Military vs. Regional Airline route

That's becaus it isn't difficult flying, it's bland, straight and level stuff. Any pilot should be able to hack that.

I'll let you in on a little secret. Airline flying has very little to do with actual stick and rudder skills. Airline flying is all about descision making. That is something that can't be directly trained but, comes from a culmination of everything in a pilots background.
 
Do you remember taking that True/False test at the DAL interview?

I thought anyone could figure out the right answers to most of those questions, but later that night four of us were at Malone's going over the interview, the tests, etc. and one guy, a Navy F14 driver says, "That was the dumbest test I've ever seen! I can't believe some of those questions! 'I get annoyed when interupted wile doing an importan task.' Who Would put False to that??!!"

I looked at him and said, "Did you put True for that?"

He said, "Of COURSE, who wouldn't be annoyed?"

I said, "You realize that IS an Engineer's job description, right?"

Well, he wasn't in our new hire class...

Airline flying is not about stick and rudder skills at all, they assume you can fly an airplane when you show up. It's a "Management Job"; Crew management, time management, fuel management, sleep management, pax management, etc. and it's about staying off CNN.

Having 2,000 hrs. as a Sht Hot Fighter Pilot in a single seater has not prepared you for Airline flying. In fact, if you are used to getting things done your way, all the time, you will be sadly disapointed at any Airline.
 
Having 2,000 hrs. as a Sht Hot Fighter Pilot in a single seater has not prepared you for Airline flying. In fact, if you are used to getting things done your way, all the time, you will be sadly disapointed at any Airline.

Thats an unfair broadbrush. While it may be true in some cases, it's not all around. I can fly crew just as easily as I can fly single seat, and I came from a pure single seat background. My biggest problem with flying airline would be the abject boredom from the job; but thats just me. Using the same broadbrush you did, I could say that any crew-centric pilot wouldn't be able to fly a single-pilot plane or know what to do, since he wouldn't have his committee available to run decisions through.
 
Do you remember taking that True/False test at the DAL interview?

I thought anyone could figure out the right answers to most of those questions, but later that night four of us were at Malone's going over the interview, the tests, etc. and one guy, a Navy F14 driver says, "That was the dumbest test I've ever seen! I can't believe some of those questions! 'I get annoyed when interupted wile doing an importan task.' Who Would put False to that??!!"

I looked at him and said, "Did you put True for that?"

He said, "Of COURSE, who wouldn't be annoyed?"

I said, "You realize that IS an Engineer's job description, right?"

Well, he wasn't in our new hire class...

Airline flying is not about stick and rudder skills at all, they assume you can fly an airplane when you show up. It's a "Management Job"; Crew management, time management, fuel management, sleep management, pax management, etc. and it's about staying off CNN.

Having 2,000 hrs. as a Sht Hot Fighter Pilot in a single seater has not prepared you for Airline flying. In fact, if you are used to getting things done your way, all the time, you will be sadly disapointed at any Airline.

A lot of folks, me included, thought that those psyche tests were pointless - until I got to class and realized that no matter what our backgrounds were we were all the same. Delta was looking to hire a person, not a pilot.

Airline pilots prove everyday that where they originally came from just does not matter. Not to sound snobbish but, at least at the major/legacy level. The regional level is a different story however because overall experience is much lower for new-hires. I think that the best guys there originally came from 135 freight on average (and no, I never did that myself so, no bias there ;)).

Here's a weird question that I bet MikeD has some personal experience with. ON AVERAGE who does better during UPT, the guy who has no aviation experience whatsoever or, the guy who has already been flying in the civilian world? And no, I'm not baiting just really curious cause I could see a case for either answer.
 
Here's a weird question that I bet MikeD has some personal experience with. ON AVERAGE who does better during UPT, the guy who has no aviation experience whatsoever or, the guy who has already been flying in the civilian world? And no, I'm not baiting just really curious cause I could see a case for either answer.

You question is a very good one, as I went to UPT with about 4300 hrs and an ATP. For me, academics was easy, contact flying (VFR) was easy, Instruments was easy, fomation was new, as was low-level nav. The latter two were challenging. But what I had to face was two things: breaking civilian "bad habits" and learning to do it the military way; and insuring I never had the attitude of complacency, or that I "already know it". So, I kept the attitude of "I'm here as a student, here to learn their way; only I happen to have a knowledge head start." With that positive and humble attitude, I did my best to do my job and help my classmates out who needed it.......cooperate and graduate.

