Military vs. Regional Airline route

>>That is a valid discussion -- was that intended to be a story about a "good" IP (seems like it to me), or a "bad" IP?<<

I thought he was a great IP, even though he was a brand new IP, but I had lots of time already and was not trying to "learn to fly", just fine tune my skills to the Military way of doing things.

Not sure he would have worked real well with a brand new kid. But he had lots of 'real world' experiences to share, which made it all the more enjoyable to fly with him. He showed me stuff that was "not in the book", so to speak...great fun as long as nobody gets hurt.
 
Not sure he would have worked real well with a brand new kid. But he had lots of 'real world' experiences to share, which made it all the more enjoyable to fly with him. He showed me stuff that was "not in the book", so to speak...great fun as long as nobody gets hurt.

Pretty typical of O-4s and above who show up to SUPT direct from operational units.

They generally don't give a crap about much of the idiotic minutiae that permeates the SUPT environment -- they have a much larger picture about some things, and a much more focused picture about the things that matter in the real world.

This is part of the balance required in a SUPT squadron -- you've got FAIPs who are experts on the jet and know SUPT inside and out (but not much else), and graybeards who bring real world experience and perspective to the fight. Neither is the perfect IP, but they're both important perspectives to have.
 
Great article in Air Forces monthly about the Strike Eagle BTW Hacker; seems like a really cool jet!
 
That was basically my point. I've seen a lot of stupid things in both training enviroments. IMHO, the person makes the pilot, not the flight school dejour.

BTW, I've seen both civilian and military guys wash out of airline training. I've known a bunch of both and it just reinforces my belief that the point of origin of the initial experience doesn't matter much. It is all aptitude.

Describe washing out of airline training and who were these military pilots specifically? What were their backgrounds and the reason for failing? Military flight training is second to none...whether the person makes the pilot or not, the training by Uncle Sam is not equaled in the civilian world. I'm not just talking about the flying, there is the rank structure, the officer thing, the competition, etc. Can't buy your way in either, it's competitive to get in and stay in. What the military pilot does with his or her training is up to them. Like I've said, I've seen military pilots just blow my mind on how bad they are. I'm not talking stick and rudder skills specifically but things like headwork and SA that are just simply lacking. Two pilots come to mind and both are not flying anymore. They simply chose to become dumb pilots it seems as they could actually fly an airplane but made bad decisions, often by choice.
 
Describe washing out of airline training

That means failing training and either being fired or asked to leave the company.

and who were these military pilots specifically?
I am not going to list their names but, they come from all branches.

What were their backgrounds and the reason for failing?
I'll give a few examples.

There was a USAF F-16 guy in an earlier class than mine at my current airline that washed out during IOE. The exact reasons are only rumor but, I do know he was not easy to get along with and thought that he was better than everyone else when the inverse was true.

My training partner was also an F-16 guy. He struggled very hard throughout training. Stick and rudder was not a problem with him but, it was all of the automation that gave him a hard time. Also, the pace of operations threw him for a loop. He eventually made it through training after receiving additional instruction and multiple check rides. However, once he made it out on the line he just couldn't keep up. After many complaints from his captains he is no longer employed here. Unfortunate, because the guy was a class act.

In the late nineties my airline had an Express operation in Orlando that operated on a b-scale. It was not unusual for new-hires to hold captain during their first year down there. So, many took the upgrade but, because they were still on probation if they failed then they were terminated. Quite a few guys fell into this. One specific person that comes to mind was a Marine Harrier pilot. His instrument skills were sorely lacking. He barely made it through new-hire training and could not get through upgrade.

I know it sounds like I am picking on fighter guys but honestly, I personally do not know of any military transport guys that have washed out. Although, I am sure that they exist. I also know of just as many civilian guys that have washed out. Their backgrounds are pretty varied. However, most were turboprop to jet transitions.

Military flight training is second to none...whether the person makes the pilot or not, the training by Uncle Sam is not equaled in the civilian world.
I mostly agree. The only drawback is that the students are only taught one way to fly when there many, many ways. However, the airlines also want us to only fly one way as well really making that moot point. Also, a lot of the major pilot mills teach the same way.

I am a big proponent of being as well rounded as possible. I think that comes more from the desire of the individual than the specific training, though. The onus is on the pilot to seek out knowledge rather than to be, for lack of a better phrase, spoon fed. Military vs. Civilian has no bearing here.
 
When I jumpsat on an Airtran 737 the Captain said military new-hires are way behind the airplane compared to Regional Capt new-hires. He said visual approaches was a big problem spot.
 
I know it sounds like I am picking on fighter guys but honestly, I personally do not know of any military transport guys that have washed out. Although, I am sure that they exist. I also know of just as many civilian guys that have washed out. Their backgrounds are pretty varied. However, most were turboprop to jet transitions.

.

I think a lot of that has to do with the tanker/transport guys being used to the crew concept....the fighter guys have had to do everything by themselves for their entire flying career and making that jump can be difficult...
 
