North Korea

He'll do whatever it takes to make noise. I think it's a combination of boredom and lack of good judgement. No one wants to fight on the other's turf. It would be a disaster for whoever rushes who. He knows it. We know it. That's why it's been this way for over 50 years.
 
It would be a huge mess for sure if an all out war starts. Short or not. I hope he is bluffing and just wants help for his starving nation. I doubt he actually cares for his people in the purest sense, but more so for his own sake and future.
 
You nailed it on the head there. Clearly he wasn't raised with the most basic values, the biggest one being the willingness to share. Unfortunately, because of him, nobody can help his people. Some of them don't even know they need help.
 
Does anyone actually believe N. Korea will blow off the UN and do a second test? Or start a short war?

Whatever it takes to stay in the limelight.

Without the hubris going on now, N. Korea is just another failing communist country with starving people and a leader hellbent on retaining power by blaming other nations for their plight.
 
Whatever it takes to stay in the limelight.

Without the hubris going on now, N. Korea is just another failing communist country with starving people and a leader hellbent on retaining power by blaming other nations for their plight.

I agree every bit.
 
There is no way N Korea would start a war, in this case they are just playing the UN for a bluff. The ultimate factor driving NK's decision making is regime survival, if they start a war they know for sure their regime would be bottom ended. However, if they were faced with a preemptive attack from a foreign invader, that's another story.

Kim Jung Ill is not crazy or irational, nor would he do anything stupid to provoke an invasion or regime removal. They have been playing the US very well for decades, particularly during the COld War era and the nuclear proliferations talks of the mid 1990s.

For the US, the cost of invading NK would be too high. Carrying out a war on China's doorstep, would result in a major confrontation between the two superpowers. Furthermore, a war could see NK carry out a nuclear strike against Japan and South Korea. For China, Nk is just a pain in the arse that they have to put up with. If the NK regime was overthrown, it would result in an influx of N Korean refugees into Chinese borders and would see a US military presense on her border, which would cause all sorts of problems, so NK regime survival is in China's best interest.

Given the above factors, NK has quite a bit of space for complacency, but they know that their relationship with China is of vital importance. Without China's support, Kim Jun Ill would have been out on his arse ages ago.

The bottom line is, NK has the bomb, and we're just gonna have to live with it. They may kick some • every now and again, but I can't see them ever using the bomb in a preemptive nature. The main issue with their nuclear acquisition, is nuclear prolifiration in the East Asian region, but that's for another day.

Cheers

Tristan
 
There is no way N Korea would start a war, in this case they are just playing the UN for a bluff. The ultimate factor driving NK's decision making is regime survival, if they start a war they know for sure their regime would be bottom ended. However, if they were faced with a preemptive attack from a foreign invader, that's another story.

Kim Jung Ill is not crazy or irational, nor would he do anything stupid to provoke an invasion or regime removal. They have been playing the US very well for decades, particularly during the COld War era and the nuclear proliferations talks of the mid 1990s.

For the US, the cost of invading NK would be too high. Carrying out a war on China's doorstep, would result in a major confrontation between the two superpowers. Furthermore, a war could see NK carry out a nuclear strike against Japan and South Korea. For China, Nk is just a pain in the arse that they have to put up with. If the NK regime was overthrown, it would result in an influx of N Korean refugees into Chinese borders and would see a US military presense on her border, which would cause all sorts of problems, so NK regime survival is in China's best interest.

Given the above factors, NK has quite a bit of space for complacency, but they know that their relationship with China is of vital importance. Without China's support, Kim Jun Ill would have been out on his arse ages ago.

The bottom line is, NK has the bomb, and we're just gonna have to live with it. They may kick some • every now and again, but I can't see them ever using the bomb in a preemptive nature. The main issue with their nuclear acquisition, is nuclear prolifiration in the East Asian region, but that's for another day.

Cheers

Tristan

I see what you mean. I am sure the NK is just bluffing for attention, as one may say. The nuke was only a tenth size of that dropped on Hiroshima (sp?). I just think NK wanted to see if they could actually use the nuke themselves... a moral boost maybe?

I think it was funny how you said "US troops" would be on China's border. That brings me to my next comment... No matter who is in the UN, the US thinks it is the daddy... Our opinions most always influence the UN's decision. This should be a UN issue if anything. Not a US issue. We do trade a lot with China and would loose a lot of money if we didn't help them when they needed us, but why shouldn't everyone in the UN pitch in some men? We do not have enough active troops to do that... there are men who are serving two tours because we need a presence there. Any comments?
 
You mean pitch in some men for regime removal or...? Now that you've mentioned the UN, it makes me think about TEam AMerica the movie. I love it when the UN guy tells Kim JI to "stop it or else". Kim replies: "or else what?" "Or else we'll get really really angry, then we'll send you a letter telling you how angry we are". As hilarious as this was, it's actually the reality of the situation.

Tristan
 
I see what you mean. I am sure the NK is just bluffing for attention, as one may say. The nuke was only a tenth size of that dropped on Hiroshima (sp?). I just think NK wanted to see if they could actually use the nuke themselves... a moral boost maybe?