Guys in similar circumstances to me who washed out, did so because they failed to do the above, and it was the attitude that killed them, either academically or in the flying. The attitude also got them targeted with a "scarlet letter" that showed them as problem children.

Attitude played a great part with the guys with no prior flight time too. Their challenge was seeing something new for the first time, and having the proverbial sink or swim vis-a-vis the firehose effect of seeing flying for the first time. They had no bad habits to change, since they had no habits at all; however they always didnt know what to study when, and had to learn alot in a small amount of time. They usually washed out for lack of aptitude, lack of hands, or just not "getting it". However that said, IF they had a good attitude, IPs would bend over backwards to try and help them.

So two different kinds of challenges for different background people. It's hard to say who does better, since those with no prior time (post PPL, I mean) there are far more of them than people who have an ATP or have otherwise been flying career-wise before getting in. Each have their own common reasons for succeeding or failing.
 
Just as a sidenote--yes, military pilot training is tough. But, I do feel like (at least in my unit), the recurring evaluations we get are pretty low threat compared to a 121 PC. For one thing, chances are you know your evaluator VERY WELL, and they know how you perform on a day-to-day basis, and plus the training is a bit overkill so it's pretty hard to screw up on your checkride. In 121 flying, you hardly ever see the simulator, and when you do--you're getting an evaluation.

And yea, the recent time I went back to a "single seat" environment, it was a bit of a challenge :D
 
I'll let you in on a little secret. Airline flying has very little to do with actual stick and rudder skills. Airline flying is all about descision making. That is something that can't be directly trained but, comes from a culmination of everything in a pilots background.

I'll also let you in on a little secret, all flying is about decision making. From flying a Cessna to an airliner...just some planes have more stick and rudder than others. The training, background and experience obviously all play a part in that.
 
I'll also let you in on a little secret, all flying is about decision making. From flying a Cessna to an airliner...just some planes have more stick and rudder than others. The training, background and experience obviously all play a part in that.

+100. I'd say the challenge I have been faced with in military flying has been much more in this department than in stick and rudder skills. Making good decisions in very dynamic situations is something that most military pilots train to and do regularly. Does that make them better in the airline environment? I couldn't say because I would be speaking to something I have no idea about.

@ bunk, I'm sure you will be awesome in the -45. It is a handful at first, but from everything I have heard, so is the COD. You won't be thrown into crazy phase II events right off the bat, though I hope you have the opportunity to get ONAV/WEPS and maybe ACM qual'd. One of the best ACM instructors I flew with came from E-2 land.
 
Here's a weird question that I bet MikeD has some personal experience with. ON AVERAGE who does better during UPT, the guy who has no aviation experience whatsoever or, the guy who has already been flying in the civilian world? And no, I'm not baiting just really curious cause I could see a case for either answer.

I can actually answer this as I was a primary instructor pilot with VT-6 at my last command...the equivelant to AF UPT. Like I said before, the ability to fly has to do with the "IT" factor. You either have it or you don't. If you have it, extra flight time will only help; if you don't have it, nothing will help. The majority of pilots I flew with had no flight time other than IFS while I did fly with some folks who had up to 700 hours of civilian flight time. I will discount the few NFO to pilot's I flew with as their SA, decision making skills, etc were far and above any of the regular students I flew with. So of the top 5 students I flew, only 1 had prior flight time and he was an Italian student. That kid could fly like Yeager, he was that good. He had a couple hundred hours was my understanding. The other 4 had only IFS flight time (~30 hours). I flew with a kid who had around 700 hours and he was above average but not top notch. I flew with him in the PA (precision aerobatics) and RI (radio instrument) phases. He was average in PA's but above average in RI's. I also flew with an ERAU grad with ~ 500hrs who was well below average in RI's. I flew with him twice, had to unsat one of his flights.

Obviously not a big enough sample to draw a conclusion but in my experience, I think prior flight time for what we do is not required. The Navy will teach a pilot everything he or she needs to know. Maype 1000+ hours is required to do really hot, I don't know. A very good friend of mine is a Marine F/A-18A+ pilot. He is a former TOP GUN instructor and literally smoked the program in both primary and advanced. He had around 2000 civilian hours when he came in the program. He had all sorts of ratings, was an aerobatic pilot, etc. The thing that were new to him was CQ, ACM/BFM, air-to-ground. He had even flown form before. He had the it factor and was definitely more than prepared for military flight training. He graduated top in his class (Commodore's list with distinction) in both primary and advanced. Looks like Buzz Lightyear...stud...I must have a man crush lol :laff:
 
So of the top 5 students I flew, only 1 had prior flight time and he was an Italian student. That kid could fly like Yeager, he was that good.