When I jumpsat on an Airtran 737 the Captain said military new-hires are way behind the airplane compared to Regional Capt new-hires. He said visual approaches was a big problem spot.

What exactly is the problem on visual approaches?
 
I think a lot of that has to do with the tanker/transport guys being used to the crew concept....the fighter guys have had to do everything by themselves for their entire flying career and making that jump can be difficult...

Agreed. I think that the guys that have spent their entire career flying single-seat have the hardest transition. But, it is probably a very small percentage that do not end up doing well.

The closest civilian equivalent that I can think of are the guys that fly crop-dusters, banner tow, pipeline, etc. for years and years. I figure that although they might be fantastic pilots with gobs of experience the transition to airline style crew concepts could also be difficult.
 
Me, learning to fly for first time flying with the "crew concept" (and with an instructor who wasn't used to flying with pointy-nosed fighter dudes, so a few minor instructional points were left out of the preflight brief):

Ready for takeoff:

Me: "Why do you want me to my hands on the throttle quadrant? You're the pilot flying...are your hands so weak that you can't set the throttles yourself and ensure they stay there throughout the takeoff roll?"

...shortly after rotation...

Me: "What? You want ME to put the gear handle up?"

....a few seconds later...

Me: "You've got a mic switch...why can't you call departure yourself? Can't fly and talk at the same time?"

It's not too terribly tough to learn crew coordination, but making it a habit pattern after thousands of cycles having to do it all yourself is a challenge.

On the other hand, put one of those guys raised to do things the crew way in a single seat fighter AND leading 3 other jets around and see how they do.
 
Me, learning to fly for first time flying with the "crew concept" (and with an instructor who wasn't used to flying with pointy-nosed fighter dudes, so a few minor instructional points were left out of the preflight brief):

Ready for takeoff:

Me: "Why do you want me to my hands on the throttle quadrant? You're the pilot flying...are your hands so weak that you can't set the throttles yourself and ensure they stay there throughout the takeoff roll?"

...shortly after rotation...

Me: "What? You want ME to put the gear handle up?"

....a few seconds later...

Me: "You've got a mic switch...why can't you call departure yourself? Can't fly and talk at the same time?"

It's not too terribly tough to learn crew coordination, but making it a habit pattern after thousands of cycles having to do it all yourself is a challenge.

On the other hand, put one of those guys raised to do things the crew way in a single seat fighter AND leading 3 other jets around and see how they do.

You are absolutely correct. The inverse is also probably true. But, I will still stick with my theory that the individual makes the pilot, not his background. If a pilot is highly motivated and also has the aptitude then he/she can be trained do fly anything. I suppose most folks ultimately believe that as well.
 
Me, learning to fly for first time flying with the "crew concept" (and with an instructor who wasn't used to flying with pointy-nosed fighter dudes, so a few minor instructional points were left out of the preflight brief):

Ready for takeoff:

Me: "Why do you want me to my hands on the throttle quadrant? You're the pilot flying...are your hands so weak that you can't set the throttles yourself and ensure they stay there throughout the takeoff roll?"

...shortly after rotation...

Me: "What? You want ME to put the gear handle up?"

....a few seconds later...

Me: "You've got a mic switch...why can't you call departure yourself? Can't fly and talk at the same time?"

It's not too terribly tough to learn crew coordination, but making it a habit pattern after thousands of cycles having to do it all yourself is a challenge.

On the other hand, put one of those guys raised to do things the crew way in a single seat fighter AND leading 3 other jets around and see how they do.
See, freight dawgs are by far much less bad ass than pointy nosed types, but that sounds very familiar to when I first got into the crew thing.
 
The military and the regionals are completely different ways to get to that mythical major job. If you want flying, the military is kind of like taking the scenic route to get there 12 hours later whereas the regionals is the direct route in traffic. Another words, very different. If you want to get to a major job, I'd stick civilian. Too many things can go wrong in your path to get that pilot spot in the mil, it's a life choice more than a job.
 
You are absolutely correct. The inverse is also probably true. But, I will still stick with my theory that the individual makes the pilot, not his background. If a pilot is highly motivated and also has the aptitude then he/she can be trained do fly anything. I suppose most folks ultimately believe that as well.

I certainly think this is true but the experience that one receives in the military flying is what separates them from the average civilian pilot.
 
That means failing training and either being fired or asked to leave the company.

I am not going to list their names but, they come from all branches.

Sorry, didn't mean their name but community. You listed good examples.

There was a USAF F-16 guy in an earlier class than mine at my current airline that washed out during IOE. The exact reasons are only rumor but, I do know he was not easy to get along with and thought that he was better than everyone else when the inverse was true.

My training partner was also an F-16 guy. He struggled very hard throughout training. Stick and rudder was not a problem with him but, it was all of the automation that gave him a hard time. Also, the pace of operations threw him for a loop. He eventually made it through training after receiving additional instruction and multiple check rides. However, once he made it out on the line he just couldn't keep up. After many complaints from his captains he is no longer employed here. Unfortunate, because the guy was a class act.

