PSA MEC asking for Envoy pilots to transfer?

Not sure what PSAs motives were here.

As an Eagle pilot I must say that there is some bitter irony in what I believe, and many others as well, to be the sword in the back of the Stop the Whipsaw movement, trying to "Stop the Whipsaw".

That being said, if their true intentions are to say that there is no point in transferring the planes or pilots right now, then I must thank them. That is the best deal for all parties; let Eagle hold the planes for a little longer.

If it is to try and "steal", yes I said it, our already beleaguered pilots in order to fund an operation currently in complete disarray, shame on them. Going over at the "same pay" is not enough. Why would someone go over to PSA for just that? There is no furlough here. What about benefits? Flow(3-5 Yrs instead of 20 at PSA?). What about the pure shame of having to go fly for the guys that you believe hurt the stand together crowd.

A few fact corrections:
-STW was NOT mainly Eagle pilots. At one point we had almost 4000 pilots and it was a pretty good mix of Eagle, Xjet, RAH, and then some others. RAH dominated.
-We did not get to vote in the aircraft transfer. Our MEC said it was going to happen one way or another and they might as well get something for it(if you believe all that). Most of us found out after the fact and were outraged.

In the end, we all like to think we have some control over this, but of course we don't. The planes belong to AAG and they will do as they see fit. Attrition at Eagle has slowed. It's not much, but we have SLIGHTLY more pilots than planned, for the first time in almost 2 years of shrinking. What is most telling is why attrition has slowed. Will it continue? Who knows. I bet it a certainty it will if upgrades start again now rather than a year and half from now.

PSA will still get their(our) planes eventually. They just need to solve their training problem. 1200 pilots and 450 of them are either in training or doing the training(I'm told). That is a big bubble.

But hey, hiring is slowing everywhere. PSA has gotten most of their new hires from other regionals. As that slows, maybe they can't actually staff these later. If their intent is to "Stop the Whipsaw", then it is a win because the planes never leave Eagle.

My money is on AAG slowing the delivery of the 700s, as they see fit.
 
Last edited:
"Corporate culture" is just management bull dreamed up to make you think you're special instead of them having to pay you more to make you feel special. A pilot is a pilot is a pilot.

Cue @PhilosopherPilot disagreeing with me. ;)
I've seen enough management teams and enough airlines to know this is not true Growing up in a Pan Am town their culture was very different from others. SouthWest and DAL both operate 737s. The similarities stop there.
Hiring process are different- different airlines look for different things. Going through a merger process now there is a definite difference in the culture of the pilots. Do we move the sticks the same? Sure.
Saying a "pilot is a pilot" is like saying a software engineer is a software engineer. My brother has done that work for multiple companies, multiple cultures- Anheuser Bush, McDonald Douglas, IBM, Nokia.... I think a few others. Each had a different culture.
 
I've seen enough management teams and enough airlines to know this is not true Growing up in a Pan Am town their culture was very different from others. SouthWest and DAL both operate 737s. The similarities stop there.
Hiring process are different- different airlines look for different things. Going through a merger process now there is a definite difference in the culture of the pilots. Do we move the sticks the same? Sure.
Saying a "pilot is a pilot" is like saying a software engineer is a software engineer. My brother has done that work for multiple companies, multiple cultures- Anheuser Bush, McDonald Douglas, IBM, Nokia.... I think a few others. Each had a different culture.

I think you may have made his point for him. Your brother worked for several companies with different cultures. People adapt to their surroundings. Just because you worked somewhere with a particular culture doesn't mean that you can never work somewhere else.
 
image.jpg

There is the first page BTW.
 
Huh, I see it as them trying to lend a hand to an airline that is losing airplanes and give the pilots a better shot at some stability.

But keep holding on.
Your last sentence being combative, and not being interested in Internet combat, I'll just say this:

I want to believe you are right.
But
I don't believe you are right.
 
Your last sentence being combative, and not being interested in Internet combat, I'll just say this:

I want to believe you are right.
But
I don't believe you are right.
I meant it more towards the STW idea and the hatred of PSA, which seems to be a waste of ones time IMO. I originally deleted it but @Screaming_Emu quoted it before I deleted it. Had to put it back in and own it at the point.

Anyways, I again just see them trying to get the Envoy pilots that are trained and qualified over which will help them most likely career wise via upgrades and help PSA's staffing as well. Anywho back to my pancakes.
 
I think you may have made his point for him. Your brother worked for several companies with different cultures. People adapt to their surroundings. Just because you worked somewhere with a particular culture doesn't mean that you can never work somewhere else.
The thing is, some people can adapt, some can't. The reason my brother was so successful and continued to work for Nokia after they shut down their US operation was that he was able to adapt to their culture. They joke that he is more Finish than they are. Other software engineers could not and were let go. Again, in aviation this is the case as well. One of the worst things a pilot can do when training at a new airline is to go in with the attitude, or even worse, say out loud "We did it this way at XYZ airline." No one cares. Those are the guys who often have issues in training.
 
Last edited:
The thing is, some people can adapt, some can't. The reason my brother was so successful and continued to work for Nokia after they shut down their US operation was that he was able to adapt to their culture. They joke that he is more Finish than they are. Other software engineers could not and were let go. Again, in aviation this is the case as well. One of the worst things a pilot can do when training at a new airline is to go in with the attitude, or even worse, say out loud "We did it this way at XYZ airline." No one cares. Those are the guys who often have issues in training.

