My First Inflight Emergency!!

jrh said:
I decided to divert to Boise because they had the best crash vehicles in the area and explained the situation to the controller--how I wasn't sure what was happening with the gear, and that I'd like the trucks by the runway, but I did not need to declare an emergency and I did not need priority over other aircraft.

Hmmmm - so you abdicated your PIC duties and just had the tower declare an emergency for you?

If they rolled the trucks an emergency was declared, maybe you didn't declare it, but it was declared on your behalf.
 
Hey Lima Charlie, lemme guess, you were in a Duchess weren't you? That exact same thing happened when I was training for my MEL rating. Brought the prop lever forward, but the accumulator did not bring to prop around enough or something like that. Pretty sure I screwed up the checklist, got things out of order, and the prop was stuck. :)

Anyway, the engine wasn't going to start, and my instructor took over. It was an interesting situation, but I didn't think too much of it, until my instructor declared an emergency. He told me it was nothing more than a precaution, but I did notice that we were slightly above the S.E. service ceiling and descending (only 200 fpm or so, but definitely descending). This was down in Prescott, AZ, where the airport is at 5042', so we did not have much room to play with.

It ended up being non-eventful, but I learned a valuable lesson.......use the checklist, and don't be too reluctant too declare an emergency.

Good work BTW!

-ColM
 
CFIse said:
Hmmmm - so you abdicated your PIC duties and just had the tower declare an emergency for you?

If they rolled the trucks an emergency was declared, maybe you didn't declare it, but it was declared on your behalf.

I didn't abdicate anything. I looked at all the resources available, then communicated to the controller what I needed and what I didn't. If the controller needed to declare an emergency for paperwork reasons, maybe they declared one, but they never said anything to me about it.

All I'm trying to caution against is going from one extreme of "never declare an emergency" to "declare an emergency over any little thing." I just want people to think before they act. Don't be afraid to declare an emergency if you need to, but don't expect it to be a magical solution either.
 
jrh said:
I'll play devil's advocate for a minute...

I think there are a few circumstances when it would be better not to declare an emergency.

The biggest question I ask myself is, how would declaring an emergency help me?

There are times when declaring an emergency won't mean diddly, and it could mess up other flights. There's no point in declaring an emergency if it's not going to help you.

<snip>

I decided to divert to Boise because they had the best crash vehicles in the area and explained the situation to the controller--how I wasn't sure what was happening with the gear, and that I'd like the trucks by the runway, but I did not need to declare an emergency and I did not need priority over other aircraft.
<snip>
Just something to think about. Don't be afraid to declare an emergency, but make sure there's a reason for it. (BTW, I consider the case of an engine failure in a twin to be an emergency. Good job!)
I'm not following how you can say there was no need to declare an emergency, yet you wanted the trucks by the runway?

:confused:
 
SteveC said:
I'm not following how you can say there was no need to declare an emergency, yet you wanted the trucks by the runway?

:confused:

When I declare an emergency, I want the focus to be 100% on ME. I want the controller's complete attention, I want to be first in line to land, I don't care about other traffic. I don't ask for permission for anything, I just do it and let the controller know what I'm doing. The world revolves around me if I'm declaring an emergency.

In the situation with the gear trouble, I wanted trucks by the runway in case the gear were to collapse and a fire start or a passenger get hurt (I had a full plane for this flight). However, there was no reason to hassle other aircraft or the controller. I didn't want the controller to start sending airliners into a holding pattern or something just because I was having a bit of gear trouble.
 
The controllers don't automatically make you first for the runway and move everyone out of the way just because you declare an emergency. They don't necessarily call out the trucks. They don't necessarily do anything, other than stand up a little straighter, and maybe call that extra guy back off from break. They do what you need them to do to help handle the emergency.

Which is exactly the way things should have happened in your gear scenario. If you had called them and told them that you had a gear problem and were declaring an emergency, they will ask you what you want to do and what you need. They don't start clearing everyone out of your way unless you need them to, either by your asking or because they know that (for example) an engine fire means you need to be on the ground NOW. With a gear problem they understand that you might very well need to spend some time trouble-shooting the problem, or want to make a low pass (or something stupid like that), or just might want to come in and land. They will be working with you, not willy-nilly making a big scene just because you said the dreaded "E" word. By declaring an emergency all that you have done is told the controller "Heads up, I've got a problem and may need some help".

If a situation is questionable enough to have the trucks standing by, it is worth declaring an emergency.
 
Engines not unfeathering is actually somewhat common. It's never happened to me but I know a handfull of people that have had it happen. Just a suggestion, but for lesson planning purposes if you are going to do a full engine failure, it is best to do it toward the end of the flight. Just in case the engine does not start back up at least you got most of the lesson if not all of it done before you have to land.
 
KBUF said:
I had the same exact thing happen on my commercial multi checkride...finally broke my won'thappentomeness! the examiner let me fly it back in and taxi it to the mx hanger. It was still stuck in the feather position, so he goes and grabs a big piece of wood with a slot cut in it, slaps it on the prop and tells me to push up on my side of the board while he pushed down on his. I thought the checkride was over, but we got back in started it up and finished the ride...we just cut the other engine for the rest of the single engine stuff and it worked fine.

