Need a Clearance?

Maurus

The Great Gazoo
I have flown into several airports where taxiways are placed at the approach end of a runway that are not actually part of the runway. An example is Taxiway Z in SFO (Diagram). The taxiway goes right past the departure end of runway 28L and 28R. There are hold short (not ILS) lines painted on Z for the runways. Say ATC gives the following clearance starting at the GA ramp.

"Taxi Runway 1L via C, Z, B"

Does ATC need to include a crossing clearance at Z if runway 28 is only being used for arrivals?
 
They are hold short signs for the approach to the runway?

We just discussed this in another topic, but IIRC no definite answer was found.
 
I have flown into several airports where taxiways are placed at the approach end of a runway that are not actually part of the runway. An example is Taxiway Z in SFO (Diagram). The taxiway goes right past the departure end of runway 28L and 28R. There are hold short (not ILS) lines painted on Z for the runways. Say ATC gives the following clearance starting at the GA ramp.

"Taxi Runway 1L via C, Z, B"

Does ATC need to include a crossing clearance at Z if runway 28 is only being used for arrivals?

Let me preface my reply with the fact that I have never worked at a tower with this type of taxiway configuration and its associated markings, plus I have not worked in a tower in more than twelve years. However I have had many opportunities to look stuff up in "the book" and say what I think it means. That's what you're getting here.

The 7110.65 says this:

(3-7-2)
b.
When authorizing an aircraft to taxi to an assigned takeoff runway and hold short instructions are not issued, specify the runway preceded by “taxi to,” and issue taxi instructions. This authorizes the aircraft to “cross” all runways/taxiways which the taxi route intersects except the assigned takeoff runway. This does not authorize the aircraft to “enter” or “cross” the assigned takeoff runway at any point.
PHRASEOLOGY-
TAXI TO RUNWAY (number) VIA (route).
EXAMPLE-
“Taxi to Runway Three Six via Taxiway Echo.” or “Taxi to Runway Three Six via Echo.”
c. Specify the runway for departure, taxi instruc tions, and hold short restrictions when an aircraft will be required to hold short of a runway or other points along the taxi route.
EXAMPLE-
“Runway Three Six Left, taxi via taxiway Alpha, hold short of taxiway Charlie.”
or
“Runway Three Six Left, taxi via Alpha, hold short of Charlie.”

Although this doesn't specifically mention runway approach areas, my opinion is that regardless of the type of operation on 28R (or 10L for that matter), if there is no need to hold an aircraft short of the 10L APCH area, ATC does NOT need to include a crossing clearance at Z. With the absence of specific hold short instructions, the clearance to cross at Z is implied.

With that said, I also recommend that anytime you are taxiing along and you have any doubt whatsoever about crossing at any particular point, ask for verification. Don't worry if you are greeted with a less than cheerful response from the controller. In my 25+ years of ATC, I managed to piss off a LOT of controllers... they all healed.

Also, I am a big proponent of calling the facility and asking questions like this. Every FAA facility I know of is chock-full of managers and staff people whose job it is to provide answers to this type of question.
 
Let me preface my reply with the fact that I have never worked at a tower with this type of taxiway configuration and its associated markings, plus I have not worked in a tower in more than twelve years. However I have had many opportunities to look stuff up in "the book" and say what I think it means. That's what you're getting here.

The 7110.65 says this:



Although this doesn't specifically mention runway approach areas, my opinion is that regardless of the type of operation on 28R (or 10L for that matter), if there is no need to hold an aircraft short of the 10L APCH area, ATC does NOT need to include a crossing clearance at Z. With the absence of specific hold short instructions, the clearance to cross at Z is implied.

With that said, I also recommend that anytime you are taxiing along and you have any doubt whatsoever about crossing at any particular point, ask for verification. Don't worry if you are greeted with a less than cheerful response from the controller. In my 25+ years of ATC, I managed to piss off a LOT of controllers... they all healed.

Also, I am a big proponent of calling the facility and asking questions like this. Every FAA facility I know of is chock-full of managers and staff people whose job it is to provide answers to this type of question.
The above reference is the old rule. The taxi rules changed about a year ago and now a pilot can no longer receive a "taxi to..." instruction plus all runway crossings must be obtained one at a time (i.e. You must clear one runway before receiving the clearance to cross the next runway).
 
From the AIM:
8. If a pilot is expected to hold short of a runway approach ("APPCH") area or ILS holding position (see FIG 2-3-15, Taxiways Located in Runway Approach Area), ATC will issue instructions.







 
From the AIM:
8. If a pilot is expected to hold short of a runway approach ("APPCH") area or ILS holding position (see FIG 2-3-15, Taxiways Located in Runway Approach Area), ATC will issue instructions.

That's good stuff. I wish our manual spelled it out that clearly. The only solid, black-and-white explanation in the .65 refers to crossing the runways themselves. No mention of the APPCH areas.

I think a call to a facility with this signage is in order. I'd bet ATC expects pilots to hold short, but won't be able to back that up with regs/orders if challenged on it. Maybe an ATSAP/ASAP item that could bring about change in the rules.



 
There is another airport around the way that will almost always specify this clearance, even at ridiculous hours of the morning.
 
Last I checked, we have similar hold lines at Stockton, there just is not a way around the runway, but the ILS hold lines are for when the ILS critical area needs to be protected (low vis/ceilings), but it is always better to ask then to just cross them and break a rule.
 
Back
Top