In the late nineties my airline had an Express operation in Orlando that operated on a b-scale. It was not unusual for new-hires to hold captain during their first year down there. So, many took the upgrade but, because they were still on probation if they failed then they were terminated. Quite a few guys fell into this. One specific person that comes to mind was a Marine Harrier pilot. His instrument skills were sorely lacking. He barely made it through new-hire training and could not get through upgrade.

I know it sounds like I am picking on fighter guys but honestly, I personally do not know of any military transport guys that have washed out. Although, I am sure that they exist. I also know of just as many civilian guys that have washed out. Their backgrounds are pretty varied. However, most were turboprop to jet transitions.

I mostly agree. The only drawback is that the students are only taught one way to fly when there many, many ways. However, the airlines also want us to only fly one way as well really making that moot point. Also, a lot of the major pilot mills teach the same way.

I am a big proponent of being as well rounded as possible. I think that comes more from the desire of the individual than the specific training, though. The onus is on the pilot to seek out knowledge rather than to be, for lack of a better phrase, spoon fed. Military vs. Civilian has no bearing here.

What I see is attitude can be a problem...which is specifically why the two fella's I mentioned lost their wings. Then going from single seat to multi-crew concept can certainly be an issue for some pilots. Flying a certain way for an entire career then changing could be a road block. That does make sense.

I agree on being well rounded but I don't see any civilian training and experience equaling what the military brings in terms of what I've already mentioned.
 
The prior time absolutely helped me in instruments, fams, and in primary. I guess the difficult part initially was just thinking at a minimum of 250 kts most of the time, and getting used to dynamic flying and all the training rules that go along with it. Perhaps "bad habits" isn't the term, but I found that I really needed to speed my brain up and start thinking much farther ahead of the aircraft (if I had a bad habit as a civilian, it was complacency)

I can see that. I remember going from the T-34C/T-44A to the T-2C and trying to stay ahead of the aircraft. Granted, I had only 30 hours prior flight time and that lasted until FAM-3 (what it was called in the old days :D). Hell, I'm worried when I go to Kingsville in August as I've flown nothing but slow turbo props since 1996 or so :o Granted, the COD could easily go 300KIAS but that was about it...maybe 320KIAS on a cold day straight and level.
 
I agree on being well rounded but I don't see any civilian training and experience equaling what the military brings in terms of what I've already mentioned.

Are we comparing apples to apples here? If so, let's use this real world example: Legacy Airlines is hiring. They hire a bunch of fighter guys with 2000 hours on average, a bunch of tanker/transport guys with about 3500 hours and 1000 as AC and, a bunch of 121 RJ guys with about 7000 hours and 2000 as captain. On average, who do you think will have the easier time in initial training?

I'll go ahead and give you the answer: it doesn't matter. After six months flying the line they will all be indistinguishable.

Now, if you want to compare just the training (from zero to hero so to speak) then yes, I agree that military training is superior if you want to be a military pilot. But, if you want to be an Alaskan bush pilot I would think that a civilian route would be better. I have seen far too many different ways to fly an airplane to say one way is superior to another.

Now, saying all of that if I were king of the world I would make a dedicated and separate Airline Training Program for new pilots similar to UPT. So, if a guy wants to be an airline pilot he first applies then gets accepted into the ATP. First is a private course in a C172 or similar then after that everything would be in Kingairs, Citations, etc. Once the guy got to the commercial ticket he would go out and fly VFR 135 freight, then multi-crew IFR freight. After a few years of that then onto pax opsand the usual progression. Basically, a standardized track.
 
Are we comparing apples to apples here? If so, let's use this real world example: Legacy Airlines is hiring. They hire a bunch of fighter guys with 2000 hours on average, a bunch of tanker/transport guys with about 3500 hours and 1000 as AC and, a bunch of 121 RJ guys with about 7000 hours and 2000 as captain. On average, who do you think will have the easier time in initial training?

That's because it's easy...it's straight and level flying, shooting approaches, etc. If a military type with 2000 hours is having a tough time with that sort of training, he has issues no doubt. Can't compare that to the dynamic flying of fighter types, carrier landings day or night (especially night), formation flying, etc. That type of flying in the military is tougher for a reason and thus so is the training. That's where I'm coming from. The background is tougher, no competition between the two.

I'll go ahead and give you the answer: it doesn't matter. After six months flying the line they will all be indistinguishable.

That's becaus it isn't difficult flying, it's bland, straight and level stuff. Any pilot should be able to hack that.

Now, if you want to compare just the training (from zero to hero so to speak) then yes, I agree that military training is superior if you want to be a military pilot. But, if you want to be an Alaskan bush pilot I would think that a civilian route would be better. I have seen far too many different ways to fly an airplane to say one way is superior to another.

Are we talking about being Alaskan Bush pilots now? Bush pilots have their attributes no doubt but that is probably due more to the experience of flying in that sort of environment. They certainly fly in a dynamic environment which is nothing like flying the straight and level sky's of the airlines. It still changes nothing in that military flight training is second to none. The type of flying, the challenge, the competition, etc, is not going to be had on the outside. Just the way it is.
 
Back
Top