That's not a culture thing, that's just not being an insufferable ass.
 
That's not a culture thing, that's just not being an insufferable ass.

And again, that right there is a reason for not having one list. Some pilots are insufferable asses. Why in the world should they be permitted to bypass my airline's hiring process? Heck, some regional airlines don't even HAVE a hiring process. So if those airlines go under their pilots should just be able to waltz over and pump one of my pilots????? Heck with that.
 
Blackhawk said:
And again, that right there is a reason for not having one list. Some pilots are insufferable asses. Why in the world should they be permitted to bypass my airline's hiring process? Heck, some regional airlines don't even HAVE a hiring process. So if those airlines go under their pilots should just be able to waltz over and pump one of my pilots????? Heck with that.

Because your airline's hiring process is just glorified BS. That's why every airline has approximately the same percentage of insufferable asses, and why pilots can work for multiple airlines with very different "corporate cultures" over their careers without a problem. It's all BS.
 
But hey, hiring is slowing everywhere. PSA has gotten most of their new hires from other regionals. As that slows, maybe they can't actually staff these later. If their intent is to "Stop the Whipsaw", then it is a win because the planes never leave Eagle.

My money is on AAG slowing the delivery of the 700s, as they see fit.

This comes out of the Eagle and XJT pilot groups all the time. The line of, "they'll never be able to staff the new flying!" has proven to be inaccurate. People keep walking through the door at TSA, Compass, Mesa and PSA, and it's not going to stop.
 
Because your airline's hiring process is just glorified BS. That's why every airline has approximately the same percentage of insufferable asses, and why pilots can work for multiple airlines with very different "corporate cultures" over their careers without a problem. It's all BS.
Yes, people slip through the cracks but I would hardly call it glorified BS. That makes the assumption that all people are the same, but they aren't. Pilots are different just as management is different. If management were truly all the same all the airlines would perform equally and there would not be Braniff or a Pan Am.
Heck taking two airlines on "opposite extremes" SouthWest and FedEx. Different missions. Different airframes. Different cultures. Different work schedules and work rules. Different regulations.
Saying "one list" is as stupid as saying "one airline". As a consumer I would want neither.
 
Yes, people slip through the cracks but I would hardly call it glorified BS. That makes the assumption that all people are the same, but they aren't. Pilots are different just as management is different. If management were truly all the same all the airlines would perform equally and there would not be Braniff or a Pan Am.

Pilots are interchangeable, and need to be so. Managers are not. I know this may offend some pilots, but it's true.

You can taken any SWA pilot, drop him into a FedEx class, and he'll be no different than any other FedEx pilot in no time flat, and vice versa.
 
Pilots are interchangeable, and need to be so. Managers are not. I know this may offend some pilots, but it's true.

You can taken any SWA pilot, drop him into a FedEx class, and he'll be no different than any other FedEx pilot in no time flat, and vice versa.

Having flown with numerous pilots, military, part 91, 135 and 121 and studied CRM accidents as well as being a CRM instructor that is so far from true. If this were the case any pilot could do the 160th mission. Any pilot could be a Blue Angel or a member of the Thunderbirds. There would be no difference between "Bud" Holland or "Sully" Sullenberger. Colgan 3407 never would have happened.
I've seen the issue with some FO's, who could not give up the Air Force way, the XYZ company way, or whatever. Some were terminated, not necessarily because they had bad stick and rudder skills, but they were not interchangeable with our pilots. It is part of why corporate departments put such an emphasis on interviews and assessing if a pilot will truly fit in.
Hiring processes are not and probably won't be perfect in our lifetime. Bad pilots make it through military training and some are washed out later. I've seen some good pilots make it through 160th assessment, just to wash out in Green Platoon or perhaps even make it to the line, but then not be able to adjust. They were great before, not so great in the 160th environment.
Again, it is not a perfect system, but it gets a group that, as a whole, fits or is able to fit the vision of the leadership.
 
Having flown with numerous pilots, military, part 91, 135 and 121 and studied CRM accidents as well as being a CRM instructor that is so far from true. If this were the case any pilot could do the 160th mission. Any pilot could be a Blue Angel or a member of the Thunderbirds. There would be no difference between "Bud" Holland or "Sully" Sullenberger. Colgan 3407 never would have happened.

Now you're talking about skill, not culture, which is obviously a much different issue, and even more difficult (impossible) to screen for in an interview process. Regardless, except for that exceptionally rare instance such as the "miracle on the Hudson," pilots are interchangeable in skill also when it comes to ordinary airline flying, which is why airline travel is so safe today.

I've seen the issue with some FO's, who could not give up the Air Force way, the XYZ company way, or whatever. Some were terminated, not necessarily because they had bad stick and rudder skills, but they were not interchangeable with our pilots.

And this happens in spite of your vaunted interview process, and would not change without it. A pilot is a pilot is a pilot...

Again, it is not a perfect system, but it gets a group that, as a whole, fits or is able to fit the vision of the leadership.

Yeah, we aren't going to agree. :)
 
Back
Top