Did he come to Meridian? Think I know him if it was in the last year or so.....really good dude, good stick from what I hear
 
Speaking of IPs, "Heat's Not's Gay" has been playing in my head while this thread has been unfolding.
 
+100. I'd say the challenge I have been faced with in military flying has been much more in this department than in stick and rudder skills. Making good decisions in very dynamic situations is something that most military pilots train to and do regularly. Does that make them better in the airline environment? I couldn't say because I would be speaking to something I have no idea about.

My good bud, Hot Rod, is a current Southwest FO and a former COD driver. He was an IP in T-2C's with VT-9 as well. He achieved 2000 hours rather quickly in the 737 and remarked how easy everything was compared to flying in the Navy. It might just be COD flying as that airplane was tough to fly and in 2000 hours in the 737, he had not one issue. In 2000 hours in the COD, he had multiple issues. Hell, I remember sitting on CAT I with him in tension, losing all hydraulics. At leas we were on the ground. Flying Case I in the overhead, zip lip, at the carrier....as you will find out, is crazy at times. In almost 2000 COD hours, I've had 4 sigle engines, hydraulic, electrical failures, lost oil, gear stuck, jammed rudder, runaway rudder trim, etc. Wait until night carrie landings...hardest thing I've done and I had a guy/gal sitting to the right. Doing it single seat must be insane. I was an LSO and my respect goes out to the single seat guys landing at night and in bad weather, it has to suck that much worse. You'll see, landing on the carrier in the middle of a thunder storm or in waters where you see the top of the screws come out of the water or in a snow storm...paddles has to rig MOVLAS. That's dynamic my friend.

@ bunk, I'm sure you will be awesome in the -45. It is a handful at first, but from everything I have heard, so is the COD. You won't be thrown into crazy phase II events right off the bat, though I hope you have the opportunity to get ONAV/WEPS and maybe ACM qual'd. One of the best ACM instructors I flew with came from E-2 land.

The COD is a handful no doubt, not a fun plane to fly at all. Hated flying that thing at the boat. I have just under 3 years at TW-2 and my goal is to get every qual I can, including ACM...tough one to get for us prop guys. Definitely ONAV/WEPS though.
 
Did he come to Meridian? Think I know him if it was in the last year or so.....really good dude, good stick from what I hear

He may have, not sure where he went. He was a tall, skinny Italian kid who had uncanny stick and rudder skills. There were two of them actually, both were outstanding students. There was a Marine student though, who just bested both of them. He had only IFS and could also fly the hell out the aircraft but with better SA and comms (given being a native speaker).
 
I'll let you in on a little secret. Airline flying has very little to do with actual stick and rudder skills. Airline flying is all about descision making. That is something that can't be directly trained but, comes from a culmination of everything in a pilots background.

And I'll let YOU in on a "little secret". The NUMBER ONE cause of fatal accidents for U.S. airlines is LOSS OF CONTROL.

Maybe the military is on to something? I have a civilian background, but was fortunate to be truly exposed to what the military does in their training due to my involvement in various safety initiatives over the years. With what I know now, the military pilot training is FAR better. In fact, most civilian training is pathetic, blind leading the blind, full of misconceptions and false ideas about aerodynamics, etc. It is truly incredible. Can a civilian pilot correct those things? Yes, if they, personally, make an effort to do so. Far too few do, so, all else being equal, the military background will net the stronger pilot due to the stronger foundation. The airlines just do not have the time and money to provide the training required to correct the issue. As it is, even most military pilots forget the stuff over the years. We all must continually strive to learn more and fly more precisely.
 
Thats an unfair broadbrush. While it may be true in some cases, it's not all around. I can fly crew just as easily as I can fly single seat, and I came from a pure single seat background. My biggest problem with flying airline would be the abject boredom from the job; but thats just me. Using the same broadbrush you did, I could say that any crew-centric pilot wouldn't be able to fly a single-pilot plane or know what to do, since he wouldn't have his committee available to run decisions through.

I've got friends who now fly with the airlines, who were either 18 or 14 drivers, who have no issues. Flying with a crew is not that hard...of course, that's my background. If a single seat guy is having issues, then I think it's more of an attitude adjustment than anything. I guess there will always be those guys who don't have the mentality to operate with a crew however.
 
Back
Top