NWA lays off 600

banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
banghead.gif
 
Well, the general public wants their tickets cheap at all costs...

Even at the cost of in-house maintenance.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Even at the cost of in-house maintenance.

[/ QUOTE ]

This has been in the news a great bit lately here in Minneapolis. The state government is concerned about the stability of NWA. The outside maintenance has been highlighted with the recent suspension of union leader, due to commetns he made in the media. Along with the recent part falling of the DC-10.

Steenland, NWA CEO, came and stated that the plane was maintenanced most recently by NWA mechanics here in MSP. He was speaking to the state gov't in the last couple of days over a number of concerns they had. This is all coming at a time when NWA wants to move ALL non-NWA affiliated airlines to the Humprhey Terminal (current charter terminal) here in MSP. NWA wants the main terminal to be for their exclusive use and expansion. And of course they want money from the state to help with the expansion.

As for the outside maintenance, do other major carriers use these vendors as well? That is one point that the CEO repeated a number of times recently.
 
Man, that's way above my pay grade. Any mechanics around today?
 
rolleyes.gif
Not good news! I fly NWA every time I fly My hometown Detroit is a hub for them. First off I don't really care if I get the cheapest flight I usually just go to nwa.com pick the day I want to fly and book it. But I do know there are cheaper carriers out there, SWA and America West but they both have connections. But I don't mind paying a bit more to NWA, getting a direct flight and staying with a long time friend of Detroit!

On the other hand this outsourcing is concerning me because this is potential saftey. The thrust reverser that fell off what if that had fallen on someones home and injured or worse killed someone. This would be a much bigger story. Sure its probably unrelated yet the public won't see it that way. Maybe I am just partial to NWA but I think that at somepoint you have to say certain things can't be cut. Fares need to rise. We pay more for gasoline everyday, it will be $3 a gallon here soon in SoCal. Poeple complain but you just pay it. I know several people who now fly to Vegas rather than drive because of the gas, thats only 250 miles. Rising costs due to energy is something we can't fight so jut hit us with it!
mad.gif
 
One consideration that might be in play here. NWA made a decision a decade or so ago to fly airplanes 30 years and more. This also meant a committment to more maintenance expense and wrenches on the ground than most airlines. DC-10s and -9s are hard to keep flying. All will require expensive mods to their insulation in the future. Any decision to park many of these airplanes will mean less mechanics required. That doesn't mean they aren't outsourcing too. But the peak requirement for maintenance at NWA may be past.

As to parts falling off of airplanes. It happens all the time. Not a good thing, not a bad thing, just a thing. You talking thrust reversers? Since I've been in the industry I can think of a number of times whole engines have fallen off. And it wasn't outsourced maintenance.

And no I'm not talking about American at ORD. Don't want to open that hornet's nest. I'm thinking of times where on post-flight inspection the guys are scratching their head and saying: "Didn't there used to be an engine here?"
 
[ QUOTE ]

On the other hand this outsourcing is concerning me because this is potential saftey. The thrust reverser that fell off what if that had fallen on someones home and injured or worse killed someone. This would be a much bigger story. Sure its probably unrelated yet the public won't see it that way. Maybe I am just partial to NWA but I think that at somepoint you have to say certain things can't be cut. Fares need to rise. We pay more for gasoline everyday, it will be $3 a gallon here soon in SoCal. Poeple complain but you just pay it. I know several people who now fly to Vegas rather than drive because of the gas, thats only 250 miles. Rising costs due to energy is something we can't fight so jut hit us with it!
mad.gif


[/ QUOTE ]


I'm reminded of the Alaska Airlines tragedy that occured over the pacific. Any kinda maintence whether in house or out sourced that cuts corners to keep cost down is both unsafe and just wrong!

-Matthew
 
[ QUOTE ]
On the other hand this outsourcing is concerning me because this is potential saftey.

[/ QUOTE ]

Don't worry. This isn't a safety issue. It's a union/outsourcing issue.

All third party shops in the US are monitored closely by the FAA and more importantly the airline that owns the aircraft. If they aren't happy with the work we do, then they will take their planes somewhere else. Work done at these shops is just as good as anything done by the airlines in house facility.

