Pinnacle Mesaba Colgan Transition and merger

Don't you worry about senior Mesaba guys. The 300 or so guys that are there, hired prior to 2000. More than 1/3 of them have guaranteed spots at Delta once Delta starts hiring again. They will bail. And keep in mind, the senior Mesaba guys were gonna get shafted once the Saabs were gone, by losing their QOL with a decreasing/shrinking pilot group from resulting furloughs. In fact, one can argue that the SLI is a savior to the senior Mesaba guys, whether its DOH or relative. And yeah, I don't want anyone junior to jump over a senior pilot when it comes to us, Pinnacle, the buying airline for one airline that was shrinking with Saabs parking, and another that is expanding tremendously due to Pinnacle buyout and financial lending for Qs. And what's the "drop a few grand for a shortcut" comment? Plenty of Colgan pilots came out of Gulfstream, Jet U, ALLATPs, and the likes, with 250-500 hrs. No different than Pinnacle.


Pretty sure those senior -900 guys really didn't care about the Saabs getting parked. It's not like a lot of Saab CAs would be bumping them down in seniority. I'd bet at WORST they'd lose a day or two off a month. Not that large of a hit in the QoL dept. I wouldn't say the SLI is a "savior to the senior Mesaba guys." The junior guys, maybe. Also, Pinnacle is NOT the acquiring carrier. XJ was bought by Pinnacle Corp, not Pinnacle Airlines Inc. Would you say ABC bought ESPN? Both are subsidiaries of the Walt Disney Corporation. As for the "drop a few grand on a short cut," you're fine with jumping guys outta JetU that might be more qualified than you, but you'll be damned if someone is gonna jump you to get "your" spot.

This is completely irrelevant. One always needs to meet the upgrade time requirements at their airline, regardless of when they started. For Pinnacle, it's 2,500TT if you already have 1,000TT at the company. I hit that mark in 2009. But there was no hiring, no movement at Pinnacle. Pinnacle management was too busy buying Q400s for Colgan and trying to pay off a loan debt to think about hiring and upgrading, even when people were still trickling away (attrition).

So, you're jealous of guys that already upgraded at Colgan, or what? Sorry your plan didn't work out. Mine didn't either. Being on reserve for 3 years wasn't my first choice when I started flying back in 2002. Assuming things had kept going as they did when I first started out as a CFI back in 2005, I'd likely be at a major by now. The economy and age 65 had other ideas. Rather than jumping on an internet message board and playing the "Woe is me" game looking for sympathy, I sucked it up and dealt with it. This merger is gonna bring pain to pretty much everyone in the pilot group. God forbid you have to wait a few more months to upgrade....

Guys, this is NOT how a majority of us 9E guys feel about the Mesaba and Colgan pilots. Most of us just want to get through this as quickly as we can and move on. CC and I have been having this same conversation over and over again since he enrolled at JetU. At least there's consistency somewhere....
 
This is completely irrelevant. One always needs to meet the upgrade time requirements at their airline, regardless of when they started. For Pinnacle, it's 2,500TT if you already have 1,000TT at the company. I hit that mark in 2009. But there was no hiring, no movement at Pinnacle. Pinnacle management was too busy buying Q400s for Colgan and trying to pay off a loan debt to think about hiring and upgrading, even when people were still trickling away (attrition).



No it's completely RELEVANT! My point is that you don't know how to FLY yet! You have not crapped your pants enough times in an airplane to be a PIC on anything but a Cherokee Cruiser. The kind of experience you get as a CFI for three years doing smash and goes or the kind of experience you get by HAND FLYING a turboprop through crappy weather. Being an SIC on a jet is about "Gear Up and Shut Up". Which you obviously have not learned the second part of yet!
 
Pretty sure those senior -900 guys really didn't care about the Saabs getting parked. It's not like a lot of Saab CAs would be bumping them down in seniority. I'd bet at WORST they'd lose a day or two off a month. Not that large of a hit in the QoL dept. I wouldn't say the SLI is a "savior to the senior Mesaba guys." The junior guys, maybe. Also, Pinnacle is NOT the acquiring carrier. XJ was bought by Pinnacle Corp, not Pinnacle Airlines Inc. Would you say ABC bought ESPN? Both are subsidiaries of the Walt Disney Corporation.

As for the "drop a few grand on a short cut," you're fine with jumping guys outta JetU that might be more qualified than you, but you'll be damned if someone is gonna jump you to get "your" spot.

I don't get it. Your time spent previously before the airline is, and should be, irrelevant. All that matters is your start date at the airline. It doesn't matter if I was Jet U and you were a CFI. You and I both chose our own paths. Same for everybody else. I didn't do something that was exclusive to me only. I did something that ANY other pilot could have chosen to do in 2007. They decided to either do it or not do it. So, it's an irrelevant point. You cannot even begin to justify someone junior going senior above a 9E guy because the junior guy was a CFI for 3 years before and the 9E guy was a 4-month Jet U only? That is bogus. Your previous activities before XJ/9L/9E should be irrelevant.


