Jumpseater's Survivor Gets W/C Survivor Benefits

lostplanetairman

Well-Known Member
The KY Supreme Court reversed the lower court decision and allowed the survivor benefits for the AirTran pilot commuting from his home in Lexington, KY to work on the Comair flight that crashed on takeoff.

"Fortney’s wife and minor child sought survivors’ benefits. An administrative law judge denied the claim under the benefit to the employer exception to the going and coming rule, finding that AirTran’s free or reduced-fare arrangement benefited Fortney by allowing him to live where he chose but burdened AirTran. The Workers’ Compensation Board reversed, but the court of appeals then reinstated the decision denying benefits. Fortney’s family sought review to the state Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court reversed the denial of benefits. In analyzing the benefit or service to the employer exception to the going and coming rule, it explained that “the rule excluding injuries that occur off the employer’s premises, during travel between work and home, does not apply if the journey is part of the service for which the worker is employed or otherwise benefits the employer.”
The factors to be considered under the exception include not only whether there is a service or benefit to the employer but also whether the injured worker is paid for travel time—for performing work on the trip, traveling to a remote site, or traveling between job sites—and whether the worker is paid for the expense of travel. Payment for travel time brings the trip within the course of the employment, but the lack of payment does not exclude a trip from the course of employment.
“The fact that an employer uses transportation or transportation expense as an inducement to accept or continue employment is material to supporting compensability, particularly when the journey is sizeable and when the employer pays all or substantially all of the expense,” the court determined. “We note that such an inducement benefits the worker who accepts it and places a financial burden on the employer but also that the inducement benefits the employer when its purpose is accomplished. An employer is unlikely to provide such an inducement unless it views the resulting benefit as outweighing the burden.”
The court remanded the case for the consideration of other remaining issues.
Fortney v. AirTran Airways, Inc., Ky., No. 2009-SC-000429-WC (June 17, 2010)."
 
That'll set some good precedence - I wonder if the family of the non-rev Colgan CAPT will be able to utilize this (assuming they're trying to collect similar benefits)
 
I'm curious jtrain, what was the precedent before this? I can see both sides of this. He wasnt really at work, but was using company provided transportation to go to work, to make the company money.

Also, would this mean that if one were on their way to a job site in a company car, the same rule would apply?
 
He was an AirTran pilot, onboard a Comair plane.

That might be, but it was a company provided benefit and he was on the way to make the company money. A different tact: What if my company gave me a buss pass to get to work, and the bus crashed?
 
My company has given me a car to travel between different states... (and then was shocked when I couldn't do a full day because I had to duty on to start driving, but that is another story.)
 
That might be, but it was a company provided benefit and he was on the way to make the company money. A different tact: What if my company gave me a buss pass to get to work, and the bus crashed?

Actually, it's a union negotiated benefit...

That said, this guy was on his way TO work, for the betterment of AirTran.

Bottom line, this helps this family move on. Cheers to them for using the judicial system to it's fullest and not giving up.
 
Back
Top