Logging Time

Seems what alot of people do is just write it in later...hence 3 years later I did mine lol.

I don't see how you could log PIC in the HP/ complex unless it's something like a CFI flying with someone who is qualified for the a/c.
Sorry we are giving you grief, but this subject has been covered so many times on this website (and others), it still amazes some of the old timers that there are still CFIs out there who do not understand the regulation and legal interpretations. In addition to the hook Poser765 threw you about loggin PIC during HP/Complex training, you may also log as PIC ALL instrument training as PIC as long as you are "rated" in the category and class of airplane being used- even in IMC conditions. Remember, there is a difference between acting as PIC and logging PIC time.
"Section 61.51 (e) governs the logging of PIC time and states, in relevant part, that a sport,
recreational, private, or commercial pilot may log PIC time for the time during which that
pilot is "the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which the pilot is rated or has
privileges." The term "rated," as used in section 61.51 (e), refers to the pilot holding the
appropriate aircraft ratings (category, class, and type, if a type rating is required), and these
ratings are listed in 14 C.F.R. § 61.5 and are placed on the pilot certificate. See
Interpretation to James R. Knight II (June 3, 1999). Sections 61.31(e) and (f) establish
additional training and endorsement requirements before acting as a PIC of a complex or
high-performance airplane, respectively. Although these endorsements are required before a
pilot may act as a PIC of a high-performance and/or complex airplane, they are not required
to log PIC time if the pilot is rated for and is the sole manipulator of the controls of the
aircraft.
There is a distinction between logging PIC time and acting as a PIC. For a pilot to log PIC
time (i.e., the sole manipulator of the controls), a pilot must be properly rated in the aircraft
by having the appropriate category, class, and type ratings. For a pilot to act as a PIC (i.e.,
the pilot who has final authority and responsibility for the operation and safety of the flight),
a pilot must be properly rated in the aircraft and be properly rated and authorized to conduct
the flight. In your example, being properly rated and authorized would include having the endorsements
for complex and high-performance airplanes as required by sections 61.31 (e) and (t). Accordingly,
in your examples, the pilot may log PIC time if that pilot is properly rated for the aircraft flown even
though that pilot does not have the required endorsements to act as a PIC."
http://www.faa.gov/about/office_org...c200/interpretations/data/interps/2009/Herman.
As for not signing a logbook and being in violation of 61.189:
http://www.ntsb.gov/legal/o_n_o/docs/Aviation/5213.pdf
"We agree with the law judge’s reasoning and conclusionthat the statutory and regulatory authority of the FAA allows the Administrator to take certificate action against a flight instructor for failing to sign a student’s logbook."
 
Sorry we are giving you grief, but this subject has been covered so many times on this website (and others), it still amazes some of the old timers that there are still CFIs out there who do not understand the regulation and legal interpretations.
Fortunately, this has been discussed often enough that the arguments over it have diminished. But there are still many folks out there, especially CFIs and flight schools that don't understand the basics of 61.51 as officially interpreted by the FAA to more than 30 years.

You pulled some of the more recent re-statements from the FAA. This one is from a Chief Counsel opinion back in 1980 in the context of flight instruction:

==============================
You request interpretations of these regulations for situations in which:

1. The purpose of the flight is instruction in advanced maneuvers.

2. The purpose of the flight is simulated instrument instruction in actual VFR conditions.

3. The purpose of the flight is instrument instruction actual IFR conditions.

4. The pilot in the left seat is not current in the aircraft or in the conditions of flight.

5. The purpose of the flight is transition from tricycle to conventional landing gear.

6. The purpose of the flight is obtaining logbook endorsement authorizing operation of a high performance aircraft, as required by FAR 61.31(e).

7. The purpose of the flight is transition to a different type aircraft of the same category and class for which the left seat pilot is rated and a type rating is not required.

In each situation, the CFI may log PIC time for all flight time during which she or he acts as flight instructor. The pilot receiving instruction may also log PIC time in each of these situations, as the pilot is the sole manipulator of the controls of an aircraft for which she or he is rated. Specifically, neither the currency requirements of situation 4 nor the log book endorsement of situation 6 are ratings within the meaning of Section 61.51. "Rating" as used in that section refers to the rating in categories, classes, and types, as listed in Section 61.5, which are placed on pilot certificates.
==============================
If it helps anyone, I have a summary of the rules on my website. http://www.midlifeflight.com/faq/faq.php?s=1#2
 
Midlife, I have had the pleasure of explaining, showing applicable regs, and showing chief council opinions and still have not been able to convince someone.
 
Midlife, I have had the pleasure of explaining, showing applicable regs, and showing chief council opinions and still have not been able to convince someone.
History has repeatedly (and unfortunately) shown that facts are rarely sufficient to overcome a firmly-held belief, no matter how erroneous.
 
Of course my students logged PIC. Your flight school owner can say whatever he pleases, but if the FAA allows your students to log PIC, you're only doing them a disservice by not allowing them to do so.
 
Of course my students logged PIC. Your flight school owner can say whatever he pleases, but if the FAA allows your students to log PIC, you're only doing them a disservice by not allowing them to do so.
My theory has always been that if you don't "allow" a pilot to log something legitimate and if logged it would have been countable toward a certificate or rating, you should offer to reimburse the pilot for the cost of having to do it over.

Example: Pilot needs 50 hours PIC cross country toward the instrument rating. During the course of a high performance transition, CFI and student do a cross country. But the CFI doesn't "believe" that the student should be "allowed" to log it as PIC until he has the endorsement. If the pilot needs to do another cross country flight to get to the 50, the CFI should pay for it.
 
Back
Top