NWA is planning to outsource all of their heavy maintence. When they are done, they will only have line stations. All heavy checks and overhauls will be done at outside vendors. Obviously the mechanics union is upset and they are trying to stop this.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
On the other hand this outsourcing is concerning me because this is potential saftey.

[/ QUOTE ]

Don't worry. This isn't a safety issue. It's a union/outsourcing issue.

All third party shops in the US are monitored closely by the FAA and more importantly the airline that owns the aircraft. If they aren't happy with the work we do, then they will take their planes somewhere else. Work done at these shops is just as good as anything done by the airlines in house facility.

NWA is planning to outsource all of their heavy maintence. When they are done, they will only have line stations. All heavy checks and overhauls will be done at outside vendors. Obviously the mechanics union is upset and they are trying to stop this.

[/ QUOTE ]

America West layed off 500 mechs the week before Christmas 1995 (Merry Christmas, huh?). They wanted to save money by outsourcing heavy maintenance to a company called TRAMCO in Seattle, in order to save money. Planes were coming back from TRAMCO to PHX with more problems than when they left, costing AmWest more money just to fix those. AmWest about a year later asked the mechs to come back, and some did, but I believe most said to piss off. IMO, big problem with outsourced maintenance is you really don't know what you're getting, and the oversight may or may not be good. I know the FAA Mx inspector is supposed to be doing his job, but who knows for sure.
 
[ QUOTE ]
Well, the general public wants their tickets cheap at all costs...

Even at the cost of in-house maintenance.

[/ QUOTE ] Im not trying to be a dickhead and just start an angument but...Arent we a capitalist socioty? I mean, if I can get a ticket for $200 vs. $400 to get to the same place, ill take the $200 ticket. You get me here...? I mean ill just take the lowest price, whether its pizza or an airline ticket. Im American...
 
I'm willing to pay more for an airline ticket to support the pilots and other employees. This low-cost thing is killing the airline industry.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I mean ill just take the lowest price, whether its pizza or an airline ticket. Im American...

[/ QUOTE ]

If American is all about getting indigestion from a rancid pizza and having your thrust reverser fall off in flight later that evening, "Je suis Quebecois!"
 
[ QUOTE ]
big problem with outsourced maintenance is you really don't know what you're getting,

[/ QUOTE ]

Same could be said with in-house mx. Not pointing fingers on this, just playing devil's advocate. What if that thrust reverser had a couple of loose bolts? I mean it's no secret that NWA was looking at outsourcing, and that's why the layoff doesn't come as a surprise to me. What if the union decided a demonstrational "job action" was in order? I agree that it's not professional, and it's not legal. But desperate people will do a lot to save their jobs. Once again, not saying this is what happened, just food for thought.
 
[ QUOTE ]
I know the FAA Mx inspector is supposed to be doing his job, but who knows for sure.

[/ QUOTE ]

Actually it's not up to the FAA to insure quality. Carriers who use outside contractors put their own maintenance inspectors on the ground there. If it's a big operation there's usually more than one assigned so they can cover all the shifts. Using an outside vendor for maintenance doesn't relieve the carrier of any responsibility so they have to put their people there. Plus as you point out, work done incorrectly costs more than it saves.
 
[ QUOTE ]
[ QUOTE ]
I mean ill just take the lowest price, whether its pizza or an airline ticket. Im American...

[/ QUOTE ]

If American is all about getting indigestion from a rancid pizza and having your thrust reverser fall off in flight later that evening, "Je suis Quebecois!"

[/ QUOTE ]

I understand and im just playing devils advocate, but i think its just economics. Someone figured out how to operate an airline better, or to me it seems that way. And Southwest at least to my knowladge is not outsourcing their maintenence...
 
Southwest also only operates one fleet type, has their mx more spread out (less time off-line = more money made) and has its fair share of union woes with the mx dept. NWA operates several fleet types, has a more or less centralized mx program and also has union headaches. With the example of union headaches that are not really unique to any airline, it's apples to oranges. NWA's come too far to suddently re-structure to the SWA way, so they have to find ways to cut back elsewhere. One of the big arguements against deregulation was mx cutbacks to save on money. So far, with the exception of some notable accidents, it hasn't been that large of an issue.
 
Back
Top