So, you're jealous of guys that already upgraded at Colgan, or what? Sorry your plan didn't work out. Mine didn't either. Being on reserve for 3 years wasn't my first choice when I started flying back in 2002. Assuming things had kept going as they did when I first started out as a CFI back in 2005, I'd likely be at a major by now. The economy and age 65 had other ideas. Rather than jumping on an internet message board and playing the "Woe is me" game looking for sympathy, I sucked it up and dealt with it. This merger is gonna bring pain to pretty much everyone in the pilot group. God forbid you have to wait a few more months to upgrade....

Guys, this is NOT how a majority of us 9E guys feel about the Mesaba and Colgan pilots. Most of us just want to get through this as quickly as we can and move on. CC and I have been having this same conversation over and over again since he enrolled at JetU. At least there's consistency somewhere....
Not jealous of them, but like you said, they already got their quick movements, upgrades, and increase in QOL. Now it'd be a double slap in the face if they jump over more seniority over more senior Pinnacle folks. And btw, you and I have NOT had these talks since Jet U. Since Jet U, we've had talks about RJ programs. This SLI talk is new. Something that came up just a few months ago with "one contract, one list, one voice." Lets keep facts straight while we are at it.
 
No it's completely RELEVANT! My point is that you don't know how to FLY yet! You have not crapped your pants enough times in an airplane to be a PIC on anything but a Cherokee Cruiser. The kind of experience you get as a CFI for three years doing smash and goes or the kind of experience you get by HAND FLYING a turboprop through crappy weather. Being an SIC on a jet is about "Gear Up and Shut Up". Which you obviously have not learned the second part of yet!
That is an ignorant post. If you are a Colgan pilot, you should know better.
 
While I think that CC is outside of "moderate", I would also say that "gear up, shut up" is way out of line as well. On the Sli front we can all place our arguments and discontent but the fact is that we all had choices. If you don't like it you can always quit. If you were chasing a "quick upgrade" you could have gone to Colgan at the time. Now some will want the jet time and with hiring going on it may be that the Jet is more favorable to getting "out" OR it could simply be a TPIC equation. Once again- we won't know til afterwards when the hindsight is always 20/20.

My personal thoughts on Sli are mine and will be kept in my head, but by-and-large we are all going to be upset. The big question(s) will be fences and possible "windfalls" that are obscenely apparent if they come to fruition as some hope and (in many cases) expect. Whether we like it or not we will all be in this as one group- we now must choose to rip each other apart or professionally move on in our careers in a manner that best suits our own personal needs.
 
No it's completely RELEVANT! My point is that you don't know how to FLY yet! You have not crapped your pants enough times in an airplane to be a PIC on anything but a Cherokee Cruiser. The kind of experience you get as a CFI for three years doing smash and goes or the kind of experience you get by HAND FLYING a turboprop through crappy weather. Being an SIC on a jet is about "Gear Up and Shut Up". Which you obviously have not learned the second part of yet!

Hey Captain Van Zanten, haven't you learned anything in your CRM training?!? Apparently not......


That is an ignorant post. If you are a Colgan pilot, you should know better.

You know, CC is really out in left field on this SLI thing.....but the gear up/ shut up statement above might be the dumbest thing I've read yet in this thread (and that's definitely saying something).

Wow, perhaps you two could hug it out or something. Then you can BOTH learn a little about teamwork.....because you need it.
 
That is an ignorant post. If you are a Colgan pilot, you should know better.

Is that the first time you actually used the word Colgan in this thread. Let me rephrase it for you in your language:

"That is an ignorant post, If you are a pilot for the crappy airline that Pinnacle Management Corporation bought in 2007, and who got to upgrade before me even though my hard work, after I got hired with only 250hrs, paid for all your Q400s that you don't even fly, you should know better" Sound better.

Dude your gonna upgrade this year. No one from Colgan is going to come to Detroit just to fly a jet. You'll have your CA seat making more money than a Colgan SAAB CA. I'd say that's just as good as being senior to him. The maybe you can get your picture taken for one of those Jet U ads. "0 hours to JET CAPTAIN in 36 months"
 
I think there is a lot of misrepresented information coming from a lot of people and it is coming from emotion, not from the facts.

