Logging Time

spoolinup22

Well-Known Member
Fellow CFI's...

so we all know the regs, but I just want your honest opinions. do you let your students log PIC if they are rated for the airplane?
 
Fellow CFI's...

so we all know the regs, but I just want your honest opinions. do you let your students log PIC if they are rated for the airplane?
It is not my logbook it is the "student's" logbook. If a CFI tried to tell ME I could not log such time as PIC I would tell him/her to pound sand. If they then refused to sign my logbook my next call would be to a FSDO to report a violation of 61.189.
 
It is not my logbook it is the "student's" logbook. If a CFI tried to tell ME I could not log such time as PIC I would tell him/her to pound sand. If they then refused to sign my logbook my next call would be to a FSDO to report a violation of 61.189.

I would find a new CFI myself
 
My thought is that I was the one flying, my CFI was just there checking up on me. Legally I know I can't log PIC until I'm rated (so my private training was not PIC if my CFI was on board).

I let my students log PIC, I went back today and all of my "dual" after my private logged it PIC and Dual Received (except of course Multi, and HP/Complex until I passed/ had the sign-off)
 
Fellow CFI's...

so we all know the regs, but I just want your honest opinions. do you let your students log PIC if they are rated for the airplane?
Provided you know the regulations why on Earth would you NOT let your RATED student log PIC?
 
nervous about the feds/ airlines looking at your logbook and asking you about that?
No, a CFI who does not sign a logbook is in violation of 61.189. Such a CFI is so ignorant of the regulations (logging time, CFI records), that he/she should be reported.
 
Provided you know the regulations why on Earth would you NOT let your RATED student log PIC?

I don't have a problem with it, it's just a company I know of only lets the CFI log PIC because

a) more than likely (hopefully) the CFI has more hours
b) if there is an accident, the feds will come after the one with more hours
 
I don't have a problem with it, it's just a company I know of only lets the CFI log PIC because

a) more than likely (hopefully) the CFI has more hours
b) if there is an accident, the feds will come after the one with more hours
Hmm, strange logic from he company. Honestly I would just have the student sign my logbook then fill in the PIC later. I can't really see how a flight school can dictate how a student fills out their own logbook.

PS And just to stir the pot...you can log PIC in HP/complex without the endorsement.

Ready...FIGHT
 
Hmm, strange logic from he company. Honestly I would just have the student sign my logbook then fill in the PIC later. I can't really see how a flight school can dictate how a student fills out their own logbook.

PS And just to stir the pot...you can log PIC in HP/complex without the endorsement.

Ready...FIGHT

Seems what alot of people do is just write it in later...hence 3 years later I did mine lol.

I don't see how you could log PIC in the HP/ complex unless it's something like a CFI flying with someone who is qualified for the a/c.
 
Seems what alot of people do is just write it in later...hence 3 years later I did mine lol.

I don't see how you could log PIC in the HP/ complex unless it's something like a CFI flying with someone who is qualified for the a/c.
Man, I am about 20% trolling. I'll give you this one question then point you somewhere. Where does it say in the 14 CFR that you have to have a hp/complex to LOG pic in a hp/com airplane? Read carefully through 61.51 (hm think that's where it is) then go look at some of the chief council rulings on the FAA website.
 
Man, I am about 20% trolling. I'll give you this one question then point you somewhere. Where does it say in the 14 CFR that you have to have a hp/complex to LOG pic in a hp/com airplane? Read carefully through 61.51 (hm think that's where it is) then go look at some of the chief council rulings on the FAA website.
Got him hook, line and sinker.
 
I don't know what you, the CFI would be logging; but the student (as long as he is at least a private aka rated) SHOULD be logging PIC. Unless he wants to be a dodohead and give up perfectly legal PIC time.

If he's not yet a private, only when he's solo as we're all aware
 
My thought is that I was the one flying, my CFI was just there checking up on me. Legally I know I can't log PIC until I'm rated (so my private training was not PIC if my CFI was on board).

I let my students log PIC, I went back today and all of my "dual" after my private logged it PIC and Dual Received (except of course Multi, and HP/Complex until I passed/ had the sign-off)
You coulda still logged PIC for that unless it was part of multi training.

Edit: Whoops. Forgot to read the above posts before giving my input.
 
Back
Top