn't even work more than a week..

So, my motto has always been treat the people like the way you want to be treated.. Unfortunately there are more people without that motto in their lives..
 
So, my motto has always been treat the people like the way you want to be treated.

So you always wanted to make <$20/hr always wondering how you are going to pay your bills as you live on credit cards some more. I have no compassion.

You want to talk about retention, how about pay your instructors a livable wage and maybe they won't jump ship the first chance they got.

If you pay your instructors what they are worth then disregard.
 
So you always wanted to make <$20/hr always wondering how you are going to pay your bills as you live on credit cards some more. I have no compassion.

You want to talk about retention, how about pay your instructors a livable wage and maybe they won't jump ship the first chance they got.

If you pay your instructors what they are worth then disregard.
No where did he post about what he pays his instructors. Give the guy the bennefit of the doubt and don't jump down his throat!
 
Now, every instructor signs a paper that they need to reimburse me for the expenses if they leave within 6 months.. Am I proud of that? No.. Absoultely not.. But you are asking me to spend $1500 on a CFI who doesn't even work more than a week..

Exactly what are you doing for the checkout that costs you $1500? And $1500 is a pretty low cost for recruitment. Two months salary is a typical commision for placement firms. Hiring employees isn't cheap.

Considering most CFIs have no idea what they are going to make when they take a job, it is hard to expect them to guarantee they will stay.

FBO/Flight schools have a pretty good business model compared to many others. The capital costs are small. Aircraft leasebacks make the A/C owners shoulder all of the risk for maintenance and insurance costs (very few other business leases work this way). The CFIs assume the risk that they will be scheduled (few flight schools pay salaries). Customers are often pressured to pay up-front (customers in many industries get credit terms).
 
So you always wanted to make <$20/hr always wondering how you are going to pay your bills as you live on credit cards some more. I have no compassion.

You want to talk about retention, how about pay your instructors a livable wage and maybe they won't jump ship the first chance they got.

If you pay your instructors what they are worth then disregard.

I took a massive paycut when I left flight instructing. Didn't make more until I was a Lear captain. Some choose not to fly for bottom feeders and screw over their fellow instructors. It's obvious the route you are choosing....
 
I took a massive paycut when I left flight instructing. Didn't make more until I was a Lear captain. Some choose not to fly for bottom feeders and screw over their fellow instructors. It's obvious the route you are choosing....

:rotfl:

Get a room you two.

He choose to be a Flight Attendant. Leave the boy alone now. ;)
 
So you always wanted to make <$20/hr always wondering how you are going to pay your bills as you live on credit cards some more. I have no compassion.

You want to talk about retention, how about pay your instructors a livable wage and maybe they won't jump ship the first chance they got.

If you pay your instructors what they are worth then disregard.

I thought it was a pretty interesting perspective. And I have no compassion for people who take a job paying <$20 an hour, and then complain about it. I would wager that most of the country makes less than $20 an hour - without the prospects of making much more than that.
 
I took a massive paycut when I left flight instructing. Didn't make more until I was a Lear captain. Some choose not to fly for bottom feeders and screw over their fellow instructors. It's obvious the route you are choosing....

I make 20/hr right now which isn't to bad just looking at the job postings. When the economy is garbage though and no one flies I make 0/hr.

I just can't stand when flight schools complain about retention. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out why or how.

But again as always SkyGod, I am here to screw my fellow Aviators.
 
I thought it was a pretty interesting perspective. And I have no compassion for people who take a job paying <$20 an hour, and then complain about it. I would wager that most of the country makes less than $20 an hour - without the prospects of making much more than that.

$20 dollars an hr isn't bad when you work 40 hrs a week.
 
FlightSchoolOwner - welcome to JC; some are a little tightly wound around here lately, so please ignore them.

The others, however, offer productive feedback - and I'll give you mine, for what it's worth (it's actually worth about $3.87 + tax)

I see a number of issues at hand, most of which can be resolved. First, most flight schools do not advertise truthfully (ie. basing cost on FAA minimums) in order to get the client through the door. That's all well and good in my mind, but the issue of not being super-stupendous student needs to be addressed immediately when the client asks for a ball park price of training. I have found that the most truthful employers/FBO training facilities which address this have the greatest retention of clients and instructors. The reason? The client is informed, and understands actual cost vs. theoretical cost. Happier clients make happier CFIs.

Additionally, as a client I HATE to be strung along because of CFI incompetence. By that I mean that the CFI does not have an incentive to create a tailored program to the individuals strength and weaknesses. I would be more inclined to work longer for an employer that paid for my time that generated them money. If that means tossing me (as the CFI, not client) an extra $100 a week to take care of being on top of client curriculums, I think that is money well spent.

One thing I have found, that you seem to know already, is that if you treat the customer well, they will be more satisfied and most likely spend additional discretionary income at your facility. Again, happy clients make for happy CFIs. Why? That income may trickle over into additional training, making both money for the company and putting more in the CFI pocket.

Kudos to you for not having a potential employee pay for a checkout. I agree with your philosophy, including signing a contract. BIMHO, the contract should only cover the revenue lost in the checkout flight rather than a period of time, because the income generated in 6 months in the summer can be dramatically different from the winter.

