Magnus Effect

Inverted25

Well-Known Member
This question is aimed at TGrayson but anyone else who has an answer chime in. Could someone explain to me how the Magnus Effect works with an airfoil. I understand that in the Magnus Effect ans objects rotation affects the flow of fluid(air in this case) over it. But a wing is stationary. Or am I missing something?
 
Could someone explain to me how the Magnus Effect works with an airfoil. I understand that in the Magnus Effect ans objects rotation affects the flow of fluid(air in this case) over it. But a wing is stationary. Or am I missing something?

It's really more of an analogy than a real explanation for how the wing operates. The rotating cylinder corresponds to the theoretical bound vortex that is attached to the wing span. The bound vortex increases the velocity of the air above the wing and decreases it below the wing, just as a rotating cylinder would do.

See here.
 
OK so heres my next question. If AOA is what causes the bound vortex and creates the pressure difference, than why is a wing cambered? I was always lead to beleive the whole theroy that by having a longer surface to travel over the top of the wing causes the air to speed up because both the top and bottom particules of air have to meet at the same time. Now I understand from a previous discussion that the particules actually dont meet up at the back of the wing, so than what is the real purpose of the camber in a wing. I always doubted the whole theory behind that because aerobatic airplanes i have flown are sysemtrical yet still fly. So is there any real reason for the most GA planes not to have sysmetrical wings?
 
So is there any real reason for the most GA planes not to have sysmetrical wings?

Clmax is lower for a symmetrical wing. Clmax is limited by the stall and the stall is caused by the boundary layer trying (and failing) to overcome an area of increasing pressure on the top of the wing. The larger the section of the wing that contains accelerating air and the smaller that contains decelerating air, the more resistant the airfoil is to a stall. In general, the area of accelerating air is the section of the airfoil before the "hump" and the decelerating is after it.

You generally only use symmetrical wings when the airfoil will have equal requirements for lift in both directions: aerobatic airplanes' main wing, horizontal stabilizers (but not always), and vertical stabilizers.
 
I would say that the majority of lift comes from the Newton's 3rd law. Hell, you can make a brick fly with enough force behind it.
 
You generally only use symmetrical wings when the airfoil will have equal requirements for lift in both directions: aerobatic airplanes' main wing, horizontal stabilizers (but not always), and vertical stabilizers.

Many jets/high performance birds have relatively symmetrical airfoils also. Not perfectly symmetrical, as you know, but far closer to it than any trainer. The reason is drag.


OP:

Personally, I wouldn't worry so much about magnus/coanda effects. Magnus correlates well with why a wing produces lift, IE faster air on top and slower on the bottom. However, as you pointed out, it isn't so much a factor for a non-rotating object.

Correct me if I am wrong tgray, but I am fairly certain that even the air in the rear of the wing attempts to reverse flow toward the lower pressure. This is especially present as you get nearer to stall AOA. The point is, air doesn't uniformly circle around the wing. It just tries to do what any air in the world does, move from high pressure areas to fill in lower pressure areas.
 
I would say that the majority of lift comes from the Newton's 3rd law. Hell, you can make a brick fly with enough force behind it.

Ugh... I hope someone just posts the links to the threads where this was discussed in depth! Wish FAA would put some QA into GA flight training!
 
Ugh... I hope someone just posts the links to the threads where this was discussed in depth! Wish FAA would put some QA into GA flight training!

Well if it's on an internet forum it's gotta be true :clap:

On a serious note, I do believe that the 3rd Law has a role to play, as does Bernoulli, the Magnus Effect, etc. All I'm saying is that I don't think there is one single theory solely responsible for the creation of lift. Also engineers have a way of making things more complicated than they need to be, hence the propagation of the Bernoulli theory, it must be right b/c it sounds right.
 
Well if it's on an internet forum it's gotta be true :clap:

On a serious note, I do believe that the 3rd Law has a role to play, as does Bernoulli, the Magnus Effect, etc. All I'm saying is that I don't think there is one single theory solely responsible for the creation of lift. Also engineers have a way of making things more complicated than they need to be, hence the propagation of the Bernoulli theory, it must be right b/c it sounds right.

On a serious note, there is one, single theory on lift, unless you are talking hypersonic high altitude stuff. Do a search in the tech forum, as this has been explained in depth. As I said, General Aviation training is awful on teaching aero. I meant it.
 
On a serious note, there is one, single theory on lift,

Seagull, he already knows everything there is to know on the subject and thinks those who claim to know more are full of hot air, including all the aeronautical engineers who have lived over the past 100 years. You know, those people who design and build airplanes, the ones who only assume the underlying theory is correct without any empirical evidence.

I recommend we let the thread die.;)
 
Back
Top