Question for regional pilots. (or mainline)

For the record, we've actually recieved requests from most major American Air Carriers to NOT give direct unless the pilot specifically asks for it, we're not even supposed to offer direct routings, they feel the airlines flight planning software knows better I guess....


You work center stuff where the "great circle" comes into effect. I work in the congested northeast where to go from IAD to PHL an aircraft has to depart due north, turn northeast for 20mi, turn southeast for 20mi, turn east for 25mi then turn northeast towards DQO to PHL. If I give them direct DQO after the initial NE turn it cuts a lot of time off. Believe me the airline computer says "we want IAD direct PHL" our computer says "HAHAHAHA I want world peace but neithers going to happen."
 
Yes, I will always take a shortcut unless I'm over mountainous terrain and at a weight that prohibits off route clearances (due to single engine performance). If it's hot outside or the use of anti-ice might be required, the ERJ has to float down to ~ 12,000 ft if an engine fails, therefore we aren't allowed to take off route clearances if terrain in the area exceeds that. The other exceptions are if I'm borderline on being overweight for landing and need to burn off as much fuel as possible or if the shortcut will put me more than 50 NM off shore.
 
I'm only a student but I observed an interesting situation once in regards to your question. I was outside in my backyard, and saw an American MD-80 on approach to Austin. It was unusually loud, and it was obvious to see his landing gear out with full flaps and he was going slowww. Usually over my house they may just have the slats out and travelling above 200 knots. I live about 15-20nm north of the airport.

I was about to disregard it as a plane that slowed up unusually soon then I saw it make a 90 degree turn to the East. I went inside and watched it curiously on the flight tracker. It made a series of circles all around the city just East of where I was before it then continued back on the approach path into Austin.

So I tried to see what was up, and saw KAUS was up on LiveATC that day so I got on it, and I heard Tower ask "American#### just curious why were you out circling to the north for" to which the pilot replied "We were cleared direct, and we had too much fuel on board so we needed to burn some off before landing."

Basically to the effect of too heavy to land.

Note this plane came in from DFW so it was a fairly short hop. It was the strangest thing I had ever seen or heard. But in this case he took direct, but it seems it didn't help them out much because they needed to get under the MLW.
 
Short flight <30 mins, I can give you a shortcut that will cut 20+ miles off the trip or just leave you on the route. Do you want the shortcut? Does it depend on the situation? Is there a general rule I could follow?

Reason I have asked is I have seen it many ways, sometimes I get asked for the shortcut, sometimes I get told they would rather stay on the route. Other times I give a shortcut or a better altitude (IE 10,000 vs 8 or 9) and I am the coolest controller ever. And on the flip side sometimes I catch an attitude on the readback like I just pissed in their cereal.


So whats the deal you guys/gals want to milk the gate-to-gate time or you just want to get it done quick for some kind of bonus. I am all ears and open to suggestions.


Also lastly is there quick question I could ask to find out how they want it?

Nothing wrong with offering!!! Seems to me that most folks would accept direct. Regionals have enough "quick turns" built into the schedules that an extra 5-10 min saved could mean enough time for a real meal of food (!) at the destination before the next flight out.

Kind of sad you are getting attitude however personally I really appreciate the controllers who offer shortcuts. We can always say no.
 
Nothing wrong with offering!!! Seems to me that most folks would accept direct. Regionals have enough "quick turns" built into the schedules that an extra 5-10 min saved could mean enough time for a real meal of food (!) at the destination before the next flight out.

Kind of sad you are getting attitude however personally I really appreciate the controllers who offer shortcuts. We can always say no.

Amen!
 
My passengers want to get there quickly...I want the shortcut, nearly every time. Please offer, we'll take 'em when it's feasible.

Guys who milk for money are not doing their passengers a service, they are acting selfishly to make a couple of extra bucks, not cool in my book.

It's one thing to fly profile, and quite another to purposefully slow down to enhance your paycheck.
 
My passengers want to get there quickly...I want the shortcut, nearly every time. Please offer, we'll take 'em when it's feasible.

Guys who milk for money are not doing their passengers a service, they are acting selfishly to make a couple of extra bucks, not cool in my book.

It's one thing to fly profile, and quite another to purposefully slow down to enhance your paycheck.

Yeah that one will usually catch up with you. What's funny about that is most think their companies don't notice them overblocking.

I'll usually take a shortcut/more direct route if offered. Things like weather, adverse winds or if I am running way ahead of schedule, (How often does that happen?) might influence me to stay on a filed course.
 
Nothing wrong with offering!!! Seems to me that most folks would accept direct. Regionals have enough "quick turns" built into the schedules that an extra 5-10 min saved could mean enough time for a real meal of food (!) at the destination before the next flight out.

Kind of sad you are getting attitude however personally I really appreciate the controllers who offer shortcuts. We can always say no.

Ehh nothing serious, more like a tone of severe disappointment. I would say 50% of my shortcuts offer an operational advantage to me in some way, 40% because it is slow enough that I could pretty much give you anything you wanted and 10% involve a request I have to actually do some extra work to help you guys/gals out. Most of the time in the last case where the shortcut is denied, the operational disadvantage extends beyond me and I don't like passing on problems.
 
I agree with Corporate Pilot. Pilots being paid by the flight hour will opt for the longest way possible. Also "time builders" will also.

Fr8dogs, corporate pilots, owner pilots or anyone else watching the bottom line will usually opt for the short cut.

BTW, I will always take the short-cut .... that gets me to the bar/buffet that much faster! :)
 
Back
Top