Retention of instructors seems to be directly tied to QOL. If both working environment and pay are significant, expect your CFIs to stick around longer. Last FBO I worked for I stayed 3 years as a CFI! Why? I was given fair raises when warrented, gained additional responsibilities and had considerable animosity to make my own judgments. Those go a long way with me personally, and those raises? they weren't insignificant.

I guess what I mean to say is that I :clap: (I hate that emoticon :) ) your efforts to run a business looking at it from the prospective of a client or CFI. Where is your school?
 
This was all I am trying to say in my original post to stop this flame session.

Compensation Directly Determines Retention
 
So you always wanted to make <$20/hr always wondering how you are going to pay your bills as you live on credit cards some more. I have no compassion.

You want to talk about retention, how about pay your instructors a livable wage and maybe they won't jump ship the first chance they got.

If you pay your instructors what they are worth then disregard.


Its a jump to conclusions mat!
 
Edit: I am curious in the itemized 1500 spent on new hires.

Me too - 15+ hours seems like an awfully long time to checkout a CFI in a 172 or a Cherokee. And I fail to understand why a new CFI would need to be checked out in anything other than the trainer that they would be in 95% of the time at first.

My opinion is that you should be paying your employees for that time anyway, since it is something you are requiring them to do. Last I checked, that was called "work."

If you don't want so much risk of employees leaving, sign a contract with them. As long as you have the right to fire them whenever you want, they have the right quit whenever they want. Sign a contract agreeing to guarantee their pay for 6 months, and I doubt you will have as much trouble with them leaving.

Or, you could pay your CFIs to sign a non-compete agreement. (dirt bag thing to do in my opinion, but so is going after former employees for training costs)

3 quiting in 5 years isn't bad anyway, given the high turnover in the business in general.
 
It is a tough industry. Really it is an extension of the regionals. Why would anyone want to sit around a flight school and bill 60 hours a months at $20 an hour, with no benefits? Flight time... they are paid $100 in flight time and $20 to eat...
When they can escape to the next step they will. I know some flight school owners that are top notch (as you seem to be), but they are constrained by the market and industry norm where the cut throat operators set the market. If you can pay a salary (or a minimum)of $3000 a month, benefits and treat them right, you would have no problem retaining outstanding career oriented CFIs. If you can't or won't then please don't take it personally. You are in a tough business, but really I don't blame any CFI for leaving in a heartbeat. Perhaps if the president can get universal health care through, the lack of benefits may not be such a detriment to retention for flight schools.
I will point out, as I have before that a FI in Europe can command a figure comparable with a Regional Captain in the US in a reputable Ab Initio academy. Many do it for a career. But there, regulation makes GA as a business a rare thing indeed.
 
FlightSchoolOwner - welcome to JC; some are a little tightly wound around here lately, so please ignore them.

The others, however, offer productive feedback - and I'll give you mine, for what it's worth (it's actually worth about $3.87 + tax)

I see a number of issues at hand, most of which can be resolved. First, most flight schools do not advertise truthfully (ie. basing cost on FAA minimums) in order to get the client through the door. That's all well and good in my mind, but the issue of not being super-stupendous student needs to be addressed immediately when the client asks for a ball park price of training. I have found that the most truthful employers/FBO training facilities which address this have the greatest retention of clients and instructors. The reason? The client is informed, and understands actual cost vs. theoretical cost. Happier clients make happier CFIs.

Additionally, as a client I HATE to be strung along because of CFI incompetence. By that I mean that the CFI does not have an incentive to create a tailored program to the individuals strength and weaknesses. I would be more inclined to work longer for an employer that paid for my time that generated them money. If that means tossing me (as the CFI, not client) an extra $100 a week to take care of being on top of client curriculums, I think that is money well spent.

One thing I have found, that you seem to know already, is that if you treat the customer well, they will be more satisfied and most likely spend additional discretionary income at your facility. Again, happy clients make for happy CFIs. Why? That income may trickle over into additional training, making both money for the company and putting more in the CFI pocket.

Kudos to you for not having a potential employee pay for a checkout. I agree with your philosophy, including signing a contract. BIMHO, the contract should only cover the revenue lost in the checkout flight rather than a period of time, because the income generated in 6 months in the summer can be dramatically different from the winter.

Retention of instructors seems to be directly tied to QOL. If both working environment and pay are significant, expect your CFIs to stick around longer. Last FBO I worked for I stayed 3 years as a CFI! Why? I was given fair raises when warrented, gained additional responsibilities and had considerable animosity to make my own judgments. Those go a long way with me personally, and those raises? they weren't insignificant.

I guess what I mean to say is that I :clap: (I hate that emoticon :) ) your efforts to run a business looking at it from the prospective of a client or CFI. Where is your school?

Autonomy? Usually I don't get too concerned about the grammar, but we're talking two very different words and meanings.

I agree though, often times it's hard to put a price on autonomy in the workplace. That's one of the benefits to teaching high school students, I have a great deal of autonomy with how I run my classroom.
 
Back
Top