Good decision to declare an emergency btw...and a good learning experience for your student!
<bold added>

I've been kind of waiting for someone else to comment on this......something about unairworthy, non-operating essential equipment....blah, blah, blah....examiner breaking FAR's....blah, blah, blah....

Anyone? Beuhler?

:pirate:
 
Steve, I did notice that as well...

Personally, when I am just tired or lazy and there are a bunch of them (student pilots) in the pattern, I just start yelling EMERGENCY on all freqs till I have airpsace all over to myself. Than I can go where I want when I want and land without anyone being in my way. Works everytime. Try it.

Seriously though, I think that this thread has talked about some information that can only help in the future. Remember ATC is your biotch. They work for you, but in return they can make things not so much fun.
 
RynoB said:
Yes, they know dirty four letter words like hold.

RynoB... thats exactly what I was thinking. I'm surprised that the forum doesn't change it to ##### or something. It actually allows you to spell it out. WOW. I at least thought the filter would pick it up.
 
in words of jack ingram....

Theres only one four little word that will dooooo


love you

lovfe this town

love this mother lovin truck that keeps brekain lovin down

you get the idea.
 
Frog can you please take that "Dr. Pepper sucks" out of your signature. Its fighting words that I dont like.
 
ColMustard said:
Hey Lima Charlie, lemme guess, you were in a Duchess weren't you? That exact same thing happened when I was training for my MEL rating. Brought the prop lever forward, but the accumulator did not bring to prop around enough or something like that. Pretty sure I screwed up the checklist, got things out of order, and the prop was stuck. :)

Anyway, the engine wasn't going to start, and my instructor took over. It was an interesting situation, but I didn't think too much of it, until my instructor declared an emergency. He told me it was nothing more than a precaution, but I did notice that we were slightly above the S.E. service ceiling and descending (only 200 fpm or so, but definitely descending). This was down in Prescott, AZ, where the airport is at 5042', so we did not have much room to play with.

It ended up being non-eventful, but I learned a valuable lesson.......use the checklist, and don't be too reluctant too declare an emergency.

Good work BTW!

-ColM

Nope, it was in a Seminole. And it landed just like it does when one engine is at "Zero thrust". It was very stable, and as I mentioned, an uneventful landing.
 
SteveC said:
The controllers don't automatically make you first for the runway and move everyone out of the way just because you declare an emergency. They don't necessarily call out the trucks. They don't necessarily do anything, other than stand up a little straighter, and maybe call that extra guy back off from break. They do what you need them to do to help handle the emergency.

Which is exactly the way things should have happened in your gear scenario. If you had called them and told them that you had a gear problem and were declaring an emergency, they will ask you what you want to do and what you need. They don't start clearing everyone out of your way unless you need them to, either by your asking or because they know that (for example) an engine fire means you need to be on the ground NOW. With a gear problem they understand that you might very well need to spend some time trouble-shooting the problem, or want to make a low pass (or something stupid like that), or just might want to come in and land. They will be working with you, not willy-nilly making a big scene just because you said the dreaded "E" word. By declaring an emergency all that you have done is told the controller "Heads up, I've got a problem and may need some help".

If a situation is questionable enough to have the trucks standing by, it is worth declaring an emergency.

I guess I always thought differently of how the term "emergency" should be used. I've always reserved it for urgent situations or when priority handling is needed.

I did exactly what you're saying I should have done, except for using the word "emergency." I took charge of the situation. I told the controller what was happening and what I needed. I got the help I wanted. Everything went smoothly. If I had thought I needed something I wasn't getting, I wouldn't have hesitated to declare an emergency.

I don't see what the big deal is.

Maybe my original issue was just semantics...I was cautioning people not to make a mountain out of a mole hill. For me, if I'm using the word "emergency," I'm saying I have a mountain to deal with. If I'm dealing with a mole hill, I simply request assistance. Now I see that not everyone interprets things the same way I have.

To conclude, I'd say the broader issue here is to make sure you stay in control of a situation. Whether you use the "e-word" or not is irrelevant. Do whatever it takes to stay safe. Don't just sit there and not utilize resources that could be helping you.
 
Hmm...another piece of information I just found....

The AIM doesn't say anything about the phraseology used to declare an emergency. I think the magical "e-word" is more a part of pilot culture than it is any sort of standardized system. The AIM simply says "Pilots who become apprehensive for their safety for any reason should request assistance immediately."

See AIM 6-1-2, page 757 in the 2006 version of ASA's AIM.

SteveC: I'm not saying either of us is right or wrong. Just throwing out some more information.
 
I'd say we're pretty much on the same page.

Thanks for checking the AIM. In the back of my mind I was wondering about the FAA's guidance on the subject, but I'm on the road and didn't feel like digging on-line. I'd wager a guess that the Controller's handbook (whatever it's called) might have some good information on the topic.

:pirate:
 
Lima_Charlie said:
Nope, it was in a Seminole. And it landed just like it does when one engine is at "Zero thrust". It was very stable, and as I mentioned, an uneventful landing.

The Seminole has an accumulator?

-ColM
 
Whether an emergency was declared or not doesn't really matter. What's important is that all the emergencies situations described in this thread had a positive outcome.
Congratulations to all of you for being able to handle the situation appropriately. Keep up the good work!!!!!!!!! :nana2:
 
Back
Top