I think it was funny how you said "US troops" would be on China's border. That brings me to my next comment... No matter who is in the UN, the US thinks it is the daddy... Our opinions most always influence the UN's decision. This should be a UN issue if anything. Not a US issue. We do trade a lot with China and would loose a lot of money if we didn't help them when they needed us, but why shouldn't everyone in the UN pitch in some men? We do not have enough active troops to do that... there are men who are serving two tours because we need a presence there. Any comments?

It used to be a big US issue back during the good 'ole days when we knew who our enemies were. If anyone wanted to pick a fight with communists, we were involved someway, somehow. But nowadays, with the remaining communist regimes barely reflecting the original idea, it's almost like yesterday's news. There's a difference between saying something and doing something. Clearly we still make a stand there in Korea. IMO, the UN and other countries are only supporting with talk and trade agreements because they don't think a military presence is necessary. I doubt the US will request additional coalition troops anyway. Besides, we don't want to give Kim Jong a reason to start making statements via troop movement. A military build-up at the DMZ would be an irressistible oppurtunity for him. He wouldn't balk at matching it.
 
I've got a feeling he is going to start a war. . . but with who, and for what?

Us taking care of North Korea. . . like men . . . will last only a few weeks. I vision a rather extensive bombing campaign. No ground troops into the north, no need. What would be really nice is if Japan's air force does some of the bombing, that way our hands are not the only one's with blood on them.
 
No troops, no way. That would be a very difficult endeaver. I'm not saying it's not doable, it's just not the greatest time to switch gears. That's a completely different environment than Iraq. A well organized army they might have, hmmm?

Air campaign would be more logical, but I still don't think it's necessary. If any, a long-term pyschological campaign would be better for everyone. Those people up there are very sheltered and could use some new ideas about the kind of life they could have if they could make more of their own choices.
 
You mean pitch in some men for regime removal or...? Now that you've mentioned the UN, it makes me think about TEam AMerica the movie. I love it when the UN guy tells Kim JI to "stop it or else". Kim replies: "or else what?" "Or else we'll get really really angry, then we'll send you a letter telling you how angry we are". As hilarious as this was, it's actually the reality of the situation.

Tristan

Lol. If that movie ever got to North Korea I'm pretty sure they must have banned it.

I wonder if he watched it?
 
I think it was funny how you said "US troops" would be on China's border. That brings me to my next comment... No matter who is in the UN, the US thinks it is the daddy... Our opinions most always influence the UN's decision. This should be a UN issue if anything. Not a US issue.

Because we're the ones putting in the most money into that worthless, paper tiger of an organization. What a waste of cash

We do trade a lot with China and would loose a lot of money if we didn't help them when they needed us, but why shouldn't everyone in the UN pitch in some men? We do not have enough active troops to do that... there are men who are serving two tours because we need a presence there. Any comments?

Because the troops dispatched to UN duty are poorly trained, poorly led, and from countries too poor or able to provide the above. Factor that in with the UN rules of engagement limit the participating troops from doing anything at all, and you have your answer. UN won't allow peace enforcement ops, only peace keeping
 
What would be really nice is if Japan's air force does some of the bombing, that way our hands are not the only one's with blood on them.

There's some suggestion that if Japan were involved the citizens of RoK would revolt and many would side with the North ...... just what we all need, another civil war! A lot of Koreans still hate Japan.

As Mike suggested in his post, the UN's operations are often 'fleshed out' by developing nations' soldiers - it makes those countries a lot of money. UN ops are a significant revenue stream for Fiji, for example.
 
There is more of a danger in NK selling those weapons to terrorists. That is the short-term threat for the time being. The only things keeping the regime from toppling is the black market economy within and China. The UN nor can any country from the six party can negotiate with real faith. It's actually very offensive to talk about diplomacy. It flies in the face of the Korean War vets. After all this is a rogue nation that still run dozens of concentration camps and gulags. The 98 summit between SK and NK is a petty farce.
 
There is more of a danger in NK selling those weapons to terrorists. That is the short-term threat for the time being. The only things keeping the regime from toppling is the black market economy within and China. The UN nor can any country from the six party can negotiate with real faith. It's actually very offensive to talk about diplomacy. It flies in the face of the Korean War vets. After all this is a rogue nation that still run dozens of concentration camps and gulags. The 98 summit between SK and NK is a petty farce.


Best thing the US can do at the six party talks is to tell the asian nations that this is their problem, they handle it; then walk out.
 
Best thing the US can do at the six party talks is to tell the asian nations that this is their problem, they handle it; then walk out.

They would TOTALLY listen, too! Could you see the look on their faces if we just said F IT! and rolled outa there...Kim Jong wouldn't know what to make of us.
 
They would TOTALLY listen, too! Could you see the look on their faces if we just said F IT! and rolled outa there...Kim Jong wouldn't know what to make of us.

Yup. . .but you know that wont happen. :(

As much as we wish it too. . . maybe we can will it to happen?
 
Back
Top