A few things:

-Pinnacle used to be a wholly owned airline just like Mesaba (ref: Express I Airlines)
-Mesaba was a growing company prior to the aquisition of NWA inc. by DAL
-Without previously mentioned aquisition Pinnacle was only flying 12? CRJ9s for DAL and DAL was trying their hardest to drop that contract Mesa style. So without the merger Pinnacle would be a CRJ200 operator with a few CRJ900s
-Pinnacle didn't have any contracts with any other carrier. Period.
-Colgan had contracts with UAL, CAL and USair.
-While Pinnacle Corps. helped finance the new airframes, find me one corporation that doesn't look to reinvest money outside it's primary source of income.
-With Colgan Pinnacle now has a foot in the door with almost every other legacy left.
-The Mesaba aquisition gives more CRJ9s to Pinnacle (read: a lot more) and also guarantees more lift with DAL.

The thing that I think needs to be made clear here is that every airline is bringing something to the table, whether it's more airframes, growth potential with other companies, an industry leading contract, or a long term contract with one of the world's largest airlines. Nobody should be sitting here think "my airline is the best for this reason and everything else the other airlines bring doesn't matter to me". It is also painful to sit here and read people that are looking for a way so that their upgrade comes now and they don't care about anyone else. It's sickening and unfortunately this is the new generation these days that's all about me, me and when I'm sick of me I go to the mirror to see more me. Just do your jobs people and let Bloch do his.
 
Hey Captain Van Zanten, haven't you learned anything in your CRM training?!? Apparently not......



Van Zanten is my idol :).

Guys I'm really just kidding about the "Gear Up Shut Up" thing. It's an old joke that was used to describe the "co-pilot". Maybe I''m aging myself too much. Anyone who knows me knows that's not how I operate. There is however a little to be said for it. A rookie FO at his first job should be humble enough to tone it down a bit. CC hasn't realized this yet. He thinks he's a veteran and has certain rights over other pilots just because he got hired a whopping year before them.

The point I'm making is that I am dead set against anyone getting put into the right seat of a jet with 250 hrs. It's not safe, period! It was a bad time in this industry that should never be repeated.
 
The contract is worth enough that we haven't parked any airplanes. Unlike Comair, Mesaba.......
And Eagle could be sold, but we'll have to see. They are on the expensive side, and no one wants to buy a large regional these days.

You have a lot of faith in your contract with Delta, and banking on a contract that is up in a few years is really short sighted.

You make infer that Colgan wouldn't have the Q's without pinnacle pilots sweating off a 191m. Note. You toss it in their like you had anything to do with that money. You make radical claims that some junior 9l guy is going to come take your spot, while it seems like you think Pinnacle pilots are going to be ransacked and sent to the street because mesaba is pilot heavy.

Have you seen ANY colgan guys talking about jumping to go fly the CRJ? I haven't. How many senior Messaba guys have a delta number? how many of those senior guys are on the saab, which is going away?

Why do you think we will even furlough?

sorry man, the girls knocked up, and she's keepin the baby.... freaking out about it now isn't gonna change what's going to come out in a few months.
 
Wouldnt count on that, many have already bipassed and once you do your SOL. There down to the 150s to 200 # already I believe, anyone have some better insight? Either way they are kinda far down the list to be hoping that 300 will go to Delta, quite a few senior guys said no thanks.


Don't you worry about senior Mesaba guys. The 300 or so guys that are there, hired prior to 2000. More than 1/3 of them have guaranteed spots at Delta once Delta starts hiring again. They will bail. And keep in mind, the senior Mesaba guys were gonna get shafted once the Saabs were gone, by losing their QOL with a decreasing/shrinking pilot group from resulting furloughs. In fact, one can argue that the SLI is a savior to the senior Mesaba guys, whether its DOH or relative. And yeah, I don't want anyone junior to jump over a senior pilot when it comes to us, Pinnacle, the buying airline for one airline that was shrinking with Saabs parking, and another that is expanding tremendously due to Pinnacle buyout and financial lending for Qs. And what's the "drop a few grand for a shortcut" comment? Plenty of Colgan pilots came out of Gulfstream, Jet U, ALLATPs, and the likes, with 250-500 hrs. No different than Pinnacle.
 
I'll come back later for some fun, and stir some stuff up. Going to dog park right now to slosh around. Gotta say though, great to see Chairohhkey still in this thing. You God damn trainwreck, you are amazing, you make my whole day sometimes.

BTW, I was 1900 FO to saab CA to -900 FO. Jet's are cake :) 1900's still beat everything.
 
Ya know, I just had a thought. CC when were you hired in 2007? If it was after Jan 18th, then you should have KNOWN a potential SLI with Colgan was a possibility (if not a probability). Why didn't you just go somewhere else since some of those guys could have jumped you even as a new hire FO? I mean, you yourself said Colgan hired some Jet U guys. Why didn't you go there instead of Pinnacle? You could already be a Q captain living the high life.....
 
He can't be the only one.

Oh SON!

highlander.jpg


I don't even need to caption that!
 
Back
Top