Pilot doesn't know how to use a transponder...

So do we all share a percentage of fault for what happened, or should that guy be called out for being an idiot and endangering people?

That depends, did he retract his flaps in the flair?

My only point is in your original statement it's see and be seen and you must agree the other pilot was no more in fault than you.
 
That depends, did he retract his flaps in the flair?

My only point is in your original statement it's see and be seen and you must agree the other pilot was no more in fault than you.
BS. If he had a radio and didn't use it, he is more at fault than the guy using the radio. Plus the downwind landing...
 
That depends, did he retract his flaps in the flair?

My only point is in your original statement it's see and be seen and you must agree the other pilot was no more in fault than you.

I'm not trying to pick sides here, but had that happened where I did the majority of my flight instruction (landing down wind, against the flow of traffic, not talking when the airplane has a radio) the locals would have beat the guy to a pulp both verbally and most likely physically too.

If you have a radio, USE IT! If you're not sure about the situation, circle overhead for a minute, plan it out and execute your plan.

Edit: boy, did I booger the spelling!
 
Last edited:
BS. If he had a radio and didn't use it, he is more at fault than the guy using the radio. Plus the downwind landing...

Nothing was said about the wind until the poster was bailing water from his sinking boat. However, landing downwind at controlled and uncontrolled airports is common. Several factors can dictate it from runway slope, terrain, trees, airports which share common airspace. The LA basin is fun when most controlled airports switch runways at the same time regardless of wind direction at each location.

Radios on 122.8... Everyone is talking over the top of each other. Who's to say the two involved weren't blocking each other. A radio isn't required at an uncontrolled airport anyway.

Despite how one pilot may perceive another pilots ability or technique you're still required to operate your aircraft in a safe manor.

505fb2a2f79c3679eefb55b354f610d6.jpg
 
Last edited:
Despite how one pilot may perceive another pilots ability or technique you're still required to operate your aircraft in a safe manor
505fb2a2f79c3679eefb55b354f610d6.jpg

Same hold true for both "pancakes." I can't always predict what the other guy is going to do. For the most part, I can reasonably assume that the guy would have been making radio calls, and will not land down wind. How do you think the NTSB report would have looked had it turned into an accident?
 
Lets be honest, we all make mistakes and this guy was caught on the radio making a bonehead mistake. Being pilots, what do we do? Roast him over it. To be a pilot takes thick skin. When I was landing the aircraft carrier, every landing is watched by the entire ship; all radio calls are broadcasted over those same plat screens. When you screwed, and everyone did, everyone knew and beatings began!
 
Same hold true for both "pancakes." I can't always predict what the other guy is going to do. For the most part, I can reasonably assume that the guy would have been making radio calls, and will not land down wind. How do you think the NTSB report would have looked had it turned into an accident?
I wonder if the NTSB would ask the pilot shooting the straight-in approach when they established sight of the windsock? :)
 
The walk of shame.

I hated when the bolt was in my box (that's what she said :)). I remember I had two passes at the boat one day, going back to the beach in San Diego. My co-pilot was witness to the awful passes, both no-grades and by the time I got back, there was a diagram drawn on the board of my horrendous passes...labled Bunky's pass. We had some great artists at the squadron at the time :p
 
I wonder if the NTSB would ask the pilot shooting the straight-in approach when they established sight of the windsock? :)
And why, if he had visual of an aircraft, he continued a 20nm straight in rather than entering the pattern? Not saying I'd do differently in his position, but I rarely an in that position in my particular aircraft.
 
And why, if he had visual of an aircraft, he continued a 20nm straight in rather than entering the pattern? Not saying I'd do differently in his position, but I rarely an in that position in my particular aircraft.
I mentioned that in my previous post. Nothing kills my thoughts of a straight-in approach faster than aircraft in or around the pattern and no comms from other aircraft.

I used to fly into a field that was frequented by ultralights, many with no radios. Come in high, give everybody a chance to see you, establish active runway, enter the pattern by the book. Some times it took a couple of laps before everybody was on the same page but I can't recall any anxious moments.
 
I mentioned that in my previous post. Nothing kills my thoughts of a straight-in approach faster than aircraft in or around the pattern and no comms from other aircraft.

I used to fly into a field that was frequented by ultralights, many with no radios. Come in high, give everybody a chance to see you, establish active runway, enter the pattern by the book. Some times it took a couple of laps before everybody was on the same page but I can't recall any anxious moments.
Agreed. That's usually how we approach those situations. There aren't too many people flying around without radios in my AO, though. As far as I'm concerned it's better to err on the side of caution and just enter the pattern.
 
I hated when the bolt was in my box (that's what she said :)). I remember I had two passes at the boat one day, going back to the beach in San Diego. My co-pilot was witness to the awful passes, both no-grades and by the time I got back, there was a diagram drawn on the board of my horrendous passes...labled Bunky's pass. We had some great artists at the squadron at the time :p
Unless your bird ends below and up on jacks for a gear check you really aren't trying.
 
Nothing was said about the wind until the poster was bailing water from his sinking boat. However, landing downwind at controlled and uncontrolled airports is common. Several factors can dictate it from runway slope, terrain, trees, airports which share common airspace. The LA basin is fun when most controlled airports switch runways at the same time regardless of wind direction at each location.

Radios on 122.8... Everyone is talking over the top of each other. Who's to say the two involved weren't blocking each other. A radio isn't required at an uncontrolled airport anyway.

Despite how one pilot may perceive another pilots ability or technique you're still required to operate your aircraft in a safe manor.

505fb2a2f79c3679eefb55b354f610d6.jpg
Again, BS. If you're tooling around in an aircraft with a functioning radio and not using it you're either incompetent, an idiot, or both. And if you don't have a functioning radio you still ought to be slapped for deciding to just drop it in downwind after apparently dicking around not doing any sort of recognizable pattern off the departure end of the favored runway.
 
Again, BS. If you're tooling around in an aircraft with a functioning radio and not using it you're either incompetent, an idiot, or both. And if you don't have a functioning radio you still ought to be slapped for deciding to just drop it in downwind after apparently dicking around not doing any sort of recognizable pattern off the departure end of the favored runway.

5e8.jpg
 
Back
Top